Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors

Banjo Lovers Online

Banjo versus TV: Week 11

Posted by jrjenks on Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Banjo 88 hrs, TV 61 hours
A weekly check-in on the Banjo versus TV project — J.R.'s resolution to spend more time in 2008 on his banjo than on TV.

Remember, from last week, how proud I was of my new practice regimen? The one where I enter songs from my practice books into TablEdit, play them back with my practice part turned off so I can play along?


Mike, my instructor, really hated it. I asked him his opinion and he gave it: big thumb-down.

The problem is with my song selection. Mike can understand that I want to play along with music and he doesn't object to that, per se. In fact, he recommended that I look for some band-minus-one CDs. But Mike says that practicing the songs as I was practicing them would make me a boring, soulless player. The songs, as TablEdit played them, were robotic and dull.

Back to the drawing board.

Also in the last week:

  • First time I've ever installed new strings! It took me more than an hour to put five new strings (D'Addario J60 Nickel 9-20 Light) on the no-name banjo. How did I do? Well, it sounds much better. But I did a terrible job of wire wrapping. I think I'll buy some more new strings and have the shop install them. Still, it was a learning experience. I'll keep trying until I get good at it.
  • Dropped the Oscar Schmidt banjo off at Hogeye Music in Evanston to have a Shubb fifth string capo installed. Jim, the luthier, was having a busy time of it and said it could take as long as a week for him to install it. I'm glad I've got my spare banjo so I don't have to go banjo-less.


Cross-posted at J.R. Jenks' blog

2 comments on “Banjo versus TV: Week 11”

Texasbanjo Says:
Tuesday, March 18, 2008 @10:26:06 AM

You might consider getting Band in a Box software.  That way you can put chords to whatever song you're learning into BIAB and it'll play backup for you at any speed and in any key.  I use it daily for practice and it doesn't make me a boring, soulless player.  It does help you learn good timing -- if you slow down or speed up, it doesn't and it'll help your timing immensely.

I don't understand why your teacher doesn't like Tabledit, but I guess he has his reasons -- it also give you the beat and that's what you need to learn:  timing, timing, timing.

jrjenks Says:
Tuesday, March 18, 2008 @1:03:06 PM

Thanks for the tip, Texasbanjo.  I see that PG Music Inc has a demo version of Band-in-a-Box.  It'll let me play with the software for two weeks to decide whether I like it.  I'll be trying it out some time.

I think Mike's objections weren't with TablEdit; they were with the source material I'd chosen.  (I was entering the tabs from my Hal Leonard Banjo Method books.)  But I also think that TablEdit is going to play any tablature in a robotic fashion, even when I choose the "Simulate human playing" option.

I know that Mike doesn't object to playing along with a gadget.  He continues to rave about his Tascam MP-GT1 Guitar Trainer, which he uses to play MP3s in the same way that you use Band-in-a-Box.

You must sign into your myHangout account before you can post comments.

More posts from jrjenks

Newest Posts

Click for Details 'Up 18 North' 10 min

Click for Details 'Flying Indian' 3 hrs

More >  

Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories