Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Sep 21, 2026 - 6:45:18 AM
likes this
592 posts since 9/10/2003

Occasionally, at a local beginners intermediate Americana music jam , I will tune my banjo to mountain minor (second string C) and play cluck old hen or Shady Grove.
My question is what chords should the guitarist be strumming? Or should they just sit it out and let the banjo and fiddle play by themselves?
Thanks

Sep 21, 2026 - 7:28:15 AM

11736 posts since 4/23/2004

quote:
Originally posted by stumpkicker

Occasionally, at a local beginners intermediate Americana music jam , I will tune my banjo to mountain minor (second string C) and play cluck old hen or Shady Grove.
My question is what chords should the guitarist be strumming? Or should they just sit it out and let the banjo and fiddle play by themselves?
Thanks


These are Dorian mode tunes which can be backed by just two chords, the Im and VII. For "Cluck Ol Hen" (we play it in A Dorian, banjo tuned to aEADE), the backup rocks back and forth between Am & G. With your banjo tuned to gDGCD, you would want Gm and F.

Sep 21, 2026 - 8:32:36 AM

7173 posts since 3/6/2006

If playing in G, the guitarist should avoid the B string altogether. Just play chords that drone on the G and D notes. Similarly, when going down to F you can play FGC for a nice effect.

Sep 21, 2026 - 9:38:01 AM
Players Union Member

dbrooks

USA

5163 posts since 3/11/2004
Online Now

At our weekly contra dances, we use the same approach recently by Trapdoor 2. 

David

Sep 21, 2026 - 11:30:18 AM
like this
Players Union Member

Emiel

Austria

10680 posts since 1/22/2003

This video might be interesting. I have not yet analyzed what Doc Watson is doing here exactly, but maybe someone else has more time…

Sep 21, 2026 - 12:57:11 PM
likes this
Players Union Member

carlb

USA

2826 posts since 12/16/2007

quote:
Originally posted by Laurence Diehl

If playing in G, the guitarist should avoid the B string altogether. Just play chords that drone on the G and D notes. Similarly, when going down to F you can play FGC for a nice effect.


On some occasions, I've tuned the B string (2nd string) to an A and not fingered it all.

Sep 21, 2026 - 7:14:26 PM
likes this

4036 posts since 10/17/2009

My question is what chords should the guitarist be strumming? 

I don't think there is a "should". Other than to "listen". Depends on what want it to sound like, listen to how choices are just different.

Or should they just sit it out and let the banjo and fiddle play by themselves? 

Fiddle and banjo sound great together. And can especially sound great in that world, how navigates, avoids major/minor triad chord based idea. Guitar can change that in many ways.

That said, the easiest for many guitar players (esp beg at jam) to wrap head around; many just go ahead and decide to make the chord major/minor... depending on which version. In examples (Shady Grove, Cluck Old Hen) depends on which version, Dorian would use a G minor; Mixolydian would use a G major. It can still sound fine, and keep lot's of the modal sound just by nature of tune, and chord choices (these often use a VII as second chord). Nothing wrong with the sound of these, if that's what want/prefer (and some folks do)

But to keep more of the modal, or perhaps neutral sound of the the fiddle/banjo thing; (or just unsure of the harmonic space)...  ways can fit into this as mentioned (G and D notes), avoiding the third of chord, playing just the root/fifth dyad stack, or with maybe just some extension. As well might play a bit more of drone idea (even as dyad stack)... playing over what might seem should be chord change, (or at least minimal changes). Also might try weave in a bit of movement lines to compliment.

Just to point out though these modal ideas can be a bit foreign to many intermediate/beginners (esp guitar) at a jam... as most learned all music is made of major or minor chords and progressions; can have difficult time listening to modal, not imagining/imposing that major/minor chord concept. Again might be easier expectation to just to make do the major/minor chord thing in those situations.

Edited by - banjoak on 09/21/2026 19:16:29

Sep 21, 2026 - 10:17:19 PM
likes this

6503 posts since 3/11/2006

I lived and breathed Irish fiddle for a bout ten years.  I've always though that the Irish back-up guitar style would work well with Old Time.  Afterall, they're experts at backing modal tunes with which Irish Trad is rife.

Red Steer - YouTube

Sep 21, 2026 - 10:27:40 PM
likes this

6503 posts since 3/11/2006

This may well be the best clawhammer jig playing I've yet to hear.  Great guitar back up-  the second tune is modal.

Allison de Groot with Quinn Bachand. Tom Billy's/ Trip to Athlone. Clawhammer Jigs.

Sep 22, 2026 - 7:12:57 AM
like this

1894 posts since 4/29/2013

quote:
Originally posted by Emiel

This video might be interesting. I have not yet analyzed what Doc Watson is doing here exactly, but maybe someone else has more time…


Mike is playing in G modal (gDGCD), while Doc is playing with capo on the third fret, making his Em chord a Gm, and D chord an F. He's catching both 4th (G) and 5th (D) strings with the middle finger, occasionally lifting up and pulling off to play single open notes on those strings (F and C) with a third fret (Bb) note on the sixth string followed by it being played open (G). 

Sep 22, 2026 - 8:28:04 AM

775 posts since 4/14/2014

Mountain Minor/Sawmill is an open Gsus4 chord. So, a guitar player would be good to start there.

Sep 22, 2026 - 3:20:19 PM
likes this

erkhlm

USA

8 posts since 3/28/2024

I end up playing a lot of guitar at old time jams as well as clawhammer banjo, and I would agree with banjoak, basically, that "it depends." I'll often ask the fiddler if they have specific chords they prefer, or if they might be expecting a major or minor feel in general. 

Sometimes this produces blank stares :) but other times I get a clear preference, which I appreciate. There's a lot of power in establishing the harmony/chords for the tune, so it can be worth that tiny bit of planning. It's interesting to hear how much the overall feeling of a tune can shift when minor chords are swapped for major ones or vice versa, especially on modal tunes where the melody can be somewhat ambiguous in terms of its tonal center. I know of a few great old time guitarists who say they pretty much only play major chords. 

Another tip that folks have mentioned that I would also recommend is to try omitting the 3rd degree of the scale/chord altogether. As soon as that 3rd rings out in a chord, you're clearly proclaiming the mood as either major or minor, but if you're only playing the 1 and 5 notes (G and D in the key of G), that should always "work", and you get to keep things ambiguous, which can be nice.

I have heard at least one well-known old time fiddler say that they prefer playing some modal tunes without any accompaniment at all, specifically so that they can maintain that sesnse of ambiguity that exists in the melody.

Sep 26, 2026 - 8:54:22 AM
likes this

4979 posts since 5/14/2007

As a guitar player, I frequently use a G chord fingering which covers the first and second strings at the third fret. and avoid or mute the fifth string. This sounds as a G (no 3rd) and will work as either a G major or G minor chord.

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

8.398438E-02