DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online banjo teacher.
Weekly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, banjo news and more.
|
Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/375693
franko48 - Posted - 06/15/2021: 05:57:58
I am interested in learning to play some songs to learn to play in our church that in many times I can not find in tab form which I have heard is not the best way to learn. Also, I have heard from a well know West Virginia banjo teacher that one should first get the rhythm down for a song first and then gradually work in the melody. Rhythm first and melody second. I presume what he was advising was to learn to play the song via chords and then work out the melody only after you have a solid in time rhythm down for the song. Any advice appreciated. Hope all have a great day. Thanks....
capo matt - Posted - 06/15/2021: 06:44:15
Hi Frank, I am also a beginner at Clawhammer so take this with a grain of salt, but I have played other instruments for many years... here's my $0.02
I think if you really know the basic tune (melody) in your head, playing will come along easier.
I started working from Wayne Erbsen's "Ignoramous" book. In the book he encourages students to first listen and get to know the tune before trying to play anything. He even provides sound clips of just the most basic version of the melody. I listen to this version several times, then find additional renditions of the tune on the Internet and listen to those. After a while, the tune gets stuck in my memory. I can whistle it or hum the melody without thinking. Then when I go to pick up a banjo, the music comes faster. The tab is helpful in guiding me, but if I really know the melody I can usually play a simple version of the tune without it.
What I like about this approach is that I can start with this basic version of the song and keep in time, keep the rhythm going. Over time I can add in some hammer-ons, slides, pull-offs to fancy it up. I like this because it encourages me to figure out my own arrangements and play to my skill level.
Some times I find that tabs can be too complex, have too many frills or fancy licks for my skill level. When I try to follow a tab like that I have to play really slow or I risk falling out of rhythm. Some years ago I attended a jam and tried to play a fancy version of a tune. I kept screwing up and we had to restart the tune. I was embarrassed. I returned a couple weeks later with more basic versions in mind and these went much better and I think folks appreciated that I was keeping in rhythm and still adding my plunk-y banjo sound to the music, even if it was less fancy.
Hope my story helps you out.
franko48 - Posted - 06/15/2021: 06:56:43
quote:
Originally posted by capo mattHi Frank, I am also a beginner at Clawhammer so take this with a grain of salt, but I have played other instruments for many years... here's my $0.02
I think if you really know the basic tune (melody) in your head, playing will come along easier.
I started working from Wayne Erbsen's "Ignoramous" book. In the book he encourages students to first listen and get to know the tune before trying to play anything. He even provides sound clips of just the most basic version of the melody. I listen to this version several times, then find additional renditions of the tune on the Internet and listen to those. After a while, the tune gets stuck in my memory. I can whistle it or hum the melody without thinking. Then when I go to pick up a banjo, the music comes faster. The tab is helpful in guiding me, but if I really know the melody I can usually play a simple version of the tune without it.
What I like about this approach is that I can start with this basic version of the song and keep in time, keep the rhythm going. Over time I can add in some hammer-ons, slides, pull-offs to fancy it up. I like this because it encourages me to figure out my own arrangements and play to my skill level.
Some times I find that tabs can be too complex, have too many frills or fancy licks for my skill level. When I try to follow a tab like that I have to play really slow or I risk falling out of rhythm. Some years ago I attended a jam and tried to play a fancy version of a tune. I kept screwing up and we had to restart the tune. I was embarrassed. I returned a couple weeks later with more basic versions in mind and these went much better and I think folks appreciated that I was keeping in rhythm and still adding my plunk-y banjo sound to the music, even if it was less fancy.
Hope my story helps you out.
Thanks for the advice Matt. I have heard and have to agree totally that one should get the tune in your head before ever even attempting to play the tune. Yes, some of the tabs are so full of stuff I get lost in the maze. I feel I would like to do the simple thing first and then add in the embellishments as the feeling comes to me. I guess if one has the melody in mind making sure the rhythm is going strong should not be too difficult. Yes, I have to agree with some of the stuff Mr. Erbsen comes up with for I learned Cluck Old Hen from some tab I got from him and after getting it in my head I now do an average job on it even though I have not played it for long. I had read from one teacher if you can learn four or five tunes real good in a year you are doing good. I sure would like to speed that up. Now, for Scruggs style I would agree especially for me. Clawhammer feels more natural to me and that is what I am leaning to.
m06 - Posted - 06/16/2021: 03:38:33
Frank, just to be clear...if you are intending to sing in church the banjo doesn't generally play the full melody to accompany your vocal. We simplify. Though sometimes a performer will alternate banjo melody with vocal in their song structure.
If that's what you mean, then you can see how rhythm and sense of time is more to the fore than full melody. Its not a big deal once you have worked out a simplified banjo accompaniment that relates to the melody to later expand that to full(er) melody.
Also good advice to have a strong sense of the tune in your head beforehand. The usual advice is good enough so that you can whistle or hum it.
Edited by - m06 on 06/16/2021 03:41:12
chip arnold - Posted - 06/16/2021: 05:46:42
Pete Seeger a master at accompanying his singing with a banjo. study him a bit on Youtube. :-)
Eric A - Posted - 06/16/2021: 05:53:52
My usual advice is to listen to a tune until it becomes an earworm in your head. You hum it in the shower. You hear it in your sleep. You sing it a cappella when you go for a walk. A bare bones basic melody version. Only the notes you need, and no more. Then find those notes on your banjo, in proper timing. Then fancy it up, if you must. But must you?
I think this is generally in sync with Wayne Erbsen's approach, and just one of the many reasons I love his books, regardless of instrument, style, or level.
Edited by - Eric A on 06/16/2021 05:58:07
watercarving - Posted - 06/24/2021: 08:09:15
Look at Chris Coole's Singing With The Banjo workshop. It was excellent and covered several ways to accompany yourself while you sign or someone else sings. chriscoole.com
John
carlb - Posted - 06/24/2021: 10:17:19
Coming to clawhammer banjo from guitar, I started with rhythm and chords. Often some of the melody notes come out of the chords. My chord charts.
Claude Grassley - Posted - 06/25/2021: 05:28:56
quote:
Originally posted by capo mattHi Frank, I am also a beginner at Clawhammer so take this with a grain of salt, but I have played other instruments for many years... here's my $0.02
I think if you really know the basic tune (melody) in your head, playing will come along easier.
I started working from Wayne Erbsen's "Ignoramous" book. In the book he encourages students to first listen and get to know the tune before trying to play anything. He even provides sound clips of just the most basic version of the melody. I listen to this version several times, then find additional renditions of the tune on the Internet and listen to those. After a while, the tune gets stuck in my memory. I can whistle it or hum the melody without thinking. Then when I go to pick up a banjo, the music comes faster. The tab is helpful in guiding me, but if I really know the melody I can usually play a simple version of the tune without it.
What I like about this approach is that I can start with this basic version of the song and keep in time, keep the rhythm going. Over time I can add in some hammer-ons, slides, pull-offs to fancy it up. I like this because it encourages me to figure out my own arrangements and play to my skill level.
Some times I find that tabs can be too complex, have too many frills or fancy licks for my skill level. When I try to follow a tab like that I have to play really slow or I risk falling out of rhythm. Some years ago I attended a jam and tried to play a fancy version of a tune. I kept screwing up and we had to restart the tune. I was embarrassed. I returned a couple weeks later with more basic versions in mind and these went much better and I think folks appreciated that I was keeping in rhythm and still adding my plunk-y banjo sound to the music, even if it was less fancy.
Hope my story helps you out.
I agree with Matt.
I struggled learning tabs in the beginning and wasted a lot of time.
Gerard_60 - Posted - 06/26/2021: 13:50:00
1. Buy a metronome
2. Record yourself frequently and listen afterwards to the mess you played.
That's learning.
No pain, no gain.
Gerard
franko48 - Posted - 06/27/2021: 08:04:59
quote:
Originally posted by carlbComing to clawhammer banjo from guitar, I started with rhythm and chords. Often some of the melody notes come out of the chords. My chord charts.
Thanks Carl for the chart. i will have to check it out. Also thanks to Terry for his advice also because I have to agree no matter how you play if you already have the tune in your head you are farther along than you think. Even when I try to play 3 finger style on a church hymn I do much better when I already know how it is suppose to sound. I am trying to get info from Dwight Diller because he plays such an awesome style it just blows me away. I love the way he plays that good old foot tapping style. I consider it rhythm deluxe.
Edited by - franko48 on 06/27/2021 08:06:09
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.