Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


 All Forums
 Other Banjo-Related Topics
 Banjo Building, Setup, and Repair
 ARCHIVED TOPIC: A Plea For The Health Of Your Banjo''s Neck.....


Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/254981/3

Page: 1  2  3  

Prof - Posted - 02/14/2013:  08:57:11


Call me guilty of stand use, but I use a homemade stand with a low cg, and it tilts back a little further than most I've seen. I've also incorporated a hook off to the side where my strap wraps around to hold it in case of an accidental bumping.




Banjophobic - Posted - 02/14/2013:  10:32:42



quote:


Originally posted by Prof




Call me guilty of stand use, but I use a homemade stand with a low cg, and it tilts back a little further than most I've seen. I've also incorporated a hook off to the side where my strap wraps around to hold it in case of an accidental bumping.






Very nice! The only thing I would add is putting a 'stop' bar across that yoke area. 


talespinner - Posted - 02/14/2013:  13:02:12



I've often wondered about hanging a banjo by the neck, thinking iy might actually be hanging by the neck until dead. I've worried that the weight of a pot with a lot of hardware might be great enough to put damaging stress on the pot to neck joint, whether dowel stick or coordinator rods. Therefore I've wondered if it would be better to hang the banjo by its pot so that the hanger rather than the neck takes the bulk of the weight. That being said, my banjos are never on stands or hangers. They are in their cases, although if I'm performing the case is open by my side on the floor.


Prof - Posted - 02/14/2013:  13:05:26



quote:


Originally posted by Banjophobic




quote:


Originally posted by Prof





Call me guilty of stand use, but I use a homemade stand with a low cg, and it tilts back a little further than most I've seen. I've also incorporated a hook off to the side where my strap wraps around to hold it in case of an accidental bumping.






Very nice! The only thing I would add is putting a 'stop' bar across that yoke area. 






Yes, I've often thought about that -- this conversation may make me actually get around to doing it.


DeanT - Posted - 02/14/2013:  18:34:38


talespinner, the string tension pulling up, is still much greater than the weight of the pot pulling down, when hanging a banjo. The neck to pot joint wouldn't even know the difference.

Banjophobic - Posted - 02/15/2013:  06:26:28



quote:


Originally posted by talespinner




I've often wondered about hanging a banjo by the neck, thinking iy might actually be hanging by the neck until dead. I've worried that the weight of a pot with a lot of hardware might be great enough to put damaging stress on the pot to neck joint, whether dowel stick or coordinator rods. Therefore I've wondered if it would be better to hang the banjo by its pot so that the hanger rather than the neck takes the bulk of the weight. That being said, my banjos are never on stands or hangers. They are in their cases, although if I'm performing the case is open by my side on the floor.






Hanging them from the wall does not negatively affect them.  If it odes, then every major musical retailer and collector for the past 40 years has been doing something wrong. They haven't-its much,much safer than a stand.enlightened


SJL - Posted - 02/16/2013:  15:42:45


I was always careful to make sure that my bottle cap starter banjo was 'properly' in the stand, that I made sure that it was centred and that the bar was closed on the top section where the neck rests. I had put it away, the strap dropped down and got caught in my foot as I was walking away. Broken neck #1.

So, what I thought I learned from that experience was to make sure that the strap was folded in a way that it couldn't fall out. I was always diligent about this with my second banjo, a seventies Japanese Masterclone. I made sure that it was in a corner of the room that got little traffic. I didn't count on the dog knocking it over. Neck number two. Fortunately a luthier was able to repair it, but I won't take any chances any more. All of my banjos are in latched cases when I'm not using them.

Dave1climber - Posted - 02/16/2013:  17:55:58



quote:


Originally posted by SJL




I was always careful to make sure that my bottle cap starter banjo was 'properly' in the stand, that I made sure that it was centred and that the bar was closed on the top section where the neck rests. I had put it away, the strap dropped down and got caught in my foot as I was walking away. Broken neck #1.



So, what I thought I learned from that experience was to make sure that the strap was folded in a way that it couldn't fall out. I was always diligent about this with my second banjo, a seventies Japanese Masterclone. I made sure that it was in a corner of the room that got little traffic. I didn't count on the dog knocking it over. Neck number two. Fortunately a luthier was able to repair it, but I won't take any chances any more. All of my banjos are in latched cases when I'm not using them.


 






This would be funny if it wasn't so sad.  sad


Hairymare - Posted - 02/18/2013:  06:16:17


Two new banjo hangers ordered. I like my banjos in reach. Thanks for the warnings. Yvette

Brerrabbit - Posted - 02/18/2013:  10:48:42



And my banjo neck from shipping UPS


Dave1climber - Posted - 02/18/2013:  11:08:01



quote:


Originally posted by Brerrabbit




And my banjo neck from shipping UPS






What happened to your neck?


Banjophobic - Posted - 02/18/2013:  19:04:09



quote:


Originally posted by Dave1climber




quote:


Originally posted by Brerrabbit





And my banjo neck from shipping UPS






What happened to your neck?






You can guess Dave............broken heart


Brerrabbit - Posted - 02/19/2013:  06:14:40



Broken from nut to pot..


budbennett - Posted - 02/19/2013:  06:43:04



quote:


Originally posted by Banjophobic




Ok, I've just taken in the 7th broken banjo neck just in this month, caused by a stand ( and 3 guitar pegheads also). Its been stated by many on this forum  including myself, how bad a stand is for the overall safety of your banjo's neck 'health'. While stands look cool for displaying your banjo, they are an accident waiting to happen if you store your banjo there long enough.



While it does keep business 'booming' (as in the 'boom' your neck makes as it hits the floor....broken heart ), I really, really hate to see all these beautiful necks broken.  Here's another plea to keep your banjo in the case, with a latch closed, when storing it. If you just have to 'see' it, get a  Hercules brand cam action wall hanger, attached to a wall stud. Its all I use in the shop. Here's a link if you want to check one out. 



musiciansfriend.com/accessorie...ar-hanger



 The latest victim of a stand is a late model Deering G.E. with a lovely curly maple neck. Ok, this concludes this  BHO  public service announcement........blackeyewink



 



P.S. I have no monetary interest in that hanger company. They are just great quality and will save your neck...FYI....big






 Since that is a guitar hanger, is it too wide for the banjo?  I only ask because I bought two hangers a few years ago and they turned out to be guitar hangers and not banjo hangers and the banjos do not fit in them.



i have never used a stand and always keep mine in the case btw.  i always wanted to hang one or two on the wall though, just have never gotten around to it.


OldTimeGal - Posted - 02/19/2013:  07:14:30


My banjo's home away from my arms is always in its case, no problem playing when it's out of site 'cause we're like-minded:-)

budbennett - Posted - 02/19/2013:  07:21:14



elderly.com/accessories/items/GSP38WB.htm



 



Have you had any experience with the banjos resting on the tuners John?


Banjophobic - Posted - 02/19/2013:  10:23:04



quote:


Originally posted by budbennett




elderly.com/accessories/items/GSP38WB.htm



 



Have you had any experience with the banjos resting on the tuners John?






Yes, but it doesn't affect them other than to occasionally push a string out of tune. The locking cam action still keeps the banjo firmly in place and resting on the tuners is no big deal.


unbanjo - Posted - 02/20/2013:  00:59:29



quote:


Originally posted by specs    But yes, it is up to every person to weigh the risks vs. benefits.    




 Here's how I weigh them: I appreciate the warning, but...



 



I've had a quality banjo for almost 5 years. During that time my neck was broken by my son (against my warning, he left it leaning against the couch. Never had an accident with a stand). It cost me $150 to get it fixed. I think I play my banjo almost twice as often due to having it on a stand vs. keeping it in a case. As a parent, I'm constantly having to put my banjo down and resume playing it a number of minutes later. If I had to put it in it's case every time, forget it! Laying it in it's  open case is not, IMO, a safe alternative- I think I'd just as soon have a broken neck as a glass of juice spilled all over my pot! The wall hanger seems like a good alternative, but for those of us who rent, it might not be an option. With my banjo stand sitting in a corner as it is, I feel pretty safe and don't see much reason to change it.



So... my risk vs. benefits analysis:



$150 for neck repair divided by 5 years= $30 per year, or about the cost of one banjo lesson, for me to be able to practice my banjo a whole lot more. I say, for me,  it's been worth it.



Edited by - unbanjo on 02/20/2013 01:07:44

Banjophobic - Posted - 02/20/2013:  07:10:29



quote:


Originally posted by unbanjo




 


 Here's how I weigh them: I appreciate the warning, but...



 



I've had a quality banjo for almost 5 years. During that time my neck was broken by my son (against my warning, he left it leaning against the couch. Never had an accident with a stand). It cost me $150 to get it fixed. I think I play my banjo almost twice as often due to having it on a stand vs. keeping it in a case. As a parent, I'm constantly having to put my banjo down and resume playing it a number of minutes later. If I had to put it in it's case every time, forget it! Laying it in it's  open case is not, IMO, a safe alternative- I think I'd just as soon have a broken neck as a glass of juice spilled all over my pot! The wall hanger seems like a good alternative, but for those of us who rent, it might not be an option. With my banjo stand sitting in a corner as it is, I feel pretty safe and don't see much reason to change it.



So... my risk vs. benefits analysis:



$150 for neck repair divided by 5 years= $30 per year, or about the cost of one banjo lesson, for me to be able to practice my banjo a whole lot more. I say, for me,  it's been worth it.






Yep, each person much decide this 'risk vs benefit'  thing for themselves. I'm sure there are many folks who will balk at this thread as someone being ODC or just over the top about the 'danger' of stands. To those who do and have used them with no incident and it is no big deal to break a neck,  I'm really glad to hear it. Unfortunately based on what i see every year, the 'risk' of breaking necks, especially very high end and or vintage collectable instruments ,is pushing the analysis too far into the 'risk' category.



Each person has to make their own assessment and decide how important/not important breaking the neck of  their instruments is. I hope you don't have a stand accident and if you do that your neck survives with little/no damages. Make sure you are using one with a wide base, low center of gravity designed to hold a banjo, is my only advice.



The goal in this thread is to maybe help folks avoid coming to see guys like me with peg heads in a separate container. blackeyesmiley



Edited by - Banjophobic on 02/20/2013 07:12:10

5 finger ninja - Posted - 02/20/2013:  08:28:03


After reading this thread , I now keep mine close to my couch in the case with the lid open! I can live with that.

5String_Picker - Posted - 02/27/2013:  20:12:38


I'm a fan of the On Stage stands myself (the one with the upper yoke). Never had a problem with them...



   

Banjophobic - Posted - 02/28/2013:  13:29:41



 Update: Another neck is being shipped as I type here. A Rich and Taylor..cracked peg head from a stand. Thats number 3 this month. blackeye



Edited by - Banjophobic on 02/28/2013 13:30:33

Dave1climber - Posted - 02/28/2013:  19:40:53



On the plus side, once you get past the distress, is that at three per month it goes a fair way to keeping the lights on.  shock



Edited by - Dave1climber on 02/28/2013 19:41:46

tillygoat - Posted - 02/28/2013:  22:00:12


I'm new to the banjo but I always keep mine in a hard case, it doesn't take that long to get it out when I want to practise, and I know it's safe.
Just my opinion...

Ron C - Posted - 03/25/2013:  09:55:40


Bringing this back from the retired threads.



I used to put my banjos back in their cases all the time. In one instance, a banjo that I did not play often was left in its case for some time - about a year or so. The banjo neck finish had become visibly rough due to the fibers of the case liner. I had the neck carefully sanded and it is now smooth. However, I am now anxious about leaving a banjo in a case for any length of time.



Any suggestions or comments?



Thanks,



Ron


colleydawg - Posted - 04/05/2013:  14:26:58


Guess I'll add my two cents' worth.  At home, I've kept my banjo on a stand for over 20 years so I can pick it up and play on it any time the notion arises.  I've been using the Hamilton KB-38 hanging instrument stand.  The instrument hangs by it's head, like on a wall hanger, and the body rests against padded arms. 



I first saw Skaggs using these on stage back in the 1980's.  I've never had my banjo fall over or off the stand.  The cool thing is you can adjust the height to accommodate anything from an electric bass to a fiddle.  They're a bit expensive, but I've found them to be the sturdiest around.  I've even used them on stage and, again, never had an accident.



Having said that, I'm also an empty nester and don't have any small children running around the house.  If you have that situation, it's possible no stand is safe and you should keep you instruments packed up in their cases and away from the foot traffic.





 



Gene


Possom - Posted - 04/06/2013:  04:15:44


Well John the other day the cheap guitar neck finally gave in. Snapped at the heel. The kids are STILL dragging it around lol.

Page: 1  2  3  

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





0.109375