Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Oct 15, 2026 - 10:38:45 PM

banjonz

New Zealand

13027 posts since 6/29/2003

Should this banjo have mediums or light gauge strings? Also, should it be tuned to A (open)?

Edited by - banjonz on 10/15/2026 22:40:41

Oct 15, 2026 - 11:28:26 PM

bFunk

USA

147 posts since 5/22/2009

Could you provide the scale length and pot size?

Also, what string gauges do you have on your full length banjos (and what scale lengths are those)? If we know that, we can figure out your preferences and give a better educated suggestion

Thanks!

Oct 16, 2026 - 4:32:14 AM

EEB

UK

469 posts since 12/2/2025

quote:
Originally posted by banjonz

Should this banjo have mediums or light gauge strings? Also, should it be tuned to A (open)?


I play an entirely original W. Temlett Snr pony banjo tuned gCGBD and opt for lighter strings when using rectified nylon. If anything, with a suitable bridge, that set-up increases volume.

But that is just my personal preference. And, as I'm sure most of us are aware, 'light' is an arbitrary and unhelpful description as applied by most nylon string manufacturers and retailers.

Edited by - EEB on 10/16/2026 04:45:33

Oct 16, 2026 - 4:35:59 AM

EEB

UK

469 posts since 12/2/2025

quote:
Originally posted by bFunk

Could you provide the scale length and pot size?

Also, what string gauges do you have on your full length banjos (and what scale lengths are those)? If we know that, we can figure out your preferences and give a better educated suggestion

Thanks!


Yes, with gut strings that calculation is necessary.

But with nylon strings we don't need to use slide-rules and mathematical formula!

Oct 16, 2026 - 5:58:01 AM
likes this

10040 posts since 9/21/2007

If I recall correctly, the Saga "Pony" was kinda/sorta a banjeaurine. Why "Pony" was chosen, I do not know. In S. S. Stewart model designation nomenclature, the "Pony banjo" was an entirely different model and size from the banjeaurine.

A banjeaurine was/is pitched a 4th higher than the regular banjo (when pitched gCGBD). This is like a standard banjo with a capo clamp at the 5th fret.

Now that said, the Saga "Pony" was sold as a wire string "travel banjo" so I doubt any of the above was a consideration in the design and marketing.

Oct 16, 2026 - 9:07:36 AM

2973 posts since 2/9/2007

It's what I'd call a banjeaurine, or a "C-scale" banjo, meant to be tuned a fourth above standard pitch. I think the scale is about 20". I'd use light strings for C pitch (cGCEG, etc.). A stout medium set (i.e. GHS PF160) ought to work tolerably at A pitch, especially if you replace the 3rd string with a wound one (as thin as you can find, like .017 or .018). That's close to the gauges of the John Hartford "Julia Belle" low-tuning set, which would also work.

My wife got one of those years ago, and wanted to tune it to standard "G" pitch, but I couldn't come up with a steel set that I thought played and sounded near enough to right tuned there. If memory serves, a mix of fluorocarbon fishing line and classical guitar strings of some sort (along with a homemade bridge) did the job (more or less).

Oct 16, 2026 - 12:36:52 PM

EEB

UK

469 posts since 12/2/2025

quote:
Originally posted by Joel Hooks

If I recall correctly, the Saga "Pony" was kinda/sorta a banjeaurine. Why "Pony" was chosen, I do not know. In S. S. Stewart model designation nomenclature, the "Pony banjo" was an entirely different model and size from the banjeaurine.


From this description my Temlett Snr 22-fret pony banjo (10"rim) c.1895 is quite a different instrument to the Stewart pony banjo.

Oct 16, 2026 - 12:38:16 PM

10040 posts since 9/21/2007

According to SSS


Oct 17, 2026 - 1:59:55 PM

298 posts since 2/16/2020

I have a 20" scale custom 5-string banjo with an 11" head. I have it tuned to open A with Julia Belle strings, though I would like to change out the fourth string from a 24w to something a little heavier. Larger gauge solid strings (think 0.018") sound kind of dead on a short scale presumably because they are just too rigid to get much vibration out of them. Wound strings are more forgiving, which is presumably why other short scale instruments like mandolins mostly use wound strings.

There is a question of how you intend to play the instrument. Fingerstyle with picks or playing with a plectrum might work better than clawhammer with strings that are heavier. I primarily play clawhammer and try to keep the string tension between about 12 and 15 lbs if I can. I use the Stringjoy tension calculator to estimate string tension.

I would be curious the kind of tension people find best for clawhammer and for 2 finger without fingerpicks. I'm assuming that the longer the scale the more tension one can use to get a decent sound.

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





0.3164063