Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Nov 4, 2026 - 4:05 PM
42 posts since 6/9/2026

I really like Sheila Adams' version of "Three Forks of Hell" on "The Civil War Collection" album by Jim Taylor. It's one of those songs I can't stop playing because the B part leads perfectly back to the A part.

It seems like there's only one chord in the entire tune. I don't perceive any other instruments in her version. Does anyone have ideas about chords? I'm mostly interested in simple guitar accompaniment.

Opinions, facts and conjecture welcome.

Nov 4, 2026 - 5:03:14 PM
likes this

5396 posts since 10/13/2005

I remember liking that tune too but I've never seen it elsewhere. Are there other names for that tune? banjered

Nov 4, 2026 - 5:46:01 PM

42 posts since 6/9/2026

As far as I know, that's the only name but like a lot of old time tunes, it could go by several names or variations. It was a TOTW by Janet Burton some time ago. It's a great tune to play. Ms. Adams version uses a lot of clucking on the downbeat as opposed to the offbeat. It makes for a compelling tune.

I found an accurate tab of Sheila Adams' version and I uploaded a jpeg to BHO - hopefully it shows below.

https://www.banjohangout.org/forum/attachment_manager/a_mngr_added.asp?addType=1&fileID=322887


Nov 18, 2026 - 11:01:56 AM
likes this

verve

USA

11 posts since 11/16/2026

A tune that seems to sit on one chord is usually modal rather than harmonic, so the interest comes from the melody instead of chord changes. For simple guitar accompaniment a steady home chord is safest, with a move to the four or five chord only where a phrase clearly leans that way; two or three chord touches across a whole part is plenty. If the banjo is in double-C, a guitarist can capo up or play in C so the keys line up.
-- verve

Nov 18, 2026 - 3:07:11 PM
likes this

7547 posts since 6/27/2009

It was Carolyn Faubel who presented this Tune of the Week for Three Forks of Hell.  If you read through the thread you may get some insightful help.  I find that when I play along with the my tab, attached here, as well as the Sheila Adams tab, I can use some chords that complement the tune, using C, Am and G.  Information on the tuning itself, as noted in the TOTW thread,  is interesting, too:  eCGCD "high atmosphere tuning".  This recording from my older video  is rough with its banjo accompaniment, but it may give you ideas.


Nov 19, 2026 - 7:48:33 AM

42 posts since 6/9/2026

quote:
Originally posted by verve

A tune that seems to sit on one chord is usually modal rather than harmonic, so the interest comes from the melody instead of chord changes. For simple guitar accompaniment a steady home chord is safest, with a move to the four or five chord only where a phrase clearly leans that way; two or three chord touches across a whole part is plenty. If the banjo is in double-C, a guitarist can capo up or play in C so the keys line up.
-- verve


My ear plays games with my brain. Sometimes I think I hear a chord change.

I was wondering if, like lots of tunes, it had an accepted chord progression but apparently not. 

It's a wonderful tune that starts playing itself, and the last phrase leads one right back to the beginning. 

Nov 19, 2026 - 8:11:15 AM
likes this

42 posts since 6/9/2026

quote:
Originally posted by JanetB

It was Carolyn Faubel who presented this Tune of the Week for Three Forks of Hell.  If you read through the thread you may get some insightful help.  I find that when I play along with the my tab, attached here, as well as the Sheila Adams tab, I can use some chords that complement the tune, using C, Am and G.  Information on the tuning itself, as noted in the TOTW thread,  is interesting, too:  eCGCD "high atmosphere tuning".  This recording from my older video  is rough with its banjo accompaniment, but it may give you ideas.


@carolynf  - My apologes for not giving you credit. The backstory and/or back rumors are great and give this tune some real history. Thanks to Carolyn for the research and posting in TOTW.

Wow @JanetB! Your recording was great. Quite different in tempo and feel, but altogether enjoyable. I'd never heard it like that. I think I'll slow me down and make it sing like you do.

In my ignorance I missed the part about "high atmosphere tuning", so I've been playing it in double C tuning with the 5th string tuned normally (high g). I will try the new tuning, but I find my "gCGCD high ignorance tuning" acceptable and nice. So anyone out there as lazy as me, give it try but you probably shouldn't tell anyone.

One of the things Sheila Adams does is hit the cluck on the downbeat as opposed to the offbeat. Sometimes. Either way, hers are always tasteful and timely.

Thanks for pointing me to the previous posts about this tune. 

Jan

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.4375