Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


 All Forums
 Banjo Hangout Web Site
 Improvements and Suggestions
 ARCHIVED TOPIC: Limit photo SIZE!


Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/197826

rudy - Posted - 01/27/2011:  10:09:56


Hi Eric,
I think it's just through general ignorance by posters, but large photo sizes in topics do not play well with many browsers.

There really is nothing to be gained on most posts by the addition of multi-meg picture sizes and widths beyond 640 pixels. It also has a number of other negative results such as a viewer having to scroll repeatedly left to right to read the text, slow load times for topics (even on broadband connections) and usage of server capacity.

It seems that it might be a good idea to limit photos to a web-friendly size and that way it would make the hangout a much more enjoyable experiance. This is really particularly apparent in topics in the building and repair forum where there are tons of photos documenting a particular build.

Is it just me that sees this as being mildly aggravating?

davidtoc - Posted - 01/27/2011:  11:29:11


Seems like that would have to be something on the server side. A lot of people are lucky to figure out how to connect their cameras to their computers, let alone resize their photos to a screen-friendly size.

Also, I'm usually really glad to see high-resolution photos because the detail is so much better. YOu can always right-click and choose view-image if you want to see the whole image at once w/o scrolling.

dave


Edited by - davidtoc on 01/27/2011 11:41:09

minstrelmike - Posted - 01/27/2011:  11:55:34


The oversized pix bother me.

I generally quit reading a topic once I have to scroll sideways to see the text.

schlange - Posted - 01/27/2011:  12:28:44


We already set it up so you can attach photos to posts. If you do it this way, you'll never have the problems you're talking about above.

Problem is, some members include images in their actual posts, for whatever reason. That's where the problem lies. I would suggest simply telling them they should attach the pics instead of putting them in their post.

drew-gurbach - Posted - 01/27/2011:  13:33:23


Maybe a BHO How To section? I gave up on a lot of things because I ran into trouble.

greenhorn - Posted - 01/27/2011:  13:54:20


I like the large pictures. You can see much more detail. I find the thumbnail sized pictures more annoying.

schlange - Posted - 01/27/2011:  15:09:27


quote:
Originally posted by greenhorn

I like the large pictures. You can see much more detail. I find the thumbnail sized pictures more annoying.


The point of thumbnails is to show you a preview, which you can then click to enlarge. Large photos take a long time to load up, and they blow out the layout as explained above. Basically, thumbnails give people a choice--large photos give you no options. People generally like choice.

robertsart - Posted - 01/27/2011:  15:15:58


I agree, I find BIG images annoying too.

That being said, I like to include the image right in the post so it's there to see, and you don't have to open the attachment. I think there is more of a chance that people will actually look at it, if they don't have to click on a thumbnail to view it. I just make sure the image is a reasonable size. If it's a big image, I just attach it.

Folks can just look at this:



And not have to open this:



   

rudy - Posted - 01/28/2011:  06:51:01


Hi Eric,

quote:
We already set it up so you can attach photos to posts. If you do it this way, you'll never have the problems you're talking about above.


Even if I adopt the "attach images to post" method it doesn't improve my viewing experience because the next guy doesn't do it. Yes, if we all adopted the same usage the world would be a better place, but as long as the current software allows adding large resolution pics directly to the posts then we'll continue to experience the same problem. Nothing changes.

quote:
Problem is, some members include images in their actual posts, for whatever reason. That's where the problem lies. I would suggest simply telling them they should attach the pics instead of putting them in their post.


That's a good suggestion, but the problem is as soon as the current thread has lapsed beyond the current page of topics then people will post the large format photos again. How many times have you seen someone post a simple question that had several great answers on the page previous to the currently shown page?

By the responses posted so far I'd say that there is a good reason why people like to post the photos directly in the topic and many people don't want to click to see the larger photo as suggested above. As far as viewers that want to see the full sized image, I do believe that making the image clickable might easily solve that problem. As long as the Hangout doesn't limit photo size in the photo storage area (a good thing, and a big thanks for that...) it just seems that it would be a good idea to automatically cap photos at the 640 by 480 size. It seems that it might be easy to implement as I notice that photos are automatically stored in full, "medium" and thumbnail size on the server already.

I'm betting that there are many readers that skip really interesting topics because of having to scroll the thread to read the text, and that's a shame.

Don't take my question as being overly-critical, as the Banjo Hangout is absolutely the best website that I've been affiliated with. It's just a suggestion for improving the Banjo Hangout viewing experience in a fairly benign behind-the-scenes way.

Hi David,

quote:
Seems like that would have to be something on the server side. A lot of people are lucky to figure out how to connect their cameras to their computers, let alone resize their photos to a screen-friendly size.



That's my point exactly! That way we don't limit the hangout experience by imposing unrealistic expectations on less-than-technically-savvy users.


Edited by - rudy on 01/28/2011 07:08:24

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

4.882813E-02