DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online banjo teacher.
Weekly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, banjo news and more.
Page: First Page 1 2 3 4 5 Next Page Last Page (5)
Brendan, I was not intending to be in any way cryptic. Though it may read that way. We see versions of this same ‘comparative difficulty’ debate from time to time.
A perspective of interest primarily in the banjo itself, rather than restricted specifically its role within the conventions of bluegrass or old time, would be far more informative in relation to creative range and technical difficulty.
The banjo in a finger-style context (modern or historical) offers exactly this meaningful comparison. Yet finger-style does not feature even when the specific subject of a technical comparison of banjo playing arises.
I’m aware that complexity does not equate to ‘better’; simplicity is often the holy grail sought by creatives in many fields. But it is rather perverse that any discussion relating to technical difficulty and the banjo, omits or is unaware of, finger-style playing that historically and consistently demonstrates greater demands on a player's technique and ability.
I first learned to play three-finger Scruggs or bluegrass. I'm a long-time OT clawhammer player. I also play fingerstyle. Fair to say that is a relevant breadth to have gained a perspective. A debate on banjo comparative difficulty without reference to fingerstyle is a bit like a debate on board games that focus on snakes and ladders and draughts (checkers) but ignores chess.
Edited by - EEB on 09/12/2026 16:00:07
EEB I think you must have quite a rare perspective, being conversant with that many styles. Personally, I took to finger style quite naturally but found clawhammer quite awkward. My hands didn’t want to do what was required. When I hear someone like Allison de Groot playing, I am flabbergasted at the skill involved. I don’t hear a lot of jazz or classical played with clawhammer though. I’m sure someone has tried.
quote:
Originally posted by Laurence DiehlEEB I think you must have quite a rare perspective, being conversant with that many styles. Personally, I took to finger style quite naturally but found clawhammer quite awkward. My hands didn’t want to do what was required. When I hear someone like Allison de Groot playing, I am flabbergasted at the skill involved. I don’t hear a lot of jazz or classical played with clawhammer though. I’m sure someone has tried.
Maybe that serves to highlight? The two techniques that today are generally presented and understood as if the only 5-string choice, are actually each the result of stylistic convention that is a cultural feature.
Yet beyond that dominant cultural assumption exists the scope of the banjo as a musical instrument independent of that narrow cultural convention. The banjo in a fingerstyle-style context has a broader history; critically a far wider geographic base and consequently is largely independent of cultural insularity and its associated stylistic convention - in much the same way as say, the violin or acoustic guitar.
This observation is prompted by a sub-text that emerged here. I don't wish to hijack an interesting thread. Maybe another thread could pick up this theme?
Edited by - EEB on 09/12/2026 23:49:19
The banjo in a fingerstyle-style context is almost non-existent today, perhaps because few want to hear the music associated with that style. I understand the difference between technique and repertoire but with the banjo the two are intertwined. If anyone today wants to learn a versatile instrument capable of playing a wide variety of music; they are very unlikely to choose banjo as their instrument. Other instruments are more suited to that role than the banjo. New banjo players today are drawn by the unique sound of the banjo playing one of the two styles heard today. That is two very different sounds, and techniques. Classic fingerstyle is not associated with any music that is very popular today, and does not produce a sound that motivates new players to say "I want to learn to do THAT."
Does this need to devolve into the ad nauseam “this or that” which is better/ which is harder contest?
My general problem with “clawhammer” as it currently exists is the ridged and fixed “bum ditty” pattern which things must be forced to fit in or around. A recent post even has a guy teaching phantom strikes where you continue the pattern but just don’t strike strings.
Why not just play the notes needed? Why the constant repetition of “bum ditty”?
Where is the economy of motion?
quote:
Originally posted by banjo bill-eThe banjo in a fingerstyle-style context is almost non-existent today, perhaps because few want to hear the music associated with that style. I understand the difference between technique and repertoire but with the banjo the two are intertwined. If anyone today wants to learn a versatile instrument capable of playing a wide variety of music; they are very unlikely to choose banjo as their instrument. Other instruments are more suited to that role than the banjo. New banjo players today are drawn by the unique sound of the banjo playing one of the two styles heard today. That is two very different sounds, and techniques. Classic fingerstyle is not associated with any music that is very popular today, and does not produce a sound that motivates new players to say "I want to learn to do THAT."
The automatic assumption forming the basis of your post perfectly illustrates the negative effect - in practical playing terms - that results from the artificial and arbitrary 'classic' designation.
'Classic' relates to a niche group, first self-titled in the 1950's, whose special interest is only (selective) historical playing and repertoire. This group has no input in regard to modern composition. A consequence of this inherently retrospective focus is the misconception of the historical as a technique.
This misconception is, subject to any analysis, nonsensical. There is no reason that finger-style technique equates to playing or composing as if we are a frozen-in-time 1900 banjoist. Yet this thoughtless deceit has been unwittingly absorbed by the modern banjo community as evidenced by Bill's post.
The simple reality is that the mimetic repetition of historical playing and repertoire is a niche special interest. Fingerstyle is a technique. The two have no necessary association.
The creative harm is caused when ignorance and neglect is perpetuated by this false construct.
Edited by - EEB on 09/13/2026 10:21:44
quote:
Originally posted by Joel HooksDoes this need to devolve into the ad nauseam “this or that” which is better/ which is harder contest?
When 'the ad nauseum this or that' routinely neglects a technique that proper recognition and comparison would actually be meaningful, that perpetuates both misinformation and neglect. That negative mechanism is then unavoidably relevant.
I have no problem with clawhammer or three-finger pick techniques. They have a profile and a place I do however, take issue with any culture or mechanism that excludes through ignorance.
Edited by - EEB on 09/13/2026 10:37:17
quote:
Originally posted by Joel HooksDoes this need to devolve into the ad nauseam “this or that” which is better/ which is harder contest?
My general problem with “clawhammer” as it currently exists is the ridged and fixed “bum ditty” pattern which things must be forced to fit in or around. A recent post even has a guy teaching phantom strikes where you continue the pattern but just don’t strike strings.
Why not just play the notes needed? Why the constant repetition of “bum ditty”?
Where is the economy of motion?
Bum ditty is a subset of clawhammer, not the style. Double-thumbing more accurately describes clawhammer.
The m-skip (what you're calling a phantom strike) is akin to a hammer-on, pull-off, slide, or bend. In other words, just an embellishment (and a nice one at that - it allows for some interesting syncopation).
I rarely play the bum-ditty stroke these days, but it has its own rhythm and value.
Now, I'm not a fan of old time music, which most clawhammer seems to depend on. There seems to be few people interested in exploring the sonic potential of the five-string banjo.
Joel,
My post was really about why Clawhammer didn't have chords or the same name not wich was best. The bum ditty is really just an accompaniment to the melody of the song and just evolved is all. Your distaste for the style is noted..Jack
Originally posted by JoelDoes this need to devolve into the ad nauseam “this or that” which is better/ which is harder contest?
My general problem with “clawhammer” as it currently exists is the ridged and fixed “bum ditty” pattern which things must be forced to fit in or around. A recent post even has a guy teaching phantom strikes where you continue the pattern but just don’t strike strings.
Why not just play the notes needed? Why the constant repetition of “bum ditty”?
Where is the economy of motion?
Edited by - Jack Baker on 09/13/2026 13:25:08
What I consider the guitar style or what my hero Joel Hooks would call the classic style are central techniques to banjo playing which are of fundamental importance. It is pretty silly to deny that or look at, especially since the most prominent form of banjo playing today, Bluegrass banjo playing really is a subset spawned by people knowledgeable of that style.
quote:
Originally posted by writerradWhat I consider the guitar style or what my hero Joel Hooks would call the classic style are central techniques to banjo playing which are of fundamental importance. It is pretty silly to deny that or look at, especially since the most prominent form of banjo playing today, Bluegrass banjo playing really is a subset spawned by people knowledgeable of that style.
Classic Banjo has a singular focus on somewhat selective historical repertoire. Fine as a special interest historical interest group; but sadly there is nil engagement with contemporary composition or finger-style/guitar-style that falls outside this rigidly insular focus. Like it or not, this contrived historical insularity - presented as if representative of fingerstyle/guitarstyle as a technique - functions, incorrectly, to frame the technique as an obsolescent form or relic. That the technique lacks the contemporary parity of a sign-posted space on the hangout is directly symptomatic of that distorting effect on public consciousness. If in any doubt, scroll back and read Bill's previous post for a 'from the horse's mouth' example of this confused, distorting effect.
Platitudes simply don't stand up faced with a manifest and describable culture of ignorance.
Edited by - EEB on 09/13/2026 16:00:50
quote:
Originally posted by Jack BakerJoel,My post was really about why Clawhammer didn't have chords or the same name not wich was best. The bum ditty is really just an accompaniment to the melody of the song and just evolved is all. Your distaste for the style is noted..JackOriginally posted by JoelDoes this need to devolve into the ad nauseam “this or that” which is better/ which is harder contest?
My general problem with “clawhammer” as it currently exists is the ridged and fixed “bum ditty” pattern which things must be forced to fit in or around. A recent post even has a guy teaching phantom strikes where you continue the pattern but just don’t strike strings.
Why not just play the notes needed? Why the constant repetition of “bum ditty”?
Where is the economy of motion?
Well I'm glad you know what I like or dislike (you are wrong BTW).
I devote countless hours to studying stroke style and put in time every week with thimble and Frank Converse's combination and hammer strike exercises and patterns. I'm a huge fan of stroke style.
Edited by - Joel Hooks on 09/13/2026 15:46:33
quote:
Originally posted by EEBquote:
Originally posted by writerradWhat I consider the guitar style or what my hero Joel Hooks would call the classic style are central techniques to banjo playing which are of fundamental importance. It is pretty silly to deny that or look at, especially since the most prominent form of banjo playing today, Bluegrass banjo playing really is a subset spawned by people knowledgeable of that style.
Classic Banjo has a singular focus on somewhat selective historical repertoire. Fine as a special interest historical interest group; but sadly there is nil engagement with contemporary composition or finger-style/guitar-style that falls outside this rigidly insular focus. Like it or not, this contrived historical insularity - presented as if representative of fingerstyle/guitarstyle as a technique - functions, incorrectly, to frame the technique as an obsolescent form or relic. That the technique lacks the contemporary parity of a sign-posted space on the hangout is directly symptomatic of that distorting effect on public consciousness.
Platitudes simply don't stand up faced with a manifest and describable culture of ignorance.
I'm glad you have it all figured out..
Don't judge a living tradition by a single low participation message board.
quote:
Originally posted by Joel Hooksquote:
Originally posted by EEBquote:
Originally posted by writerradWhat I consider the guitar style or what my hero Joel Hooks would call the classic style are central techniques to banjo playing which are of fundamental importance. It is pretty silly to deny that or look at, especially since the most prominent form of banjo playing today, Bluegrass banjo playing really is a subset spawned by people knowledgeable of that style.
Classic Banjo has a singular focus on somewhat selective historical repertoire. Fine as a special interest historical interest group; but sadly there is nil engagement with contemporary composition or finger-style/guitar-style that falls outside this rigidly insular focus. Like it or not, this contrived historical insularity - presented as if representative of fingerstyle/guitarstyle as a technique - functions, incorrectly, to frame the technique as an obsolescent form or relic. That the technique lacks the contemporary parity of a sign-posted space on the hangout is directly symptomatic of that distorting effect on public consciousness.
Platitudes simply don't stand up faced with a manifest and describable culture of ignorance.
I'm glad you have it all figured out..
Don't judge a living tradition by a single low participation message board.
That response might have credibility if the 'message board' in question (actually a multi-page website complete with black-face gallery) didn't assert in oracle-like fashion as a 'What is...' and 'How to...' even giving the impression that dressing up in a suit and bow tie is in some way relevant to playing finger-style/guitar-style technique in 2026. There is a total void where 'living tradition' or more importantly continuity of technique could be actively encouraged and supported (and that's the honest appraisal of someone with the passion and motivation to help provide that support).
Edited by - EEB on 09/13/2026 16:36:44
You do excellent work altruistically sharing primary sources, making them accessible and usable by scanning and placing them in the public domain where they belong. But ‘Classic Banjo’ continues to be blighted by those few who treat what is everyone's heritage as private property.
Edited by - EEB on 09/13/2026 16:50:41
Well I'm glad you know what I like or dislike (you are wrong BTW).
I devote countless hours to studying stroke style and put in time every week with thimble and Frank Converse's combination and hammer strike exercises and patterns. I'm a huge fan of stroke style
Good to hear Joel, sorry I was dead wrong; I'm still learning banjo.....J
Originally posted by Joel Hooksquote:
Edited by - Jack Baker on 09/13/2026 17:18:38
Joel,
Now I know why I don't usually subscribe to these posts. You are only concerned with being the most correct and brilliant. I taught Classical Composition at NYU in NYC for 35 years and never thought I was as brilliant and all knowing as you seems to think you are....Please grow to adulthood Joel and we will be the best of friends...I am not trying to best you--get over it I beg you....Jack Baker pps. If this nonsense doesn't stop I promise that I will leave BHL forever--not an idle threat. I don't think you would mind at all....SO SO SAD pps. We should all love and support each other but it is rarely that way anymore
"De gustibus non est disputandum,"
Edited by - Jack Baker on 09/13/2026 21:40:39
Personally I’d be happy to civilly continue a discussion elsewhere on finger-style as a technique. How a very straightforward and neutral coexistence as a technique, alongside other banjo techniques is, perhaps unwittingly, marginalised and distorted by it's modern designation and portrayal as ‘Classic Banjo’.
Again, I have no wish to further hijack the original interesting OP.
My own involvement with early banjo is quite specifically and seperately as part of a cultural research project. I would be saddened if this work was misconstrued as further associating finger-style technique as a historical 'curiosity'. Research and finger-style as a technique are two entirely different things.
Edited by - EEB on 09/14/2026 00:51:28
quote:
Originally posted by Jack BakerJoel,
Now I know why I don't usually subscribe to these posts. You are only concerned with being the most correct and brilliant. I taught Classical Composition at NYU in NYC for 35 years and never thought I was as brilliant and all knowing as you seems to think you are....Please grow to adulthood Joel and we will be the best of friends...I am not trying to best you--get over it I beg you....Jack Baker pps. If this nonsense doesn't stop I promise that I will leave BHL forever--not an idle threat. I don't think you would mind at all....SO SO SAD pps. We should all love and support each other but it is rarely that way anymore"De gustibus non est disputandum,"
You are an interesting fellow. I am not sure where you are getting these presumptions about me.
You presume I don't like clawhammer banjo. That was incorrect. I guess this conclusion was based on my critique of many using a ridged structure that is musically limiting? I don't know.
My other comment to Mike was based on what seems to be conclusions arrived on activity and posts from a single message board website generalizing an entire group across many generations, doing the very thing he has accused others of in the past.
Neither of those are critical of you, Jack, nor does that proclaim that I am "correct or brilliant" or something
I did not know we were debating, so I'm not sure why you used the Appeal to Athority fallacy with the "trust me" variant. I did not question your resume.
I know from your previous "I'm out of here, and taking my tabs with me" posts that you are sensitive. So I am sorry if my posts clearing conclusions about my likes and dislikes upset you somehow. Please don't leave BHO on my account.
After all, these message boards only exist with participation.
Thank You for your response Joel. For the record, I have never said that you do or don't like anything with regards to any style of banjo....Thank you for being polite...Although, I don't think I'll visit the discussion part of the site. I'll just produce Songs that people may be able to use...I do not understand much of what you discuss with other people either so it's best I stay off the discussion part of the site as I said....Jack You don't really elucidate what style of banjo you do play other than something called Stroke style which can be several forms of plucking downwards on the string with the backs of your nails so It's confusing to me...
Edited by - Jack Baker on 09/14/2026 03:48:04
Jack Baker , mechanically I use two methods. First method is plucking the strings with bare fingers. The second method is striking down at the strings with the index (wearing a banjo thimble) while plucking with the thumb.
The repertoire I play is from primarily American publications between 1855 and 1930. This covers commonly known jigs and reels (as well as those composed for banjo), various dance and performance music (marches, polkas, schottisches, and so forth) through Romantic era (some well known standards, some composed for banjo), cakewalks, ragtime, and so forth.
While most of what I play comes from published compositions and arrangements, I do make my own arrangements when there is none available for a piece I want to play or when I find the available arrangements lacking.
For "stroke style", I do something similar, though the volume is fairly limited as the publications for that style start to fall off around the end of the 1880s.
I have not posted anything recently, but there are plenty of videos and recordings of me over the years attempting to play music on banjo.
Page: First Page 1 2 3 4 5 Next Page Last Page (5)
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.