Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Let's just admit that people pay a lot to have Gibson on the headstock

Page: 1  2   Last Page (2) 

Nov 16, 2026 - 6:59:34 AM
likes this
4185 posts since 12/31/2005

There is a nice-looking 1929 3 double conversion in the classifieds for $9K. I see Grich era banjos in the same price range. At the same time, high end custom banjos from top builders from the same era don’t command such value. How does this make sense? If there is value in a prewar rim and components, the Grich era banjos don't give you that. So how are they approaching the same price points?

The Gibson company that produced the 1929 banjo is not really the same company that produced the Grich era banjos. The location, machinery, people, and components are all different. But two different banjos, from essentially two different companies, made in two different eras, out of different components command a premium nobody else gets.

This might just be an application of the 30-year rule (whatever is hot on the used market at any given point is whatever everyone wanted but could not afford 30 years ago when they were younger and broke). But I would love to hear an argument that these prices are based on sonic merit.

Nov 16, 2026 - 7:25:36 AM
likes this

chuckv97

Canada

80965 posts since 10/5/2013

I’ve always wanted that logo on my banjo but couldn’t afford the price tag. About 8 years ago I bought a TB-1 conversion from Jim Britton - Hatfield neck, Blaylock ring - with the coveted Gibson logo on the peghead, even though it’s not inlayed at a Gibson factory. The pot , co-rod, resonator, and one reso screw are from 1930 so I figure it’s “Gibby” enough.




Nov 16, 2026 - 7:41:49 AM

2700 posts since 5/19/2018

Having had/have more than a few PreWWII Gibson instruments over the decades, I can say from experience that most of the instruments that come from the hands of today’s top builders far exceeds in quality and build any instrument that left the Gibson factory back in the 20’s-40’s.

The prices that are being asked for the Vintage instruments is in large part based on rarity, myth and to some degree, perceived sound quality....and mainly, lots of folks just buy a name. 


 

Edited by - Alvin Conder on 11/16/2026 07:52:01

Nov 16, 2026 - 7:44:16 AM
like this

16861 posts since 10/30/2008

Greg Rich banjos OTHER THAN GRANADAS aren't approaching $9000, in my watching of the vintage dealers' asking prices.

Greg Rich Granadas seem to have a tremendous appeal to the bluegrass pickers. Maybe it was Sonny Osborne's early approval on a Grand Ole Opry broadcast (which drew hundreds of orders for Gibson). Greg Rich Gibson 3s, 4s, and 75s and 250s have never broken $5000 as far as I've seen.

I have seen mint GRE Granadas with asking prices at $10K and slightly higher. Not a lot of them, but enough to notice. They are more commonly priced at $7000 to $10K.

Neither Style 5 Deluxe nor Style 6 GRE banjos seem to have the popularity and top pricing of GRE Granadas.

Nov 16, 2026 - 7:57:05 AM
likes this

733 posts since 7/24/2021

Is it Hype ? I’m not sure, but I seemed to have drank the cool aid on the whole GRE banjos. So much so I won’t hardly even look at a banjo from 70s up till 87. Why ? There has to be banjos from that period that blow away some Greg Rich models… right? Either way Mr Murphy I seem to be guilty . Also there are great banjos from boutique builders to Gold tone that are kicking the door down ! Why are GRE banjos near the same price level to Pete war is kinda beyond me. But I am guilty. That’s was liberating just admitting it. lol

Nov 16, 2026 - 8:04:11 AM
likes this

2013 posts since 1/9/2012

To satisfy that headstock itch for $525, you can buy an authentic, ~1930 Gibson from me, as listed in the BHO classifieds. ;)


 

Nov 16, 2026 - 8:04:58 AM
likes this

51 posts since 2/23/2020

After years of being broke and not able to afford a gibson, nack in May I took some money out of my retirement account and "re invested" it in a 2017 goldstar J.D. that I was watching on Craigslist for almost a year.it has a G on the headstock and I couldn't be happier with the tone. The only thing I don't like is the blank inlay block but I can live with that.

Nov 16, 2026 - 8:17:52 AM
likes this

773 posts since 4/27/2008

quote:
Originally posted by Alvin Conder

Having had/have more than a few PreWWII Gibson instruments over the decades, I can say from experience that most of the instruments that come from the hands of today’s top builders far exceeds in quality and build any instrument that left the Gibson factory back in the 20’s-40’s.

The prices that are being asked for the Vintage instruments is in large part based on rarity, myth and to some degree, perceived sound quality....and mainly, lots of folks just buy a name. 


 

 


One day an original uncut archtop with original neck will bring big money when rarity hits them.  Based on how many cut rims prewars I see for sale, seems this will be sooner that later.

Nov 16, 2026 - 8:51:43 AM

4185 posts since 12/31/2005

quote:
Originally posted by The Old Timer

Greg Rich banjos OTHER THAN GRANADAS aren't approaching $9000, in my watching of the vintage dealers' asking prices.

Greg Rich Granadas seem to have a tremendous appeal to the bluegrass pickers. Maybe it was Sonny Osborne's early approval on a Grand Ole Opry broadcast (which drew hundreds of orders for Gibson). Greg Rich Gibson 3s, 4s, and 75s and 250s have never broken $5000 as far as I've seen.

I have seen mint GRE Granadas with asking prices at $10K and slightly higher. Not a lot of them, but enough to notice. They are more commonly priced at $7000 to $10K.

Neither Style 5 Deluxe nor Style 6 GRE banjos seem to have the popularity and top pricing of GRE Granadas.


Fair point on non-Granada models.  I have, however, seen "I want" prices on other models that is creeping up there.  But your truthful point raises another interesing issue:  How much are people willing to pay for gold plating and engraving?  Apparently a lot.  Again, absolutely nothing wrong with that, but it's another example of either listening with our eyes or simply wanting to pay for something other than tone since that tone can be achieved with far cheaper models of equal quality.
https://reverb.com/item/101725290-1999-gibson-earl-scruggs-standard-resonator-banjo?utm_campaign=US-Shop_unpaid&utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=google

Nov 16, 2026 - 9:55:08 AM
likes this

Dean T

USA

4797 posts since 4/18/2024

I payed up for a late 90’s ESS to have the name on the headstock. I played it for 9 years. It was ok, sounded good, but the fit and finish wasn’t great, and needed a lot of upkeep and repair. It did not hold up well in the hot Kansas summers. I’m over it, and wouldn’t trade my Deering for another one.

Nov 16, 2026 - 10:42:14 AM

46 posts since 10/31/2025

I'd pay more NOT to have the gold plating, personally. I think it looks awfully gaudy.

Nov 16, 2026 - 11:24:31 AM

48 posts since 6/8/2015

I’ve paid a lot more for a pristine Crowe 75. I’ve paid much more for a GR 1990 Custom Shop Granada. They are each unique. And if the Granada ever goes up for sale it will be my son selling after I’m dead…he knows the value. Got some other banjos, and would love a Huber and a Deering Tenbrooks Saratoga Star but the two Mastertones are pristine, well played daily and well protected/insured/taken care of. The Granada is 37 years old! I feel lucky to have them

Nov 16, 2026 - 11:53:57 AM
Players Union Member

Hess

USA

22 posts since 3/6/2024

I feel like this is one of the biggest divisions in the banjo community. Those who swear by pre-war Gibson being the gold standard for THE banjo sound. Then those who love their modern banjos and couldn't imagine paying substantially more for something that isn't much better sound-wise.

I saw a Facebook post by Bill Evans this last week saying how much he appreciated his luthier who had to essentially remake the hooks for his pre-war Gibson to fit the warped flange because he didn't want to replace it and take the hit in value. It reminds me of those old homes with knob-and-tube wiring. Hard pass.

For me, it comes down to paying much more for the banjo purchase, then buying a new neck and tone ring conversion, and then paying for the ongoing upkeep/repair cost for the ~100 year old components. People who have that much invested also have a big incentive to convince themselves that their banjo is now God's gift to the bluegrass community whether it sounds amazing or not.

It's hard for me to see the value when there are so many solid great sounding modern banjos that are around half the price. I'm also not a collector, so I don't attribute much value to something just because it may be old or rare.

Edited by - Hess on 11/16/2026 11:54:53

Nov 16, 2026 - 12:04:53 PM
likes this

488 posts since 10/3/2010

IMHO, it's always the rule of supply and demand. That's what keeps the prices up, (sometimes artificially).
Between the time of 1966 and 1973 there became a cottage industry of builders, (including Asian) some good and bad, that had access to the parts needed to make " masterclones" of every kind.
As far as banjos go, this is what spurred Gibson towards getting the "fit and finish" corrected.
We have to thank Dave Kennedy, Bob Day, and Doug Hutchins along with Greg Rich that provided guidance that produced a better quality of banjo with some being exceptional instruments.
Unfortunately, I doubt that Gibson will ever build any banjos with any regularity again. So goes the supply/demand price situation.

Nov 16, 2026 - 12:07:15 PM
like this

banjoy

USA

12080 posts since 7/1/2006

Okay, I admit it.

Nov 16, 2026 - 12:24:41 PM
Players Union Member

Flyguy

USA

46 posts since 1/14/2024

When I started playing banjo in the late 70’s all the pros were playing old Gibsons. Friends, fellow pickers were playing 70’s Gibsons. I bought a new Stelling in the 80’s which was a fine banjo but I then played an early 30’s original flathead 3. That was a magical life changing moment. They wanted 75K for it, ouch. Finally in 1990 I bought a new Granada and was happy with that, but that old flathead kept haunting me. 2007 bought a Huber Jim Mills a very fine banjo. Recently acquired a 29 TB3 double conversion and I finally satisfied that old Gibson urge. Is it better than my Granada or Huber, probably not but like me it is old and I like that. You can change tone but don’t think you can get better than an old Gibson, there is just a sweetness to it.

Nov 16, 2026 - 12:36:34 PM

48 posts since 6/8/2015

My previous post may have come off sounding snooty which was not intended. My family was my priority for the last 40+ years so in recent years I had been playing a very good Recording King banjo that I still play a lot. I was not looking for another banjo but these found me after the kids were grown and out of the house and I could afford some nice things. When my wife gave me the nod it was a done deal. I could never see myself spending $150K for an old flathead banjo…I would much rather buy 20 new banjos that play and sound great

Edited by - Mastertone Banjo on 11/16/2026 12:38:39

Nov 16, 2026 - 12:41:58 PM

4185 posts since 12/31/2005

quote:
Originally posted by Flyguy

When I started playing banjo in the late 70’s all the pros were playing old Gibsons. Friends, fellow pickers were playing 70’s Gibsons. I bought a new Stelling in the 80’s which was a fine banjo but I then played an early 30’s original flathead 3. That was a magical life changing moment. They wanted 75K for it, ouch. Finally in 1990 I bought a new Granada and was happy with that, but that old flathead kept haunting me. 2007 bought a Huber Jim Mills a very fine banjo. Recently acquired a 29 TB3 double conversion and I finally satisfied that old Gibson urge. Is it better than my Granada or Huber, probably not but like me it is old and I like that. You can change tone but don’t think you can get better than an old Gibson, there is just a sweetness to it.


The best banjos I have played and heard were old Gibsons.  But not every old Gibson I have played or heard is special.  Between incessant tweaking and adjusting for preferences, many old Gibsons, and even Grich era ones, sound average to good.  They might be capable of greatness with a good setup.  I have played Grich era banjos side-by-side with smaller builders (Yates, Davis, Huber, Sullivan, Hatfield) and the small builders easily hold their own, and at a helluva discount from the Gibson.  I'm not against Gibsons at all.  I have played some I really wanted but could not afford.  But I would agree that the best-of-the best prewar Gibsons have not been equalled.

Nov 16, 2026 - 2:37:36 PM

64 posts since 7/21/2023

It's just hilarious that most of these "Gibson" headstocks are counterfeit!

No, not "repro" or "conversion", they're counterfeit. Fakes.

Spending 4 or 5 figures on a fake will always make me chuckle

Nov 16, 2026 - 3:11:23 PM

16297 posts since 1/15/2005

quote:
Originally posted by CrazyCatLazy

It's just hilarious that most of these "Gibson" headstocks are counterfeit!

No, not "repro" or "conversion", they're counterfeit. Fakes.

Spending 4 or 5 figures on a fake will always make me chuckle


Sorry Mr. jones, but I do not think you are correct.  Most are not counterfeit and there is no intent to deceive.  If you had said, "some" I may have agreed with you.

Nov 16, 2026 - 3:18 PM

242 posts since 8/20/2025

quote:
Originally posted by CrazyCatLazy

It's just hilarious that most of these "Gibson" headstocks are counterfeit!

No, not "repro" or "conversion", they're counterfeit. Fakes.

Spending 4 or 5 figures on a fake will always make me chuckle


Just to make other people think you have a Gibson.

Any neck made with Gibson on the headstock without the express consent of Gibson is just an unlicensed knockoff. The intent of doing it is either to trick people into thinking you own a real one when you're out playing it, or to charge what you concieve to be a higher price than what it would be worth if it did not contain the G word otherwise you'd let the luthier put their name, or no name, on it.

Nov 16, 2026 - 3:40:49 PM

17217 posts since 12/2/2005

Yes, and people will pay a premium for a bottlecap "Fender" that's structurally identical to one of a lesser brand name. There's a reason companies invest money into marketing and bling.

Nov 16, 2026 - 4:15:33 PM

chuckv97

Canada

80965 posts since 10/5/2013

So you think Arthur Hatfield didn’t get Gibson’s permission to make a neck with the Gibson logo on the headstock?

Nov 16, 2026 - 4:27:25 PM

2838 posts since 10/17/2013

quote:
Originally posted by CrazyCatLazy

It's just hilarious that most of these "Gibson" headstocks are counterfeit!

No, not "repro" or "conversion", they're counterfeit. Fakes.

Spending 4 or 5 figures on a fake will always make me chuckle


It's NOT hilarious to Sullivan OR Neat OR Turtle Hill...or you name it.

It's not a laughing matter to them, to have hours of work on a neck, looked on as "counterfeit."

That's a very disparaging comment.

Your "logic" just doesn't come across very well. 

They ARE REAL conversion necks, regardless of your armchair estimation of what goes into them.

 Calling them counterfeit is just immature. There are persons who DO NOT laugh at sinking 4-5k into a conversion. 

A counterfeit will have zero Gibson parts. 

 A conversion will have about 90 percent. Not a fake. 

Edited by - ksbluegrassbanjopicker on 11/16/2026 16:35:54

Nov 16, 2026 - 4:29 PM

Owen

Canada

20020 posts since 6/5/2011

.... Further to Skip's ^^ post:   Yes, and in ignorance, some will pay double the worth of a beginner level bottle-cap banjo at a pawn shop. sad [Don't ask me how I know!!]

From the unsolicited drivel dept:  I've mentioned it before, but I have these [attached pic] in my stash, but seeing as procrastination is one of my strengths it doesn't get beyond the "idea" phase.  I figure the KitchenAid one would look good on the peghead of my "We didn't even try"* GoldTone peghead, and maybe the Kitchen Craft one would be a suitable inlay block (?) on my Morgan Monroe.

Why would other people pay 4-or-5 figures to make someone think he has one-of-who-knows-how-many Gibsons, when he could have a one-of-a-kind KitchenAid or Kitchen Craft?  devil [I think part of my hesitancy to do-the-deed is that I wonder whether anybody who might see/hear me play would actually notice/care.]

* Thank you Old Hickory / Ken Norkin. yes


 

Edited by - Owen on 11/16/2026 16:30:45

Nov 16, 2026 - 7:09:51 PM

PKM

USA

627 posts since 4/19/2011

I've always find it very humorous whenever I hear the "Greg Rich" BS hype. I have a Gibson Greg Rich era RB-4 and I am the original owner,...the neck was set crooked to the rim !!
Yes sir, the fret board is angled and not level, when compared to the rim, & tone ring. :-)))). Yeah, so you can shove your "Greg Rich era" crap where the sun doesn't shine.
36 years ago, I was teaching at University of South Florida's School of Architecture & Community Design and finally saved enough up to buy it as my first real banjo. So, in spite of its flaws, I'll never sell it, and love it because of the sentimental value, and it plays OK with a typical darker tone expected of an RB-4. But don't talk to me about fine Greg Rich craftsmanship ! I also own two Hatfields, and in quality, they far exceed what Rich produced !
Want to hear something even funnier ? I also have a newer Gold Star, (not one of the more desirable ones). and it kicks the Gibson butt in tone, playablity, fit & finish,... and it was made in Asia !!
I've been so tempted to someday go to IBMA, and hand my RB-4 to Greg Rich, and ask him, "WFT were you thinking ? Did you show up at work drunk that morning ?" :-))))

Page: 1  2   Last Page (2) 

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.1474609