Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


 All Forums
 Playing the Banjo
 Playing Advice: Clawhammer and Old-Time Styles
 ARCHIVED TOPIC: Absolute beginner - Help? Seattle-Eastside?


Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/375700

pianojuggler - Posted - 06/15/2021:  09:51:38


I just got a beginner banjo. I have watched dozens of videos on yootoob on basic clawhammer technique and I am still having trouble hitting individual strings.

Is there anyone in the Bellevue area (or anywhere on the Eastside, or near downtown Seattle) who could spend a few minutes with me to get me going?

I can come to you. I'll buy you lunch.

Thanks,
pj

mbanza - Posted - 06/15/2021:  10:56:21


Here is the BHO Washington State list of instructors: banjohangout.org/teachers/sear...it=Search

You can narrow it by zip code using "Advanced search".

gtani7 - Posted - 06/15/2021:  11:03:24


You could peruse the books by Dan Levenson and Ken Perlman at Dusty strings and ask them how to start. Besides their lessons and workshops, they'll be happy to spend a few minutes on how to use your nails etc if they're not too busy (try index and middle fingers).  Rocket science banjo and brainjo vids too if you haven't seen those



One tip from DL or KP that i found helpful is to hold banjo neck pretty high, like 45 degrees.  That's the only way I can frail with middle finger for some reason





Dusty might still require making an appointment a day before, call them. Kennelly Keys and Stan Brown might have some decent book selection too.


Edited by - gtani7 on 06/15/2021 11:08:02

AndyW - Posted - 06/15/2021:  11:44:58


It's slow going at first so don't expect instant results. The 4th string proves the most difficult. You've just got to keep at the practice and results will come.

The Dan Levenson book mentioned 'Clawhammer Banjo From Scratch' has series of incremental exercises which take you through hitting strings(basic motion), double thumbing then drop thumbing before finally presenting full on tunes.

One thing which will make a bit of difference is letting the nail on your frailing/striking finger grow a little bit but this will obviously take a couple of weeks.

Clawdan - Posted - 06/17/2021:  05:05:15


Hi PJ,

Thanks all for the recommendations of my materials. I hope to be out your way by August for the Centralia campout BUT until then, even one or two skype lessons can help you get going and we can do that from wherever I may be. In York, PA currently and heading to Pittsburgh, PA on the 25th.



PM me and we can get started straight away!



Play Nice,

Dan Clawdan Levenson

Clawdan.com

Author of Clawhammer Banjo From Scratch - a Mel Bay publication

Half Barbaric Twanger - Posted - 06/17/2021:  06:35:31


I'm on the other coast, so I can't meet with you, but let me try a SWAG (Semi Wild-A** Guess).  I suspect that you are trying to play too fast (aka "up to tempo").  My experience has been that I do better starting slow and, after I've got the right motions, speeding it up.  



 



"First get it right, then get it fast"  -advice to aspiring banjo players  



On an similar situation: one year, when I went to summer camp for a month, I decided to teach myself how to juggle, with tennis balls.  I took a little ribbing when I started off with two tennis balls for two hands, but after getting the motions right, I got up to five within two weeks.  I then started teaching myself one-handed juggling, starting with a single ball, and got up to three, by the end of the month,  



I hope this helps.  



Bill



P.S. It took me 9 months to get the bump-ditty rhythm of frailing -but my playing was so bad I could only stand to listen to myself for five minutes a daysmiley


Edited by - Half Barbaric Twanger on 06/17/2021 06:42:50

pianojuggler - Posted - 06/17/2021:  14:05:13


Thanks, all for the inputs.

I looked at the list of local teachers, and only one seems to sorta fit. Molly was also on Dusty Strings' page. I will contact her and see if we can connect.

I have yet to find one video that really covers everything. So, I have picked up bits and pieces from several, but the last few bits have only made things worse. Two things that I've noticed: a lot of people say to use a "knocking" motion for one string, then a lateral motion for the strum. But then the video is a straight-on shot and you can't see what is actually happening between the fingernail and the string. And frequently, the sound and video aren't perfectly synchronized. *sigh*

My frustration now (especially after chipping the nail on my middle finger and having to trim it short) is that when I try to hit a string (other than 1) in a "knocking" motion, my nail sounds the string, but then the tip of my finger lands on the string and mutes it. I was getting better results with more lateral wrist movement and letting my nail sound the string in a purely downward motion.

Having learned and taught many skills over the last many decades, I know that getting the basics right at the very beginning is crucial. It takes ten times as much time and effort to unlearn something wrong than it takes to learn it right in the first place.

As for speed, I have the metronome set -- depending on the day -- from 100 to 120 with "bum" as two beats and "did-" and "-dy" as one beat each (translate that into however you prefer to refer to tempo). I started at 40. I went back to just really really slow to try to get the right motion on the "bum".


Dan, I will PM you shortly and see if we can set something up. Centralia is a good 100 miles south of me, but if you happen to be stuck in Seattle for a day coming or going, I'd be tickled to meet up. I know all the best Thai restaurants in the Seattle area.


Bill H... tennis balls are too light. Proper juggling balls are between 3.5 and 4 ounces per ball (maybe 3 ounces for juggling 5 or more). But, yes, similar situation. I've taught over 1000 people to juggle.

Speaking of which, I'll trade anyone banjo basics for beginning juggling lessons.

Clawdan - Posted - 06/18/2021:  05:42:26


Great plan PJ! Molly is GREAT! Enjoy your time with her. Looking forward to setting something up in August and great Thai food!



Dan

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

5.273438E-02