Posted by Ken LeVan
- Play count: 200
Size: 849kb, uploaded 2/20/2018 5:56:12 AM
Genre: Traditional / Playing Style: Bluegrass (Scruggs)
sound test of brass vs wood tonerings in identical banjos
Tuesday, February 20, 2018 @6:31:47 AM
And when you say brass... brass rod, tube, other?
And regardless of what form the brass takes, I would expect to hear a significant difference. Knowing your attention to things that matter in a controlled test... i.e. changing only one variable at a time, I have no doubt when you say "identical" banjos, you mean identical in every way other than the tone ring. So what's interesting here it that I can jump instantaneously to about the same place within the 'tune' by clicking at about the 1/4 and 3/4 play points on the track, creating an almost unbroken stream of music. And I can detect no difference what-so-ever in either tone or volume. IMO I'd identify both of those rings on the 'bright' side of tonality, though I know other factors such as head, strings, or even use of picks also modulate that.
Ken LeVan Says:
Tuesday, February 20, 2018 @10:09:59 AM
I made that file this morning as I am about to post something on the current wooden tone ring thread. Both banjos are exactly the same, and I'll post exploded views of both pots.
The one is a 2-alloy self-skirted "whyte Laydie/Electric tonering of my own design I call the "ToneWave, the other is a skirted baked ipe, very wide one I call the "SuperWoodie. When I sit playing them, I really can't tell any difference myself, although there is some elusive quality of the wooden one I think I hear, but it may be my imagination.
You must sign into your myHangout account before you can post comments.
You are allowed to post recordings of yourself performing:
- public-domain (non-copyrighted) songs
- original songs written by yourself
- songs written by someone else and licensed through ASCAP, BMI, or SESAC
Anything posted in violation of this notice may be removed by the webmaster without prior notice, and may result in your myHangout account being locked. Read complete copyright policy.
'Back Up and Push' 39 min
'Amazing Grace' 9 hrs