DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online banjo teacher.
Weekly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, banjo news and more.
Hi everyone,
I got a cheap old 1880s Bucbee banjo with a 25" scale and a skin head. I'd like to string it up with nylguts and keep it in open A and double D.
1. Does anyone have suggestions on which set of Aquila Nylguts I should use? I prefer higher tension, and I find the descriptions on the website to be a little confusing.
2. If I did want to slap steel strings on, would that be okay? It's a rather thin neck, so not sure how it would hold up to the increased tension.
Thanks.
Best,
Bryce
Edited by - bFunk on 10/19/2026 12:54:09
Depends a lot on you. I'm assuming clawhammer as a style (based on your tunings) and your mention of steels.
If you are used to standard (medium) gauge steel strings, thin nylgut or nylon are going to drive you crazy. They take a very different attack. Then again, you may like them. Only one way to figure it out = buy a variety of gauges and see what you like.
Again, if you are used to steel, start with heavy to medium gauge nylon. Not nylgut. Stick with a wound 4th, not the solid 4th of nylgut. You can get singles from LaBella. Check out the gauges listed on the Clifford Essex Music website for their nylon "classic banjo" sets. Medium to heavy would be the place to start...IMNSHO.
After you've been playing on nylon a while, you may want to change gauges (up or down). You are the driver.
Regarding steel on the ol' Dobson...it can work...but you need to be careful. Because of the shorter scale length, I would recommend starting with light gauge steel...like 9s. I use 9.5s on my short scale. The shorter neck length works to your advantage with steels...but you'll want geared tuners (the ABM tuners from Bob Smakula work great). The geared tuners are a big plus with nylon too.
If you're paying attention to your banjo, you're not going to kill it by trying different strings.
There's a lot of badmouthing Nylguts on this forum, but I have them on both of my shorter scale Stewarts, and I love them. Yes, you have to make sure there are no sharp edges, and yes, they stretch a lot at first, but then they last forever and keep pitch beautifully.
I use Nylgut Mediums on my main A/D player, sub a classical guitar D or A for the 4th (this one does wear out). Biggest issue is that they only come in sets, but I've broken very few.
I would not put steel strings on this banjo.
Edited by - John Yerxa on 10/19/2026 19:10:03
Thanks so much for the replies everyone, all the knowledge is much appreciated.
They have some fairly fat nylons on them currently which I think is kind of killing the sound, so I’ll experiment with some slightly lower gauge strings. And I think I’ll avoid steel strings for the time being.
Any other input always appreciated.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.