Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Nov 21, 2026 - 10:00:31 AM
5 posts since 11/21/2026

So I guess I’m here to see if anyone else feels what I feel or has any advice on how to stop feeling it. My boyfriend is a phenomenal musician and banjo player, and he recommended I come to Banjo Hang Out because the people here are real and genuine and might be able to get me.

For context: I’m bad at music. In sort of a profound way. I don’t have an ear whatsoever for things like chord changes, intervals, harmony, etc. and I also struggle with rhythm and limb/finger independence an insane amount. I don’t feel rhythm or beats in my body beyond the simplest downbeats. That being said: I’m a good singer. I have a great voice (I have pretty decent vocal technique) and I like to use it. I love singing. Somehow I have a degree in music (hah). However, my actual ear and musicianship were so poor that I barely passed, got told unanimously by faculty that I not only should’ve given up the degree but that it would be a bad choice to play any instrument in public, and I was given up on as “untrainable” by nearly all but one teacher. I feel as though I was born with a deficit. Like other people just…get things that I don’t. As you can imagine, this is incredibly exhausting. I watch other people just…get things with minimal effort.

I’m now technically a professional musician (I sing gigs, I have taught vocal lessons, I’ve been in a jazz band, I’ve even written a couple 4th-grade level dorky songs with some basic guitar chords and a melody. I picked up guitar a couple of years ago, and that’s about as good as I’ve gotten). In my professional life, I still struggle with the basics. Counting is difficult, I truly don’t hear entrances and struggle to stay on beat, I need sheet music or I won’t get it, I can’t harmonize with another singer, I can’t play along with anyone in a jam setting because I can’t identify even basic chords, picking is out of the question, strumming anything other than a straight 3 or 4 pattern is impossible, and basic piano skills feels like an alien instrument. And this is where I’m at after 4 years of working on these concepts in college, as well as 10+ years of private vocal lessons, and doing every musical activity possible throughout middle/high school.

Now, when I try to talk about this with people, I get two responses: 1.) you can’t compare yourself to other people, we’re all on our own journey, and 2.) everyone feels like this; you just have to practice more. The greats all put in the hours.

These responses feel impossible, unhelpful, and short-sighted. Something feels broken or missing in me. Like everyone on earth got the ability to do these things but me—not just musicians, even average people can come in at the right time when singing a song for karaoke. Nearly everyone can do this. I feel uniquely alone in my struggle. And I’m completely at a loss for how to improve, because practicing got me nowhere. I didn’t really improve while training for my degree, I just finally found performance material that was easy enough for me, and my teachers gave up on challenging me and exhaustedly passed me. Ear training never “clicked.” I just got lucky because my senior year was 2020, so the exams that would've failed me couldn’t be completed. And I do continue to practice despite my frustration. I still work on these skills and try to put in the hours, but struggling with BASIC concepts that 10 year olds seem to comprehend is disheartening.

If you’ve read this far: thank you. I’m weeping as type because I’m at my wit’s end. I can’t give up music because for some ridiculous reason I actually want to do it and I love how singing makes me feel. But the knowledge that I’m so far behind everyone else all the time is so painful. This is why I’ve finally ended up here searching for answers. My boyfriend can longer take it. He’s kind of a musical prodigy. Everything he does is incredibly impressive and gets a lot of attention. He loves music, it’s his gift, and he feels like he’s flying when he does it. I, on the other hand, am so ashamed and embarrassed and frustrated that I end up in tears and emotional after music happens (probably 50% of the time). He’s tried being encouraging for the most part, but he takes it personally that I feel bad about myself. He just wants to do music and not have anyone cry—which is fair. He has expressed that he feels like he’s dying trying to date me. I’ve exhausted him and myself. Which hurts because I already felt bad about myself, and now I feel bad for feeling bad.

I do not know what to do. At all. I want to do this without feeling so bad, but the only people who give me advice are people that clearly don’t struggle—not in the ways that I do. I’ve exhausted everyone of their patience and ended up without any advice that’s actually helped. This forum is sort of a last-ditch effort to call out and see if ANYONE knows how this feels. And if so, did you overcome it? Can you play with other people now? Were there training techniques that ACTUALLY worked? I’m willing to practice, but the training tools often feel like dead-ends, or they were developed for people with the musical sense I wasn’t born with. I just want to play music without feeling like a sympathy/charity case. Please, if anyone has advice, I’m open, I’m just very lost. Any responses welcome, and sorry this was a mess, I just needed to dump my feelings out in one place.

Nov 21, 2026 - 10:12:02 AM
likes this

pinenut

USA

1479 posts since 10/2/2007

quote:
Originally posted by largolife

Now, when I try to talk about this with people, I get two responses:

1.) you can’t compare yourself to other people, we’re all on our own journey, and

2.) everyone feels like this; you just have to practice more. The greats all put in the hours.

These responses feel impossible, unhelpful, and short-sighted.  Because they are; forget them.

Something feels broken or missing in me.  The/your answer may seem unrelated to the observed problem.


Edited by - pinenut on 11/21/2026 10:17:19

Nov 21, 2026 - 10:28:02 AM

5 posts since 11/21/2026

quote:
Originally posted by pinenut
quote:
Originally posted by largolife

Now, when I try to talk about this with people, I get two responses:

1.) you can’t compare yourself to other people, we’re all on our own journey, and

2.) everyone feels like this; you just have to practice more. The greats all put in the hours.

These responses feel impossible, unhelpful, and short-sighted.  Because they are; forget them.

Something feels broken or missing in me.  The/your answer may seem unrelated to the observed problem.


I appreciate that you took the time to read that giant wall of text!! You may be right that other internal work should be done. I guess I meant, that something musical specifically was missing or broken in me, but perhaps it is even deeper than that...


Nov 21, 2026 - 11:24:53 AM
likes this
Players Union Member

Texasbanjo (Moderator)

USA

33455 posts since 8/3/2003

If you can sing and keep on key and in time, then you are teachable. Don't believe anyone that says you aren't. You already are started on your musical journey just by being a vocalist, especially if you are doing that at gigs.

Some people learn quicker than others. Some learn by reading, some learn by rote, some by listening, so some or all of those options are available to you.

My husband was a lot like you say you are: couldn't hear chords, couldn't read music, couldn't hear the beat. He also couldn't sing a decent song without messing it up. My group needed a bass player so I bought him an acoustic-electric bass, showed him a few guitar chords and taught him the basic 1-5 of the bass guitar. At first he had to watch the rhythm guitar picker and change chords as she did, but with lots of woodshedding (me on guitar and vocal him on bass), he began to catch on and eventually could anticipate a chord change. After a while, he was managing to do the bass part without any help. Please understand that he started his musical journey when he was in his 60s, so he was slower to learn than most.

So, it can be done. Maybe you just need some help (from husband?) and lots of practice with a partner that knows how it goes, and it'll get easier and better.

I hope this may give you some hope that you can achieve your objective.

Nov 21, 2026 - 11:27:34 AM
likes this

pinenut

USA

1479 posts since 10/2/2007

quote:
Originally posted by largolife
quote:
Originally posted by pinenut
quote:
Originally posted by largolife

Now, when I try to talk about this with people, I get two responses:

1.) you can’t compare yourself to other people, we’re all on our own journey, and

2.) everyone feels like this; you just have to practice more. The greats all put in the hours.

These responses feel impossible, unhelpful, and short-sighted.  Because they are; forget them.

Something feels broken or missing in me.  The/your answer may seem unrelated to the observed problem.


I appreciate that you took the time to read that giant wall of text!! You may be right that other internal work should be done. I guess I meant, that something musical specifically was missing or broken in me, but perhaps it is even deeper than that...  This is a complicated; there are a few regulars on the Hangout with similar issues for a variety of reasons.


 

"I need sheet music or I won’t get it,"

 

This  sticks out to me.  Memory... 

Memory is very important; choose one 'tune' that is common and has strong melody (this means that it is old, common and has many verses and 'songs' associated with it). 

Fully memorize a version that articulates the words on your guitar or the instrument that is most familiar to you and sing along. 

note:  Use any support tools that help get it memorized and fully playable without the supports.

note:  This is one of the early gateways that is not often well articulated in literature.  It helps me.  https://www.banjohangout.org/blog/37163

Edited by - pinenut on 11/21/2026 11:33:10

Nov 21, 2026 - 12:14:58 PM
like this

banjoy

USA

12098 posts since 7/1/2006

Stop beating yourself up. Maybe music is not your thing. Maybe something else is. Everyone has gifts and yes, everyone is different. Perhaps your creativity lay elsewhere. Maybe it is and this is just part of the trip.

I've only been married once but soon after I was married my wife was now exposed to jam sessions, me picking in the living room, gigs, bands and all that. She really wanted to be a part of that and decided she wanted to play guitar. So we got her a guitar and fixed her up with lessons. After a year of trying she came back to me in tears that she was really trying and it just was not working, and she really carried a lot of guilt about that. My advise to her was the same I'm giving to you. After she gave it some thought she mentioned a pottery class she was interested in at a nearby co-op. She signed up and she was a natural. She made some incredible pieces of pottery, so we also got a potter's wheel and kiln. Sold the guitar. Pottery came to her naturally and I still have quite a few pieces of cool stuff she made.

You maybe have your eye on an unattainable goal? And because you love or affection for your partner and want to be a part of that? Maybe? You can still be a part of that and not be a musician.

Anyway, just some things to consider. If music is in your blood and it truly is what you want to do, where there is a will, there is a way. That's not just some empty trope. Maybe posting here can lead to a breakthrough, Who knows. In any event, please allow yourself some grace, it's really okay.

Edited by - banjoy on 11/21/2026 12:18:40

Nov 21, 2026 - 12:36:38 PM
like this

chuckv97

Canada

81027 posts since 10/5/2013

If you have a good voice and are singing at gigs I would think you can build on that. But how can you sing gigs when you say you can’t hear entrances or feel the beat? I bet you’re better than you think you are,, just maybe not cut out to play guitar very well. I would go back to very basic rhythm training (maybe you have already but might be worth another go-through) and ear training to recognize intervals and chord changes. Baby steps! One victory makes the next one possible.

Nov 21, 2026 - 1:20:43 PM
likes this

Nopix

USA

600 posts since 6/11/2025

Sage advice here indeed. Don't beat yourself up. Even if I were to play a wrong note right here and now, nobody will be hurt. (nothing to cry over)
Capitalize on what you already know. Build upon what you already know. Take stock in what you already know. Apparently, you know the key you're singing in. You may have just comitted it to memory. Trouble is, if you sing in a difficult key to play in, you're already sort of doomed. Easy to sing to songs, can be complicated to play also. Has anyone told you as much? I think you'll find out somewhere at sometime, assumptions were made. Music is a human thing. It wasn't handed down by aliens. I consider it a mental lock and key puzzle.

Nov 21, 2026 - 2:15:15 PM
like this

Alex Z

USA

6291 posts since 12/7/2006

"Somehow I have a degree in music (hah). . . . . got told unanimously by faculty that I not only should’ve given up the degree but that it would be a bad choice to play any instrument in public, and I was given up on as “untrainable” by nearly all but one teacher."

"My boyfriend can longer take it. He’s kind of a musical prodigy. Everything he does is incredibly impressive and gets a lot of attention. He loves music, it’s his gift, and he feels like he’s flying when he does it. I, on the other hand, am so ashamed and embarrassed and frustrated that I end up in tears and emotional after music happens (probably 50% of the time)."

"I’m now technically a professional musician (I sing gigs, I have taught vocal lessons, I’ve been in a jazz band"

 

Something is not quite right about this posting.  It's an inconsistent picture in several spots, and yet also over-the-top in several details.  How might it be verified that the whole thing is accurate enough, and from a single person's situation, such that responses would be meaningful and helpful?  

Nov 21, 2026 - 2:43:24 PM

5 posts since 11/21/2026

quote:
Originally posted by Texasbanjo

If you can sing and keep on key and in time, then you are teachable. Don't believe anyone that says you aren't. You already are started on your musical journey just by being a vocalist, especially if you are doing that at gigs.

Some people learn quicker than others. Some learn by reading, some learn by rote, some by listening, so some or all of those options are available to you.

My husband was a lot like you say you are: couldn't hear chords, couldn't read music, couldn't hear the beat. He also couldn't sing a decent song without messing it up. My group needed a bass player so I bought him an acoustic-electric bass, showed him a few guitar chords and taught him the basic 1-5 of the bass guitar. At first he had to watch the rhythm guitar picker and change chords as she did, but with lots of woodshedding (me on guitar and vocal him on bass), he began to catch on and eventually could anticipate a chord change. After a while, he was managing to do the bass part without any help. Please understand that he started his musical journey when he was in his 60s, so he was slower to learn than most.

So, it can be done. Maybe you just need some help (from husband?) and lots of practice with a partner that knows how it goes, and it'll get easier and better.

I hope this may give you some hope that you can achieve your objective.


This is helpful to hear. I guess I was feeling a bit like "nobody who struggles with these things even wants to do music, only naturals ever do it." And "it's stressful for a group to play with people who can't keep up, and it is embarrassing for the group." Knowing that there's someone out there who's had those struggles too and manages to play proficiently after some time and isn't considered a burden to his group actually is really helpful. Knowing that someone was wanted even while being a technically less capable musician makes me feel better. Knowing that there's hope of improving despite not having a natural gift or inclination helps too. (I haven't interacted with too many people who have a hard time with the basics of music and still end up doing it.) Perhaps I need to find someone to play with that is good but not so good I can't keep up, or who is willing to dumb it down so I can practice with them rather than trying to slog through it alone and having no practical application. It sounds like your husband got better by virtue of being in a group. I don't feel as though I would be at a level I could play with one, but if your husband managed to not slow you down and he became capable of keeping up, maybe I need to get over that feeling. Thank you for your input. I'm feeling incredibly low, and knowing that someone stopped to care for a minute means a lot. 

Nov 21, 2026 - 3:05:57 PM

5 posts since 11/21/2026

quote:
Originally posted by banjoy

Stop beating yourself up. Maybe music is not your thing. Maybe something else is. Everyone has gifts and yes, everyone is different. Perhaps your creativity lay elsewhere. Maybe it is and this is just part of the trip.

I've only been married once but soon after I was married my wife was now exposed to jam sessions, me picking in the living room, gigs, bands and all that. She really wanted to be a part of that and decided she wanted to play guitar. So we got her a guitar and fixed her up with lessons. After a year of trying she came back to me in tears that she was really trying and it just was not working, and she really carried a lot of guilt about that. My advise to her was the same I'm giving to you. After she gave it some thought she mentioned a pottery class she was interested in at a nearby co-op. She signed up and she was a natural. She made some incredible pieces of pottery, so we also got a potter's wheel and kiln. Sold the guitar. Pottery came to her naturally and I still have quite a few pieces of cool stuff she made.

You maybe have your eye on an unattainable goal? And because you love or affection for your partner and want to be a part of that? Maybe? You can still be a part of that and not be a musician.

Anyway, just some things to consider. If music is in your blood and it truly is what you want to do, where there is a will, there is a way. That's not just some empty trope. Maybe posting here can lead to a breakthrough, Who knows. In any event, please allow yourself some grace, it's really okay.


This is fair advice. I have thought about giving up on music entirely. Most of college was one enormous self-esteem hit after another. My scores were consistently poor in a lot of areas. Yet, for some reason, I keep coming back. I wish I knew why. I think I just actually love music. When I see others doing music, it's all I want to be doing. When I'm alone, I sing. I love the feeling of using my voice powerfully. I've felt this way since middle school, and I wanted to do music even when it was "uncool." I'm running into the roadblock of feeling frustrated that I'm missing some component that would make me actually able to do it well. Thank you for listening, and maybe you're right that there's something that someone can offer that will help me have a breakthrough. I'm desperate for a success story from someone else who was born without the gift, you know? Feels isolating to be the "slow buffalo," and to see no-one else in the same position. There have been a couple wise words about practicing techniques or people in similar situations and their path forward that have been shared so far that I will take to heart. Thank you again for caring.

Nov 21, 2026 - 3:18:30 PM
likes this

chuckv97

Canada

81027 posts since 10/5/2013

quote:
Originally posted by Alex Z

"Somehow I have a degree in music (hah). . . . . got told unanimously by faculty that I not only should’ve given up the degree but that it would be a bad choice to play any instrument in public, and I was given up on as “untrainable” by nearly all but one teacher."

"My boyfriend can longer take it. He’s kind of a musical prodigy. Everything he does is incredibly impressive and gets a lot of attention. He loves music, it’s his gift, and he feels like he’s flying when he does it. I, on the other hand, am so ashamed and embarrassed and frustrated that I end up in tears and emotional after music happens (probably 50% of the time)."

"I’m now technically a professional musician (I sing gigs, I have taught vocal lessons, I’ve been in a jazz band"

 

Something is not quite right about this posting.  It's an inconsistent picture in several spots, and yet also over-the-top in several details.  How might it be verified that the whole thing is accurate enough, and from a single person's situation, such that responses would be meaningful and helpful?  


I'm scratching my head a bit, too.  It feels/sounds odd,,,  hope I'm wrong

Nov 21, 2026 - 3:25:35 PM
likes this

Dean T

USA

4835 posts since 4/18/2024

It would help if the OP would fill out her profile, so we could get a better perspective on her age, interests, instruments, playing ability and time, and short bio, so we could understand her situation a little better. She’s a fantastic journalist to type that much with no mistakes and no edits, very impressive. I’ve been playing for 50 years, and still could never sit in with a jazz band, or understand their timing, so I would love to hear more about that!

Nov 21, 2026 - 3:56:01 PM

5 posts since 11/21/2026

quote:
Originally posted by Alex Z

"Somehow I have a degree in music (hah). . . . . got told unanimously by faculty that I not only should’ve given up the degree but that it would be a bad choice to play any instrument in public, and I was given up on as “untrainable” by nearly all but one teacher."

"My boyfriend can longer take it. He’s kind of a musical prodigy. Everything he does is incredibly impressive and gets a lot of attention. He loves music, it’s his gift, and he feels like he’s flying when he does it. I, on the other hand, am so ashamed and embarrassed and frustrated that I end up in tears and emotional after music happens (probably 50% of the time)."

"I’m now technically a professional musician (I sing gigs, I have taught vocal lessons, I’ve been in a jazz band"

 

Something is not quite right about this posting.  It's an inconsistent picture in several spots, and yet also over-the-top in several details.  How might it be verified that the whole thing is accurate enough, and from a single person's situation, such that responses would be meaningful and helpful?  


I'm sorry if it seems a bit disjointed. I guess the gist of it is that, despite extensive training, I am still struggling with a lot of basic concepts and it is disheartening. My vocal technique has been enough to sort of carry me in places where my musicianship failed me. During college, I failed my sophomore jury. At the point, the faculty had a come-to-Jesus moment with me, and recommended that with my level of struggling, this probably wasn't the path for me. I refused to quit. I wanted to sing, I LIKED singing. Essentially, I sounded great, but my musicality was far below that of my peers and it still is far below the average musician's. After refusing to quit, I found a teacher who was willing to work with me despite even his feeling like I wasn't capable. He thought he might be able to salvage my degree at least. He picked easier music than I probably should've had, and I managed to finish out my degree with a lot of allowances made. (My program was also dying at this time, and I think this played into their decision to pass me.)

fast-forward a few years, and I am trying to do professional work. Voice lessons are okay because I focus on technique--which I do have a grasp on, but I feel that I am not introducing my students to the musical concepts they should be exposed to in order to become musicians rather than singers. Gigs are hit-or-miss. I find that I can do okay half of the time with a lot of crutches (band helping me out by picking up my mistakes and making accommodations for me, using sheet music to visually see my counts and entrances, etc) but there are still a fair amount of biffed gigs (in some unfortunately egregious ways, too).

Meanwhile, post-college, I start dating someone who is essentially a prodigy. His talent is astounding. I love what he does, and he has such a capacity for healing others with his music. But when I struggle with insecurity (despite that I was struggling before I ever met him), he feels as though being around him is making it worse for me. And I, unfortunately don't feel seen, because I know he'll never know what it feels like to struggle in the ways I do. He knows this too. It hurts him to see me unable to fully enjoy the thing he's so gifted at, and I'm disappointed because I can't keep up with him (or other musicians.) this cycle of pain for both of us led him to reccomend I reach out to other musicians who might be more likely to come forward with similar experiences and speak of their own resillience. 

So, now I'm here. I'm mostly reaching out to see if there's anyone who's not a natural born talent who might have some wisdom on how they overcame struggling with basic concepts. I just don't see other people having this hard of a time with basic stuff. Sure musicians I know might struggle with a specific type of picking or hitting high notes or improvisation or jazz chords or some nitpicky technical thing, but when it comes to truly basic concepts like "can you hear if this is a I, IV or V" or "do you come in on the right beat when singing 'Jolene' at karaoke," I guess I just don't know musicians who struggle with those things. And certainly not BOTH of them.
 

So if anyone who knows what that feels like, to practice those simple things for years and still not get them, and has somehow had a breakthrough that helped them get it and be able to do it successfully without biffing it or having a bunch of crutches or accommodations, then that's what I guess I'm looking for. It's hard to get so much advice from people who just don't know what it's like to feel "musically blind." A couple of people have offered meaningful advice already, which I want to try and see if it helps. And being heard and seen as real and not impossible is helpful in and of itself. I guess I just don't want to feel so alone on this path. I do love music, but it's exhausting to know I'm making such insignificant progress, and I feel like there are no good training tools for the kind of brain I have. I am absolutely taking all of the advice that I've gotten from everyone so far, though. I'm not here to be miserable and whiny, I just want to get un-stuck. Feeling "not alone" is meaningful to me, and I want to make progress!

thank you for reading this, and I hope this response added clarity and context to my post.

Nov 21, 2026 - 7:38:59 PM

7177 posts since 3/6/2006

Is the prodigy boyfriend a member here? Would love to check out some of his music.

Nov 21, 2026 - 8:10:02 PM

3819 posts since 4/19/2008

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





0.109375