Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


Sep 19, 2026 - 3:55:10 AM
3443 posts since 2/4/2013

I bought a "fully functional" vintage Barnes and Mullins (possibly made by Clifford Essex). It arrived with a nasty old neck repair which was loose - I could waggle it up and down. Two small screws and some sort of filler material in the gap. There's a picture below. You can also see it the photos that the peghead was not attached quite square with the neck.

As expected when the filler material was cleared out (It was quite loose). There 's a dowel connecting the neck and headstock. The small screw in the neck came out fairly easily and it was easy to remove the headstock with dowel attached. The filler material was filling the area of wood below the nut. The other screw is less keen to move and the dowel is held tightly with glue.

So what do I do now? It would seem sensible to get the old dowel out and replace it. It's a bit split at the neck end and has a hole where the screw was. And it's not quite straight which is why the peghead was not square with the neck. The main question is how to fill the rest of the gap around a dowel. I assume I'll need to carve a piece of suitable wood for this. Or am I missing a better option? Bear in mind I only have simple hand tools and a Dremel like device.Cleaning up surfaces and removing any old glue will be done.


Sep 19, 2026 - 5:24:04 AM

pfalzgrass

Germany

275 posts since 9/13/2017

Assuming the bone nut was sitting in the gap. I probably would cut the dowel at the end, removing enough material that there is no gap at all, and then carve a bit out at the beginning of the headstock to install the nut.

Epoxy to glue the headstock to the neck should be fine. Get rid of the screws and fill the holes with wood and sawdust. 

Edited by - pfalzgrass on 09/19/2026 05:32:32

Sep 19, 2026 - 6:22:02 AM
like this

3948 posts since 4/7/2010

I had a Weyman tenor banjo with a similar repair. I believe the person I sold it to as-is made a new neck for it. Probably the best thing you can do with your Barnes & Mullins.

Bob Smakula
smakulafrettedinstruments.com

Sep 19, 2026 - 6:29:55 AM

10037 posts since 9/21/2007

Barnes and Mullins banjos were made by Barnes and and Mullins.

It is likely that Barnes Brothers made the post 1922 Metal Hoop Specials and Professionals (which were first put on the market that year) for CE.

Sep 19, 2026 - 6:36:16 AM

deke46

Australia

239 posts since 8/30/2009

I agree with Bob, salvage the peghead cover, fretboard and dowel stick and make a new neck.

Sep 19, 2026 - 6:38:08 AM

deke46

Australia

239 posts since 8/30/2009

By the way I don`t think those are the original tuning pegs.

Sep 19, 2026 - 9:01:33 AM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by Bob Smakula

I had a Weyman tenor banjo with a similar repair. I believe the person I sold it to as-is made a new neck for it. Probably the best thing you can do with your Barnes & Mullins.

Bob Smakula
smakulafrettedinstruments.com


quote:
Originally posted by deke46

I agree with Bob, salvage the peghead cover, fretboard and dowel stick and make a new neck.


While I agree that this approach would be best, making a new neck is beyond me both in terms of skills and tools. I could send it off to a luthier to make a new neck  This might be long term solution but I feel I want to see what I can do even if it is a failure.

Sep 19, 2026 - 10:07:17 AM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by Joel Hooks

Barnes and Mullins banjos were made by Barnes and and Mullins.

It is likely that Barnes Brothers made the post 1922 Metal Hoop Specials and Professionals (which were first put on the market that year) for CE.


I do find the whole vintage banjo manufacturing thing very confusing. I was under the impression that many Barnes and Mullins banjos were made for them by other makers. I have another Barnes and Mullins that was made by Windsor (essentailly a rebadge of a Windsor wood rim banjo).

Sep 19, 2026 - 10:09:21 AM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by pfalzgrass

Assuming the bone nut was sitting in the gap. I probably would cut the dowel at the end, removing enough material that there is no gap at all, and then carve a bit out at the beginning of the headstock to install the nut.

Epoxy to glue the headstock to the neck should be fine. Get rid of the screws and fill the holes with wood and sawdust. 


I thought about doing this but the peghead would need a bit of reshaping to match the two parts and I'm not so keen on that.

Sep 28, 2026 - 6:42 AM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by deke46

By the way I don`t think those are the original tuning pegs.


You're right about that. The tuners aren't good. They don't have shafts that fit properly in the holes so with strings on they get pulled out of straight. One has a bent shaft. So getting some better tuners will be another task. At least I have it glued up using a dowel and wood insert for the gap. The good thing is that with strings on the neck seems ok with good action.

Sep 28, 2026 - 10:49:07 AM

3127 posts since 9/18/2010

I agree with others. The only way to have a fully functional, aesthetically pleasing neck is to replace this one. Some call it alligator dentistry, I usually call it a "farmer repair", bur whatever, uninformed people can certainly ruin fine instruments with their well-meaning but uninformed "repairs".

Sep 28, 2026 - 2:19:11 PM
like this

banjonz

New Zealand

13024 posts since 6/29/2003

The peghead in these photos are from a J.A.Turner (British) banjo I am restoring.
At some point before I got it, it appears the peghead was broken off and someone made a replacement (not matching the shape of its original). It was only glued on as a butt joint. I removed it, drilled two matching holes in both pieces and glued in two pieces of 1/8" brass rod.
My intention is to disguise the joints front and back.

You could use the existing 'dowel' and fill the gap at the rear with something that matches the wood of the neck. The repair can be disguised.




Sep 29, 2026 - 8:31:32 AM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by banjonz


You could use the existing 'dowel' and fill the gap at the rear with something that matches the wood of the neck. The repair can be disguised.


I used a new piece of dowel. the problem was that the holes on each part were not drilled evenly so the new dowel was not quite straight and the peghead was then off centre. I left the holes alone but with some judicious sanding and adding a couple of bits of thin venner in places I got it all straight. As this is not really a restoration (not enough skills here) but to get a working banjo I not looking for perfect, although it needs to look reasonably decent. I used a piece of beech for the gap as it was what I have. It's a decent enough match and strangely now it's almost sanded to shape it seems to take on the orangey hue of the adjacent finish.

Oct 2, 2026 - 3:26:28 AM

Ivor

England

112 posts since 11/18/2020

Are you brave enough to show us a picture Graham?

I’m sure you’ve done the best job you can and if it plays well, that’s a result, in my book!

Oct 9, 2026 - 5:53:14 AM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by Ivor

Are you brave enough to show us a picture Graham?

I’m sure you’ve done the best job you can and if it plays well, that’s a result, in my book!


I am brave enough. It's not quite finished. A bit more sanding needed. But I do have a working banjo that sounds really nice which is my aim.

But I have a question for the experts. I filled the screw holes nad the very edge of my insert with sawdust and glue but it turns blackish grey. Why is this? What am I doing wrong. I used low viscosity superglue. Pictures below of the reapir as it is and for comparison the original state. The colour chnage is just the light.


Oct 9, 2026 - 6:10:50 AM
likes this

1410 posts since 10/31/2007
Online Now

That looks great! Nice rescue of a bodged up mess!

Oct 9, 2026 - 11:13:33 PM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by lazlototh

That looks great! Nice rescue of a bodged up mess!


Thanks, although some might describe it as a less messy bodge.It would look nicer if I had avoided the filler turning black/grey.

Oct 10, 2026 - 3:06:42 AM
like this

247 posts since 7/14/2017

Sanding dust and glue is always darker than the wood which was sanded. Ebony is an invisible repair, rosewood hard to see, on spruce it's very visible. Plus the light reflects differently from sawdust. So it's rarely a good colour match as filler.

Cross grain plugs of the same wood get closest, but screw holes are hard to disguise.

Oct 10, 2026 - 8:15:19 AM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by Profchris

Sanding dust and glue is always darker than the wood which was sanded. Ebony is an invisible repair, rosewood hard to see, on spruce it's very visible. Plus the light reflects differently from sawdust. So it's rarely a good colour match as filler.

Cross grain plugs of the same wood get closest, but screw holes are hard to disguise.


I used a mix of sawdust from the neck wood, which I got from having to widen the tuner holes slightly for the new tuners, and lighter beech which I used for the insert. I'm in two minds as to whether to live with it, as perfection is not the aim, or sand some out and try something else close to the surface so it's more like fixing a dent.

Nov 16, 2026 - 8:01:49 AM

Ivor

England

112 posts since 11/18/2020

Looking at the overall condition of the instrument Graham, I would be happy to leave the repair as it is and play it…after all, it’s a thousand times better than the original repair!

Nov 16, 2026 - 8:53:19 AM

2245 posts since 4/25/2007

I would be interested in seeing the complete banjo Graham particularly the rim.

Nov 16, 2026 - 9:11:56 AM

2245 posts since 4/25/2007

quote:
Originally posted by GrahamHawker

I bought a "fully functional" vintage Barnes and Mullins (possibly made by Clifford Essex). It arrived with a nasty old neck repair which was loose - I could waggle it up and down. Two small screws and some sort of filler material in the gap. There's a picture below. You can also see it the photos that the peghead was not attached quite square with the neck.

As expected when the filler material was cleared out (It was quite loose). There 's a dowel connecting the neck and headstock. The small screw in the neck came out fairly easily and it was easy to remove the headstock with dowel attached. The filler material was filling the area of wood below the nut. The other screw is less keen to move and the dowel is held tightly with glue.

So what do I do now? It would seem sensible to get the old dowel out and replace it. It's a bit split at the neck end and has a hole where the screw was. And it's not quite straight which is why the peghead was not square with the neck. The main question is how to fill the rest of the gap around a dowel. I assume I'll need to carve a piece of suitable wood for this. Or am I missing a better option? Bear in mind I only have simple hand tools and a Dremel like device.Cleaning up surfaces and removing any old glue will be done.


The volute may indicate the banjo was made by Abbott. I have seen that on some of the banjos he made for Barnes and Mullins. 

Nov 16, 2026 - 12:53:53 PM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by Stephen John Prior

I would be interested in seeing the complete banjo Graham particularly the rim.


Hi Stephen. You've seen it as I posted the banjo in collectors corner and you confirmed it was an Abboit pot (it's not magnetic so I guess it's brass), so I guess it might be all Abbott.

https://www.banjohangout.org/topic/410333

Nov 16, 2026 - 12:55:19 PM

3443 posts since 2/4/2013

quote:
Originally posted by Ivor

Looking at the overall condition of the instrument Graham, I would be happy to leave the repair as it is and play it…after all, it’s a thousand times better than the original repair!


Yes that's what I'm doing. I did a little bit more sanding so the repair wood was not sticking out above the level of the adjacent neck and left it at that.

Nov 16, 2026 - 1:13:25 PM

2245 posts since 4/25/2007

quote:
Originally posted by GrahamHawker
quote:
Originally posted by Stephen John Prior

I would be interested in seeing the complete banjo Graham particularly the rim.


Hi Stephen. You've seen it as I posted the banjo in collectors corner and you confirmed it was an Abboit pot (it's not magnetic so I guess it's brass), so I guess it might be all Abbott.

https://www.banjohangout.org/topic/410333

 

Whoops sorry yes I remember it now. Yes the neck and rim was most certainly made by Abbott.

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.1328125