DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online banjo teacher.
Weekly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, banjo news and more.
|
Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/204249
J-Walk - Posted - 04/10/2011: 17:30:45
Does anybody play this tune? It's one of those new old time tunes written by Steve Mason, of the Alferd Packer String Band:

Steve looks amazingly like another Steve I know.
I discovered this tune a few years ago, but playing it was well beyond my skill level back then, so I forgot about it (except for the excellent title). It's on a CD that seems to be out of print. If it's still available, it's difficult to figure out how to buy it.
In any case, I ran across it again today, and (with a few more years of playing experience) I'm impressed. It's really a great tune -- perhaps better than most "real" old time tunes. You'll find two jam recordings of it here:
Key of D.
I think I'll write it up as a Tune Of The Week backup, in case one of the scheduled contributors flakes out. But there's really not much to say about it, except that it's an exceptionally cool tune that's fun to play. I don't think anyone else has recorded it. So if you play it, please post an MP3 so I'll have something to link to if this backup TOTW ever happens.
Kitt - Posted - 04/10/2011: 17:53:39
Yeah! That's a mighty fine tune. I found it on there three times. The last one had a more crusty aka title attached to it. The first one was my favorite of the three, as the fiddles were singing proudly.
banjo_brad - Posted - 04/10/2011: 18:13:12
I listened to the first appearance on that page, and really had a hard time differntiating between "Sam and Ella" and "Sally Slapped..." they are almost the same.
Guess it's another example of "only one OT tune, but 4 different names."
-B-
J-Walk - Posted - 04/10/2011: 18:33:34
Well, they are both in D, both have 8 measures per part, and they use the same three chords. But those criteria hold for hundreds of tunes.
But if you play them, they are VERY different. Both are great tunes, but I think Flounder is far superior in the fun-ness of playing factor. Especially that ascending scale in the A part. It took me a while to figure it out. It's way simple, and I was expecting something more complicated.
Maybe we'll give it a shot on Friday at the TOTMC jam.
BANJOJUDY - Posted - 04/10/2011: 18:41:49
Someone in ABQ plays this tune frequently at jams. After reading more on this thread, I discovered the mp3 from Carp Camp (Winfield) - and this fellow goes there every year.
It is a great tune - thanks for bringing it to the Hangout - think I'll play it this evening.
Judy
RG - Posted - 04/10/2011: 21:04:55
Great name for a band, Alferd Packer was accused of cannibalism in 1874 when a mining party he was with got stuck in a Colorado Rockies blizzard. Parker escaped before he could be brought to trial, but was recaptured in 1883 in Wyoming and sentenced to death for manslaughter, but the sentence was overturned due to ex post facto law. As a University of Colorado alum, I always laughed at the name of the University cafeteria which was named the "Alferd Packer Grill". Coincidently, after his recapture Packer served a jail sentence, was paroled and later served as a guard for the Denver Post...it was rumored that he was a vegetarian for the last years of his life. During his trial it was claimed by the prosecution that "...there were 7 Democrats in Pitkin county and you (Packer) ate 6 of them"...
Clawdan - Posted - 04/11/2011: 06:58:44
Hey John,
Couldn't find that tune in the listening section. Did I go wrong? You going to play it to get us going on it at Salome this weekend?
Dan
bluemule_77 - Posted - 04/11/2011: 07:28:08
Dan,
You may have been following the link for the band rather than the second link to the Carp Camp tune page. (?)
Brian
ramjo - Posted - 04/11/2011: 08:11:56
quote:
Originally posted by RG
Great name for a band, Alferd Packer was accused of cannibalism in 1874 when a mining party he was with got stuck in a Colorado Rockies blizzard. Parker escaped before he could be brought to trial, but was recaptured in 1883 in Wyoming and sentenced to death for manslaughter, but the sentence was overturned due to ex post facto law. As a University of Colorado alum, I always laughed at the name of the University cafeteria which was named the "Alferd Packer Grill". Coincidently, after his recapture Packer served a jail sentence, was paroled and later served as a guard for the Denver Post...it was rumored that he was a vegetarian for the last years of his life. During his trial it was claimed by the prosecution that "...there were 7 Democrats in Pitkin county and you (Packer) ate 6 of them"...
RG--that's the best story I've heard in at least two weeks!
J-Walk - Posted - 04/11/2011: 10:22:38
Yeppers, you'll hear that one in Salome this weekend, Dan.
FWIW, I made a video of one of those jam tracks -- just to make the tune a bit more findable on the Web.
![]() VIDEO: Sally Smacked Me With A Flounder (click to view) |
Clawdan - Posted - 04/12/2011: 07:20:03
Hey Brian,
Still time to get on your horse and ride over to Salome!!!! We'll be there Thursday.
Thanks for the vid link J. Yep, a good one.
Dan
Edited by - Clawdan on 04/12/2011 07:20:36
wormpicker - Posted - 04/12/2011: 07:38:23
I might make it to Salome after all! And I'm working on Flounder. (great tune!)
Paul
cbcarlisle - Posted - 04/12/2011: 10:40:44
Ya know how some fiddle tunes have the name in the rhythm of the melody? Like, "Whistle up a tune called SOL JERS JOY."
Listenin to it, seems like this tune oughta be called, "Sally Up And Smacked Me With a Flounder."
J-Walk - Posted - 04/12/2011: 11:03:22
That's a good point, Curt. How 'bout this for lyrics?
A Part:
Sally up and smacked me
Sally up and smacked me
Sally up and smacked me with a flounder that was very flat
Sally up and smacked me
Sally up and smacked me
Sally up and smacked me with a fish
B Part:
Sally up and smacked me with a flounder
Sally up and smacked me with a flounder
Sally up and smacked me with a flounder
And the flounder it was very very flat
wormpicker - Posted - 04/12/2011: 18:57:57
quote:
Originally posted by J-Walk
How 'bout this for lyrics?
Very catchy!
J-Walk - Posted - 04/12/2011: 19:30:48
I was hoping to lure you back here with some good lyrics. You took the bait, chum.
wormpicker - Posted - 04/12/2011: 20:00:28
I really hope we don't go on trading barbs like this. Let's reel it in, shall we?
wormpicker - Posted - 04/12/2011: 20:43:33
How could you say such a thing, Brian? Anyway, long time, no see. Drop me a line sometime.
bluemule_77 - Posted - 04/13/2011: 06:27:14
Yeah, sorry; that was crappie of me. Really, I was just casting about for puns.
We'll tackle that drive to AZ sometime soon.
wormpicker - Posted - 04/13/2011: 06:58:39
Let's just cut this off and get back to music.
So, anybody try out that new clip-on electronic tuna?
Anybody know Paddy on the Pike?
J-Walk - Posted - 04/13/2011: 07:30:35
I don't play Paddy on the Pike, but I do play St. Anne's Rod & Reel.
chasgrav - Posted - 04/13/2011: 07:57:12
It takes a lot to lure me back over to the BHO, but I do weigh in occasionally.
bluemule_77 - Posted - 04/13/2011: 13:06:13
quote:
Originally posted by chasgrav
It takes a lot to lure me back over to the BHO, but I do weigh in occasionally.
Glad you're on board.
J-Walk - Posted - 04/13/2011: 15:57:59
At first, I thought these puns were just an accident. But now I think you're doing it on porpoise.
banjo_brad - Posted - 04/13/2011: 16:41:20
You gonna record that tuna and get it in a can, [b]J-Walk[/b]?
-B-
bluemule_77 - Posted - 04/13/2011: 18:09:10
I know the Brits and the Yanks are going to get these jokes... but what about the Fins?
J-Walk - Posted - 04/13/2011: 18:57:26
You and me both. I have to lie down. I'm getting a bad haddock.
wormpicker - Posted - 04/13/2011: 19:52:06
I have nothing really to add to this conversation. I'm just replying for the halibut.
Paul R - Posted - 04/13/2011: 20:56:08
I was having a whale of a time, but this is just too much. I'm getting swamped. I think I'll go listen to some new wave music now.
leemysliwiec - Posted - 04/25/2011: 13:38:13
As you will see in a post about another subject, this is one of my favorite tunes. How great that you and others have discovered. Whenever I play it , other musicians like it....Thanks for the post.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.