Posted by JanetB
- Play count: 1116
Size: 1,267kb, uploaded 7/19/2012 12:29:10 PM
Genre: Old Time / Playing Style: Clawhammer and Old-Time
A friend played it long ago, a lot of BHO members post it, and it's on the Henry Reed collection. I'm finally learning it, but wonder about the major/minor parts.
Thursday, July 19, 2012 @12:50:57 PM
I tune i really like to CH... your version is a bit darker... what tuning/key are you in Janet?
Thursday, July 19, 2012 @1:09:16 PM
This is in open G with the 5th string tuned to an A. My first version was less "dark" with the A part being all in A major. Then I listened to Henry Reed's some more, and changed it a bit. The A part now has an E minor and an A minor. It has that double tonic, or myxolidian sound, too, with an A and G. The B part now reminds me of a common type of melancholy folk song.
Feel free to post your video on my Sound Off thread, not to start a "post-a-thon" or anything, but I could learn a lot from other people's renditions of this tune. I'm still getting to know it and it's a bit confusing to find the perfect one to learn from. Even Henry Reed isn't consistent with his notes, so it must be all open for interpretation. There's a fiddled version by Oscar Wright, according to Miles Krassen, but I haven't heard it yet. Wouldn't this make a good Tune of the Week (TOTW)? Do you ever look at this Ken? It's a really interesting thread on the Playing Advice--Clawhammer and Old-Time forum.
Thanks for your interest and your ears!
John Kuhn Says:
Thursday, July 19, 2012 @4:24:41 PM
Fine rendition Janet. Your melody's beat stucture was right on and exactly the way Im used to hearin it.. Delivery was great in your Clawodic style!
Thursday, July 19, 2012 @4:30:04 PM
I must say thank you, John. You're most encouraging, and so I can conclude that you treat all your (well-behaved) students this way, which totally affects motivation and the desire to play and improve. I had a teacher who gave A++++++++'s in English. He was a literary artist and got the most from his students in this way.
Thursday, July 19, 2012 @4:38:38 PM
Yes Janet that definitely has the folk song feeling. Nice playing.
Wednesday, October 17, 2012 @4:24:41 PM
My Favorite, I like the dark please!
Wednesday, October 17, 2012 @4:35:38 PM
Thanks for listening, Stephen. I think the dark part is the minor sound, which is the drudgery aspect of working in the kitchen. Nice to have you back from wherever you were. I miss the KIDD, and Rick Hayes has been off galavanting, too. You'll be a long while catching up with my posts--I've gone hog-wild these days!
You must sign into your myHangout account before you can post comments.
You are allowed to post recordings of yourself performing:
- public-domain (non-copyrighted) songs
- original songs written by yourself
- songs written by someone else and licensed through ASCAP, BMI, or SESAC
Anything posted in violation of this notice may be removed by the webmaster without prior notice, and may result in your myHangout account being locked. Read complete copyright policy.
'Sigma by CF Martin' 1 min
'Huldy in the Sinkhole' 46 min