Posted by jrjenks on Monday, May 17, 2010
A check-in on the Banjo versus TV project — J.R.'s ongoing plan to spend more time on his banjo than on TV. This post covers 4/11/2010 through 4/17/2010.
I've been thinking about modifying one of my cheap acoustic banjos to make it electric so I can practice quietly. And maybe so I can connect it to a loop pedal.
Which is why I've been learning about electric banjos this week.
...which is paired with a metal shim placed on the other side of the drum head, under the bridge. The pickup detects the movement of the shim.
That's a good way to electrify a banjo if your goal is to perform on stage. But since I want to do quiet practice, that's not the way I'm going to do it.
Actually, that's not the way I'd do it even if I were planning on performing on stage with an electric banjo. If I were going to do that (and yes, I'll do that some day) I'd take advantage of the fact that I own a Nechville banjo and I'd purchase the Nechville Turbo Module...
...which is a swappable replacement head that turns a Nechville acoustic banjo into an approximation of the Nechville Meteor electric banjo.
The Nechville Meteor uses two pickups: one piezoelectric pickup inside the head and one magnetic pickup (a humbucker) which you can see between the drum head and the fretboard. Unlike the magnetic pickup I described above, which detects the movement of the bridge, this magnetic pickup detects the movement of the strings.
Another pickup option is the Kavanjo Pickup System, which places two sets of five electromagnetic pickups right on the drum head.
I've got a lot more to learn about banjo pickups and such, but that's a start.
Also in the last week:
Update: I'd be remiss if I left out another electric banjo thing that David showed me – the 1976 jazz banjo album "Melting Pots"...
...by Susie Monick.
Susie played several songs (including Wicked Witch Breakdown, a variation on Cripple Creek that David and I had previously discussed) on a solid-body electric banjo which you can see on the back of the album cover.
A solid-body banjo electric banjo doesn't have a drum to vibrate so there's no point in trying to detect the movement of the floating banjo bridge using a piezo pickup or a magnetic pickup with a metal shim under the bridge. It's got to be all about using magnetic pickups to capture string movement.
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 @5:12:16 AM
A magnetic pickup will work fine when soft batting is used to damp most of the volume. The pickup works by sensing the string vibrations only. Your instructor may have a mag pickup that came with a thin steel foil strip that fits under the bridge feet- this takes the place of the string's vibrations, and puts the pickup in closer proximity to signal, so a weaker magnet can be used. Weaker magnets make for less feedback and noise.
The foil isn't needed if you buy a high output pickup and mount it close to the neck, not by the bridge.
Piezo pickups have a much weaker output, so they need a pre-amp most of the time. But a pre-amp can be turned way down in it's volume output level. Piezos are much more sensitive in picking up head and string vibrations than magnetics, and give a closer 'actual banjo tone' than magnetics. Neither is actually very accurate to the actual tone, which is so complex that it has yet to be digitally duplicated accurately yet.
No need to pull banjo strings. The pulling thing works on the heavy wound strings on a guitar, but the strings on a banjo are all so close together in overall gauge that pulling isn't needed. (unless you use nylon strings, which are very stretchy. It's good to pull them.)
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 @6:54:09 AM
Thanks, stanger, for the insight into pickups. I'm getting a better picture of how to construct my quiet practice banjo.
It seems that tracking the movement of the bridge with a piezo pickup will give me a more banjo-like sound and tracking the movement of the strings with a magnetic pickup will be more like an electric guitar. Tom Nechville has put both options on the Meteor and allows you to mix and match as you please.
I'll keep the pulling advice in mind for ukuleles and guitars, which I'd like to learn to play some day.
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 @8:30:57 AM
Yup. And you can buy several systems that incorporate both. You can also buy systems that use a magnetic and microphone, and/or all 3.
When it comes to amping a banjo, I always used a piezo, but others have done fine with all of the systems. The thing to remember is none are going to be accurate, so the sound to look for has to be a thing you think works for you. As far as practice goes, it's no big deal about an amp, but if you perform, and amp becomes just as important as the pickup.
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 @8:34:04 AM
Alison Brown has the most natural sounding amped banjo I've ever heard, but it still doesn't sound like the natural banjo. She uses a mic mounted on the flange, but that's all I know. I'll bet she has a pickup under the head, and she's probably running the signal in different ways to her amp onstage and the house P.A.
This stuff can be super archane... sort of like making gold from tin. I experimented for over 20 years!
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 @11:39:19 AM
stanger, I did a little Googling and it sounds like Alison Brown has messed around a lot with electric banjo configurations. I'd like to learn more about what she's done.
I saw your description of her mic at http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/135559
Her Wikipedia entry at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alison_Brown says she's "known for a soft nylon-string banjo sound" so I wonder if nylon string are part of the sound you describe.
She apparently has a Nechville electric banjo that she designed (http://www.mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=14333) which I guess is the Nechville Aurora Borealis Electric Banjo (http://www.herbdavidguitarstudio.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=3351).
She also plays a Deering Crossfire (http://www.bluegrasscenter.com/crossfire.html).
You must sign into your myHangout account before you can post comments.
'More Banjo Parts!' 1 min
'Martin 000-18' 5 hrs