I'm always willing to take a chance on a possible mountain banjo as long as it's not too pricey. I recently obtained what was described as a "homemade banjo like instrument," from the Seattle Goodwill. The pictures were typically fuzzy but I figured it could either be an "original" Watauga County instrument or a recently-made version based on the Foxfire books. Either way, I was interested. Upon receipt I am still puzzled: there are clues to support both premises. I hope someone will recognize it and contact me to clear it up.
At first glance it seems to be made of redwood but dings and scratches (and the innards upon disassembly) show the color is a stain. The squarish neck is a massive (26") log with straight, fine grain; at the "heel," roughly 5 1/2" from the pot, it is 2 7/16" wide and 1 13/16" thick. The banjer is 34 1/2" long with a 9" pot, the head being 6 1/8," which is roughly standard for Watauga Co. instruments. The three pieces of the pot are made from a rough plywood; the plies are 1/16" and 1/8" thick. The back of the pot has a round hole pattern with four smaller holes roughly in an X. The screws follow this design with an added screw at the bottom. There is also a plugged screw hole at the top, 12 o'clock, position (which would have been right behind the top screw on the front). The rear (5") long neck tab has three screws. The front/top section has four screws in a cross pattern with two extra screws: one to the left and right of the 12 o'clock screw. The front neck tab is 3" with three screws.
The dilemma I face is the attribution of the unmarked instrument. Most urban makers would have inscribed their names and my experience with such banjers is that they tend to hew quite closely to the Foxfire pattern or, on the other extreme, tend to want to show their individuality, with influences from modern banjos or flights of fancy. This instrument does neither; most of the elements are completely within the general tradition but there are enough distinctive touches to suggest a maker outside the usual family traditions: the unusual, but restrained, peghead design is such an element. The two (and a half) remaining pegs, as well as the nut seem to be made of the same wood, perhaps hickory. The exciting, and frustrating, thing about history (and collecting) is that one never has enough information; it's as if Clio were the origin of the phrase, "always leave them wanting more."
[See pix in the folder "Seattle Mt Banjer"]4 comments
cbcarlisle has 26 friends. View entire friends list.
RG posted a forum topic 'TOTW 5 March 2021 Rose Conley (Down in the Willow Garden)' 1 day
Playing Since: 1957
Experience Level: Purty Good
BANJOS, FRETLESS: Riley Baugus (Cold Mt); 4 Anon.19thC. flushfret, Buckbee flushfret, Lyon & Healey 7-string flushfret; Fairbanks & Cole fretless; 5 Cubley; several Anon.19thC. fretless; Homer Ledford mt. style; 2 Bell (Boucher), Bell (Stichter), Bob Flesher (Boucher); Eric Prust tackhead, 2 Nate Calkins tackhead, Anon. tackhead.
WATAUGA COUNTY-type Mountain banjos: 2 Frank Proffitt; 2 Frank Proffitt, Jr.; Leonard Glenn; John Peterson; Nate Calkins; Dick Gilman; John Huron; Richard Smith; J. Waller; Jim Brandenburg; rebuilt Stoney End; antique Anonymous (Winston-Salem NC); old Anon. (Kingsport TN); old Anon. (Greene Cty TN); old Anon. (NYC), 2 self-made.
SELF-MADE: William Sydney Mount copy, mountain banjers, Shaker box banjer, fiddle case banjer, gourd banjers [see my banjer website].
BANJO, Fretted: hand-made 19th cent. Anonymous (1870-90, VA-NC); Henry Curtis.
OTHER: hammered dulcimer; mountain dulcimer; autoharp; jew's harp; mouth organ.
Frank Proffitt, Stu Jamieson, Eck Robertson, Luther Strong, Sam Hinton, Guillaume de Machaut, Roscoe Holcomb, Uncle Dave Macon, Wade Ward, Sergei Prokofiev, Doc Watson, Clarence Ashley, Almeda Riddle
Classified Rating: not rated
Rate this Member
Visible to: Public
Last Visit 9/13/2020
I's born in Kentucky, Raised in Tennessee, If you don't like my music, Don't shake my tree; Look down the road, Far as you can see, I'm gone to Californy, With my banjer on my knee.
'C tunes' 3 hrs