DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online banjo teacher.
Weekly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, banjo news and more.
|
Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/254981
Page: 1  2  3  
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/29/2013: 19:44:45
Ok, I've just taken in the 7th broken banjo neck just in this month, caused by a stand ( and 3 guitar pegheads also). Its been stated by many on this forum including myself, how bad a stand is for the overall safety of your banjo's neck 'health'. While stands look cool for displaying your banjo, they are an accident waiting to happen if you store your banjo there long enough.
While it does keep business 'booming' (as in the 'boom' your neck makes as it hits the floor....
), I really, really hate to see all these beautiful necks broken. Here's another plea to keep your banjo in the case, with a latch closed, when storing it. If you just have to 'see' it, get a Hercules brand cam action wall hanger, attached to a wall stud. Its all I use in the shop. Here's a link if you want to check one out.
musiciansfriend.com/accessorie...ar-hanger
The latest victim of a stand is a late model Deering G.E. with a lovely curly maple neck. Ok, this concludes this BHO public service announcement........![]()
![]()
P.S. I have no monetary interest in that hanger company. They are just great quality and will save your neck...FYI....![]()
Edited by - Banjophobic on 01/30/2013 08:51:14
dfwest - Posted - 01/29/2013: 20:13:08
Holy cow - that's a lot of broken necks. What is it that knocks them off the stands? Dogs, children, marauding Huns, earthquakes...?
Dave
From Greylock to Bean Blossom - Posted - 01/29/2013: 20:15:08
John,
Do you not see any health hazards to the neck from hanging it by the neck?
Ken
NealR - Posted - 01/29/2013: 20:19:42
OOOOOOO Noooooooo
I am guity as charged. I do swear to remove my banjo and guitar from their stands at work and home. I told my wife 5 minutes ago that I was going to donate one of my stands to a friend for his recently purchased dobro. Instead I will give him a word of warning. I have heard enough of these sad sad stories. And I cannot afford to repair my necks. In the case or in my hands is my new saying.
Hope Faith and Love
Dingoman25 - Posted - 01/29/2013: 20:25:28
John,
serious question:
the neck is damaged when the banjo is knocked out of the stand, or is just resting the neck against the stand top "anchor" for years on end also causing undue stress?
thanks,
Chris.
plunka5 - Posted - 01/29/2013: 20:25:42
Unless you are a performer...if it is not in your hands...then put it in the case and close the latches!!!
I've come close too many times NOT to remember this quote now.
desert rose - Posted - 01/29/2013: 20:43:15
I always advise people who insist keeping their instrument on a stand to please keep a business card of your favorite luthier in the case... because you will eventually need his service![]()
Scott
Clockwork John - Posted - 01/29/2013: 22:30:52
The only place I EVER keep ANY of my instruments out of the case unless I'm playing them, getting ready to, or need them within easy reach (such as a jam where I'm switching off between mandolin, tenor banjo, and maybe guitar), is in my music room/pet room. In there, it's stacked cases, instruments leaning against the wall things on stands... I'm sure it would make some luthiers and repairmen queasy. BUT, I'm the only one who ever goes in there. My wife stays out, and I keep the door closed to keep the cats out. As an added benefit, the 65 gallon aquarium in there makes an excellent whole room humidifier.
overhere - Posted - 01/30/2013: 02:31:10
My wife drives a vacuum cleaner the way she drives a car. The thought never crossed my mind to get a stand for my banjo. Wall hangers (good ones) only way to go if you have to have it handy… if not keep it in the case.
Side note; I cringe when I’m in a music store where they have their stuff out on the floor on those flimsy stands. I do notice however all the cheap ones are on the stands and the good stuff are on the wall brackets. And the Martins are high up out of reach. hahha
OM45GE - Posted - 01/30/2013: 03:52:38
You said it John. And the advice about latching the case is well taken. Years ago I grabbed my guitar case to head for a gig and my vintage Martin 1929 OM 28 tumbled onto the floor. Fortunately, it landed on a rug wasn't damaged but I always leave my instruments latched in the case if they're not on my lap.
eagleisland - Posted - 01/30/2013: 05:59:45
Thanks for that, John. I've just bookmarked this page and am now prepared to simply post the link the next time a "what's the best banjo stand?" thread starts on the Shopping Advice forum. Judging by past experience, it should show up within a few weeks. ![]()
Dave1climber - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:06:01
The "best banjo stand" is just an accident waiting to happen.
Dan Drabek - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:13:38
But the worst banjo is the one that never gets taken out of it's case. I find that I play my banjo way more often if it's right there ready to pick up. Even if it's just to play a quick tune, or try out a new phrase. I think a good idea would be to have two banjos. One good one for when you want to do some serious work, and a cheap one that you can leave out on the wall or stand and use for the quick fix. As long as the neck is good and the action is correct, you could just leave it stuffed with a towel for practice.
DD
MTBanjo - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:29:08
quote:
Originally posted by Dingoman25
John,
serious question:
the neck is damaged when the banjo is knocked out of the stand, or is just resting the neck against the stand top "anchor" for years on end also causing undue stress?
thanks,
Chris.
It is absolutely from the banjo getting knocked over. Most instruments can get away with being knocked over in their stand now and then. They aren't very heavy, and have shorter or thicker necks. Banjos are very heavy, and have a long, thin neck. That's a lot of weight that gets moving, and it all comes down on the neck when it hits the ground. If you have a guitar or mandolin get knocked over in it's stand, it's probably fine. If your banjo gets knocked over, you are VERY lucky if it doesn't break.
It can happen from kids, animals, people in a moment of thoughtlessness or clumsiness, or just putting in the stand a little "wrong", or the stand being on uneven ground.
I never even used a stand when we played shows. We're always in a tight area with cords everywhere and people squeezing around each other's instruments. Way too easy to knock it over.
Edited by - MTBanjo on 01/30/2013 08:34:46
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:33:49
quote:
Originally posted by Dingoman25
John,
serious question:
the neck is damaged when the banjo is knocked out of the stand, or is just resting the neck against the stand top "anchor" for years on end also causing undue stress?
thanks,
Chris.
Chris
Hanging the neck form a wall system will not damage it. If so, then 99% of all retailers, including Gruhn, Elderly, mandolin Brothers, are and ahve been 'damaging' instruments for over 40 years-![]()
.
Yes, the damage from a stand accident comes when the banjo impacts the floor or other hard surface after tumbling out. The banjo is weighted in such a way as to 'whiplash' the neck when it falls forward. ![]()
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:36:52
quote:
Originally posted by Dan Drabek
But the worst banjo is the one that never gets taken out of it's case. I find that I play my banjo way more often if it's right there ready to pick up. Even if it's just to play a quick tune, or try out a new phrase. I think a good idea would be to have two banjos. One good one for when you want to do some serious work, and a cheap one that you can leave out on the wall or stand and use for the quick fix. As long as the neck is good and the action is correct, you could just leave it stuffed with a towel for practice.
DD
No, the worst case scenario is a banjo that cant be played because the neck is busted from a stand, trust me. Why not leave the banjo in the case, flat on the floor, with the lid open? You can then 'see' that its there. This is why i like that wall hanger. You can 'see' it, but its secure at all times.![]()
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:40:43
quote:
Originally posted by Dave1climber
The "best banjo stand" is just an accident waiting to happen.
The only stand I use here is the Hercules ultimate, with cam locking action, and I have the legs bracketed down to the floor and the stand is in a area by itself. The banjo cannot tumble out of it. But its the only stand I'll use, and only in that situation (bracketed down). Unless someone wants to get that stand and go to that extreme of securing it, I don't recommend any stand, from a luthier's perspective.
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:43:09
quote:
Originally posted by From Greylock to Bean Blossom
John,
Do you not see any health hazards to the neck from hanging it by the neck?
Ken
Hangers do harm Ken. As a side note to this, I just looked at my invoice program for the year 2012. I repaired 47 broken peg heads last year....32 of them were banjos. According to my 'note' sections, every one of them but 2 was from a stand accident. You do the math there......![]()
Oh, the other 2 were this: one was in a car accident and the other from a strap breaking and the banjo dropping on concrete.
Edited by - Banjophobic on 01/30/2013 08:44:42
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:52:15
quote:
Originally posted by dfwest
Holy cow - that's a lot of broken necks. What is it that knocks them off the stands? Dogs, children, marauding Huns, earthquakes...?
Dave
All of the above, plus vacuum cleaners, cheaply made stands and Murphy's law. ![]()
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:53:49
quote:
Originally posted by eagleisland
Thanks for that, John. I've just bookmarked this page and am now prepared to simply post the link the next time a "what's the best banjo stand?" thread starts on the Shopping Advice forum. Judging by past experience, it should show up within a few weeks.
Well cool-the only reason I posted this was to hopefully scare the crap out of these hardcore stand lovers. You can take a poll of other repairmen on this site and see how many necks they have repaired over the years from broken stands. I'm guessing the total number of broken instrument necks from stands, not just banjos, must be very high. Sometimes all you need are statistics to see the root cause of bad things.
Edited by - Banjophobic on 01/30/2013 08:57:19
specs - Posted - 01/30/2013: 08:56:08
Dunno, everybody I know that keeps their instruments in their cases doesn't end up playing it as much as those that hang them on the wall or stand. I keep mine hanging in my office and I end up picking it for at least a few minutes near everyday. Ever since I moved my wifes favorite guitar to a hanger from its case, she has played it easily 4x as often. I'd rather run the risk of an accident than have an unused instrument. With that said, it was clear early on that a stand wasn't a good solution with pets and toddlers running around, so onto the wall they went.
quote:
Originally posted by plunka5
Unless you are a performer...if it is not in your hands...then put it in the case and close the latches!!!I've come close too many times NOT to remember this quote now.
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 09:00:29
quote:
Originally posted by Banjophobic
quote:
Originally posted by From Greylock to Bean Blossom
John,
Do you not see any health hazards to the neck from hanging it by the neck?
Ken
Hangers do no harm Ken. As a side note to this, I just looked at my invoice program for the year 2012. I repaired 47 broken peg heads last year....32 of them were banjos. According to my 'note' sections, every one of them but 2 was from a stand accident. You do the math there......
Oh, the other 2 were this: one was in a car accident and the other from a strap breaking and the banjo dropping on concrete.
Oops-sorry for the typo earlier.
MTBanjo - Posted - 01/30/2013: 09:05:22
quote:
Originally posted by Banjophobic
quote:
Originally posted by From Greylock to Bean Blossom
John,
Do you not see any health hazards to the neck from hanging it by the neck?
Ken
Hangers do harm Ken. As a side note to this, I just looked at my invoice program for the year 2012. I repaired 47 broken peg heads last year....32 of them were banjos. According to my 'note' sections, every one of them but 2 was from a stand accident. You do the math there......
Oh, the other 2 were this: one was in a car accident and the other from a strap breaking and the banjo dropping on concrete.
Don't forget my banjo. Broken peghead. From being shipped through FedEx, packed badly.
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 09:07:54
quote:
Originally posted by MTBanjo
Don't forget my banjo. Broken peghead. From being shipped through FedEx, packed badly.
OH, right..it was Fed-ex. That must be the one I listed as "car accident"..oops. It should have read: "truck accident....Fed-Ex". Hows it holding up?
MTBanjo - Posted - 01/30/2013: 09:21:49
John, it's great! I'm finally getting the set up dialed in (I'm no expert...yet), and it's sounding great. Hasn't broken again. ![]()
Specs: I know what you mean, but really, if you play banjo, you play banjo. Not playing it because of two extra steps: remembering that it exists, and opening the case, is more of a personal problem, than a real argument for keeping a banjo out of its case. For beginners it does make a difference having it easily accessible. But if you want to play banjo, having to realize you have a banjo without it staring you in the face, and opening the case, are pretty easily overcome obstacles.
Whether the very real threat of a broken neck is worth it to someone, in order for it to be that much easier to play, is up to each person, in the end.
MTBanjo - Posted - 01/30/2013: 09:23:40
Sounds like wall hanging is the best of both worlds. Can't get knocked over, and it's right there, ready to grab.
stelling man - Posted - 01/30/2013: 09:25:33
Thanks for posting that John, It's the same thing some of us on the HO have preaching for years..
STELLING MAN
Montanarick - Posted - 01/30/2013: 09:38:14
If you must use a stand.....put in the corner (impossible to walk past it) of a room that only you are aloud to go into......that's what I do....Although I totally agree with John's sage advice.....I don't floss as often as I should either.....even though my dentist has told me so often why I should![]()
specs - Posted - 01/30/2013: 09:53:32
quote:
Originally posted by MTBanjo
Specs: I know what you mean, but really, if you play banjo, you play banjo. Not playing it because of two extra steps: remembering that it exists, and opening the case, is more of a personal problem, than a real argument for keeping a banjo out of its case. For beginners it does make a difference having it easily accessible. But if you want to play banjo, having to realize you have a banjo without it staring you in the face, and opening the case, are pretty easily overcome obstacles.
Whether the very real threat of a broken neck is worth it to someone, in order for it to be that much easier to play, is up to each person, in the end.
Quite often for me it is not the "realize I have a banjo" as much as having the time/inclination of getting it. Situations vary, I can't just leave a case in the middle of the room. Or say the kids eating or taking a bath, running 15ft away and getting my banjo off the wall and bringing it into the bathroom to play while i watch him is doable -- digging out of a case not so much. Sure obstacles can be overcome; but why put more obstacles in your way than you have to? I'm just saying from my amateur experience, people that keep the instruments available end up playing them more often. But yes, it is up to every person to weigh the risks vs. benefits. I'm glad to hear the experts think the wall hangers are an acceptable solution.
Dan Drabek - Posted - 01/30/2013: 10:00:53
quote:
Originally posted by Banjophobic
quote:
Why not leave the banjo in the case, flat on the floor, with the lid open? You can then 'see' that its there.
For me, that's the best choice and is pretty much what I do. But mine is sitting on top of a low table rather than the floor. Same thing with my guitar, except I keep the lid closed with just one latch hooked. If we had kids running around our house, I would probably have to do something else. :->
DD
From Greylock to Bean Blossom - Posted - 01/30/2013: 10:08:05
Thanks John, I have been thinking of getting wall hangers because i like to keep my banjos where I can grab them quickly and I have worried about them being on stands.
ken
Edited by - From Greylock to Bean Blossom on 01/30/2013 10:08:27
Dingoman25 - Posted - 01/30/2013: 10:19:36
Thanks Zach & John.
OK, banjo's now in its (locked) case, and I'll think about the best place to mount a wall hanger.
My office is brick walled, so I'll use a sheet of 3 ply as well to protect the back.
Good post John.
Chris.
Ks_5-picker - Posted - 01/30/2013: 10:20:41
John,I think you're right. I also have the same opinion of soft cases.The strap on a blue heron case I had came unhooked and broke the neck on a banjo I had.
erikforgod - Posted - 01/30/2013: 11:21:34
I never use a stand....I always keep my banjos wrapped in bubble wrap inside their sturdy gig-bags and leaning against the corner of the room behind the bed fretboard down....
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 11:41:56
Ok, now I'm ready for the full frontal assault from the stand makers..........![]()
SReynolds - Posted - 01/30/2013: 11:51:37
I do like the looks of a banjo restsing in place on its stand. It is also very easy to grab abd set a spell to pick a song or two I'm working on (learning not writing)
I was reading stories similar to this one month ago and decided that if, for some reason, it tumbled, then I couldn't play it AT ALL. So, out comes that durn case.
I set it right on the floor, next to the living room chair. Yes, it is in the way and it looks dumb, but I'm not about to hide the thing inside a closet.
I now use the stand when I take breaks from playing. Setting the banjo down inside the case is alot like work, especially when it has a strap on it, as it don't want to fit inside the case.
bluejazz - Posted - 01/30/2013: 12:20:29
I found myself kind of speechless when I first heard this during a lesson last week. I just finished building a pretty nice mahogany stand designed for a resonator banjo or guitar. And instantly, upon hearing this I find its value plummeting. Geez, just like my stock market experiences. :-)
Oh well, I have a brother-in-law who plays guitar and spends the rest of his time trying to figure out new ways to use his political views to irritate me. Maybe I will give the stand to him.
Edited by - bluejazz on 01/30/2013 12:22:26
MTBanjo - Posted - 01/30/2013: 12:21:49
quote:
Originally posted by specs
quote:
Originally posted by MTBanjo
Specs: I know what you mean, but really, if you play banjo, you play banjo. Not playing it because of two extra steps: remembering that it exists, and opening the case, is more of a personal problem, than a real argument for keeping a banjo out of its case. For beginners it does make a difference having it easily accessible. But if you want to play banjo, having to realize you have a banjo without it staring you in the face, and opening the case, are pretty easily overcome obstacles.
Whether the very real threat of a broken neck is worth it to someone, in order for it to be that much easier to play, is up to each person, in the end.
Quite often for me it is not the "realize I have a banjo" as much as having the time/inclination of getting it. Situations vary, I can't just leave a case in the middle of the room. Or say the kids eating or taking a bath, running 15ft away and getting my banjo off the wall and bringing it into the bathroom to play while i watch him is doable -- digging out of a case not so much. Sure obstacles can be overcome; but why put more obstacles in your way than you have to? I'm just saying from my amateur experience, people that keep the instruments available end up playing them more often. But yes, it is up to every person to weigh the risks vs. benefits. I'm glad to hear the experts think the wall hangers are an acceptable solution.
I understand, and even agree. To be honest, my banjo spends most of its time on my couch. But I have no kids, a very well behaved dog, and if I'm having people over I put it in its case. I still remember the days where if my banjo was in its case, under the bed...there it would stay. For weeks, sometimes. I guess I'm just past that point now. I'm going to play banjo, even if I need to drive across town to go pick it up!
PickSLicker - Posted - 01/30/2013: 12:44:57
What goes on in y'alls houses? I've had kids, Dogs, Drunks etc...,At home , on stage. Never once have I had an instument fall off it's stand. Never even seen it happen.
Montanarick - Posted - 01/30/2013: 12:54:21
quote:You're only telling the truth.....those of us that use stands are taking a risk....I'm re-evaluating.....
Originally posted by Banjophobic
Ok, now I'm ready for the full frontal assault from the stand makers..........
Montanarick - Posted - 01/30/2013: 12:57:13
quote:I should have clarified...my kids are grown and long gone.....when they were little nothing was safe........I would have kept my banjos in a vault!
Originally posted by PickSLicker
What goes on in y'alls houses? I've had kids, Dogs, Drunks etc...,At home , on stage. Never once have I had an instument fall off it's stand. Never even seen it happen.
banjo.1313 - Posted - 01/30/2013: 13:04:02
I shamefully admit, I use a stand. it, however, is in my office where nobody else goes except my wife and she steers clear of my banjo cause she doesn't want me to have to replace/fix it and listen to my grumbling
BanjoRW - Posted - 01/30/2013: 13:22:29
Murrell Thixton, of Sullivan Banjos, confirms that it's fine to use a wall hanger. Just to be safe, though, I used 3-inch decking screws to attach the hanger to the stud.
picKen - Posted - 01/30/2013: 13:43:48
I'm no business man John, but it seems to me that you should be telling everyone to always use a stand. ![]()
Banjophobic - Posted - 01/30/2013: 13:51:06
quote:
Originally posted by bluejazz
I found myself kind of speechless when I first heard this during a lesson last week. I just finished building a pretty nice mahogany stand designed for a resonator banjo or guitar. And instantly, upon hearing this I find its value plummeting. Geez, just like my stock market experiences. :-)
Oh well, I have a brother-in-law who plays guitar and spends the rest of his time trying to figure out new ways to use his political views to irritate me. Maybe I will give the stand to him.
Your stand may be much better designed, and for banjos, than most that are currently marketed. Maybe I should slip in a caveat here. Ok, If you own a stand that will not tip over, under any circumstances, and or your banjo is located in an area where it will not be touched, except by you and you know that it will never fall out regardless of this, then forget this thread.
Ok there, that should cover my rear end a little....![]()
Edited by - Banjophobic on 01/30/2013 13:52:42
MTBanjo - Posted - 01/30/2013: 14:07:25
quote:
Originally posted by PickSLicker
What goes on in y'alls houses? I've had kids, Dogs, Drunks etc...,At home , on stage. Never once have I had an instument fall off it's stand. Never even seen it happen.
Well, it's one of those things. I've never seen or experienced flying through the windshield of my truck after hitting something, because I wasn't wearing my seatbelt. But I sure wear my seatbelt, all the time.
Some people don't.
Joe the banjo guy - Posted - 01/30/2013: 14:16:47
A note on the wall hangers, I keep all of my instruments on wall hangers around the house. I really believe, as John says, that they're safe there if the hanger has been properly attached, i.e., into the stud.
I'm either incompetent at using my stud finder, or something freakish happened, because recently one of my hangers came out of the wall with a beloved Guild Starfire hollow body electric in it. Still playable, but there's some significant damage that may not be repairable.
Anyway, I still use the wall hangers, but make SURE they're anchored in a stud.
erikforgod - Posted - 01/30/2013: 14:17:53
quote:
Originally posted by Montanarick
quote:I should have clarified...my kids are grown and long gone.....when they were little nothing was safe........I would have kept my banjos in a vault!
Originally posted by PickSLicker
What goes on in y'alls houses? I've had kids, Dogs, Drunks etc...,At home , on stage. Never once have I had an instument fall off it's stand. Never even seen it happen.
Ok my 6 month old is beginning to crawl...now I am worried HELP!!!!
Steven M - Posted - 01/30/2013: 14:34:49
A previous poster bemoaned 'digging' out the banjo from the case.
I've just timed how long it takes me to get mine out of its case and it took all of 3 seconds. It took me much longer to put the picks on to my satisfaction.
Case, every time!
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.