DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online banjo teacher.
Weekly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, banjo news and more.
I should’ve listened to Laurence D, who mentioned a few years ago that they’ll likely move the goalposts. I worked it up to 3,241 watch hours, but the rug's been pulled out from under me,,, sheesh. And to think they've run ads on my videos for 4 years already, but no loot coming my way - cheap, lowdown scammers, I say!
Edited by - chuckv97 on 11/19/2026 17:48:00
quote:
Originally posted by NopixChuck, Do you have a Patreon or Venmo account?
I've seen people that do far less, asking for far more.
No, I never went that route. All I did was have a PayPal Tip Jar in the comments section on each video. I'm done,, no more wild goose chases. Busking provides mucho more $$.
thanks for the concern, Steve.
Edited by - chuckv97 on 11/19/2026 17:42:18
Ouch for sure. YouTube has moved the goalpost like this at least 2-3 times in the 13 years I've been on YouTube.
There are a gazillion small YouTube channels like yours and mine that are too small to be included in the ad reviews, but YT has no problem at all monetizing all these channels for itself. Think about that for a minute. YT collects pennies from ads across *millions* of small channels, it does ad up. So it's good enough for them to monetize for themselves, just cut the creator out of the loop.
I think small creators need to band together and go after those stolen revenues. And I consider them to be stolen. I think you might agree Chuck. It sure feels that way to me.
In a related matter, google (which owns YouTube) recently changed how it collects money from advertisers ( the business that place all those ads) so that it can basically reach in to an advertiser's budget, grab it all and ignore their ad placement parameters. You can google something like "google upsets AdSense advertisers" and there's a ton of info out there from pissed off advertisers.
So I guess when the best expression of humanity through all this new technical innovation over the last few decades is ... advertising revenue?? The highest expression of humanity is ads? Google and YouTube rely on it. They create that reality. Now we should all sit down shut up and be content ... is what we are supposed to do.
All this is happening because the roll-out of artificial intelligence is not going as planned, and ad reviews have dropped A LOT and this is their way to keep milking the cash cows while they still can.
Sorry for the long post but this hits a nerve.
I just spent a few minutes with google chat to ask about YouTube ads. There are approximately 66 million tiny channels on YouTube that are not monetized. Those channels generate between 1.5 and 3.5 billion dollars in annual ad revenues that YouTube keeps for itself.
I was also able to plot out all the changes YT made over the years just for y own curiosity. Very briefly, until 2017 small channels could be monetized, then YT put a stop to that and canceled monetization on all small channels. So for a few years no ads would show up at all on those channels. Then in 2020 YT got a bright idea, licking its chops, and decided to place ads on those channels after all. But if you the creator wants a piece of our ad pie, you gotta jump through all these hoops while dancing a jig, juggling plates while riding a unicycle, and you better darn well hold you mouth right.
Edited by - banjoy on 11/19/2026 20:03:01
At a Bluegrass camp/workshop 5 years ago I heard a member for a well known Seattle group talk about YT.. Several hits submitted over several months averaging a whopping $8 per month.. That would be $1.33 per month for each member.. There are street beggers in 3rd world countries that could play their plastic $2 flute and do much better than YT.
quote:
Originally posted by banjoyI just spent a few minutes with google chat to ask about YouTube ads. There are approximately 66 million tiny channels on YouTube that are not monetized. Those channels generate between 1.5 and 3.5 billion dollars in annual ad revenues that YouTube keeps for itself.
I was also able to plot out all the changes YT made over the years just for y own curiosity. Very briefly, until 2017 small channels could be monetized, then YT put a stop to that and canceled monetization on all small channels. So for a few years no ads would show up at all on those channels. Then in 2020 YT got a bright idea, licking its chops, and decided to place ads on those channels after all. But if you the creator wants a piece of our ad pie, you gotta jump through all these hoops while dancing a jig, juggling plates while riding a unicycle, and you better darn well hold you mouth right.
Exactly, Frank. I looked into it quite a bit before I started the channel but never thought they'd double the requirements for monetization. Oh well, I had fun making the videos, I lesrned a lot, it got me practicing more, and met some nice folks online..... but, now what am I gonna do with all this extra time? Crickets....?
Chuck. I remember about a year or two ago when you had just under 1,000 subscribers and I think you announced that you were going to go for it, and I've watched as you've gone from that to over 4,000 subscribers which is inspirational to me. It seems to me you've played by the rules and even when you attained their base thresholds there was still some small detail that you didn't meet, oh so sorry, no ad revenue for you! Now they've done it again. I empathize with your frustration(s).
I hope you continue to make and post videos.
Thanks, Frank. I’ll keep making videos, just not as many and maybe better quality - I rushed a lot of them due to chasing the Blarney Stone. Busking is where it’s at, baby!
(although these “karaoke-type buskers” that drag in à wagon load of electronic equipment these days are faking their way into people’s hearts,,, sheesh, I hate modern crap…… and, HEY YOU KIDS,,, GET OFFA MY LAWN!! )
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.