Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors

Banjo Lovers Online

Discussion Forum

Want to hide these Google ads? Join the Players Union!

 All Forums
 Playing the Banjo
 Playing Advice: Clawhammer and Old-Time Styles
 ARCHIVED TOPIC: TOTW December 21, 2018: Brightest and Best/Falls of Richmond

Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link:

ndlxs - Posted - 12/21/2018:  06:10:49

Today’s Tune of the Week is my version of the Christian hymn “Brightest and Best”, which I play with an unusual gDGGD tuning.  The two middle strings are tuned to the same note, which gives you a grand dulcimer/octave mandolin like sound.  The terrific traditional musician Tim Eriksen uses this tuning for a number of his banjo tunes; he adapted it from a similar guitar tuning developed by the British ballad singer Martin Carthy.  This tuning is somewhat limiting, and is probably more useful for songs rather than for instrumentals.

Here is my video of Brightest and Best:

Here is my tab for Brightest and Best:;v=23498

Before I get into the hymn itself: Don’t care for the holiday sentiments? Don’t care for religion at all? I’ve got you covered! This is a two for one TOTW: I also use the very same tuning (capo’ed up, of course) for Falls of Richmond:

I have heard Falls of Richmond played in aEAC#E, aEADE, aEAEE, and now aEAAE. 

Here is Haiku’s TOTW from 2008:

Tab for my version of Falls of Richmond:;v=23499

I’ve always thought of this as an Advent hymn; but it was written for Epiphany, the traditional last day of the 12 days of Christmas and the day in which the visitation of the magi is celebrated.  The words of Brightest and Best were written by the Church of England Bishop Reginald Heber in 1811.  He ended up as the Bishop of Calcutta and died mysteriously at age 42, supposedly from the shock of going from the intense heat of India into a cold bath, but more likely a heart attack. This is one of the few of his hymns that have survived into the 21st century; one other, “From Greenland’s Icy Mountains” was omitted from the Episcopal Church’s 1982 revision; one modern critic felt that in the modern world, the words of this hymn seem patronizing and insensitive to other beliefs, with references to "...every prospect pleases and only man is vile", and to "the heathen in his blindness [bowing] down to wood and stone". 

Personally I love the words to Brightest and Best, especially the last verse, which I think sums up the wrongness of the materialism of Christmas:

Vainly we offer each ample oblation,

Vainly with gifts would His favor secure;

Richer by far is the heart’s adoration,

Dearer to God are the prayers of the poor.

These words have been put to three separate tunes; this one, which I didn’t try to copy exactly, is the tune “Star in the East” by William Walker.  Regarding the melody; I sing the verses with something close to the original modal melody; I sing the chorus with a major scale version of the original modal melody.

The preceding history is from here:

Here is a wonderful vocal version:

Here is the vocal version from the book The Christian Harmony:

Make sure you check out Tim Eriksen’s singing and picking:




JanetB - Posted - 12/21/2018:  20:42:01

Your song is most special for Christmas, Andy, and your powerful version lifted me the whole day.  Your tuning was interesting to try and the way the two tunes sound together, you could easily make a medley of Brighter and Best with Falls of Richmond.

I ended up by happily using my Southern Harmony and Musical Companion book -- it hasn't got much opportunity as a reference yet.  Just the introduction is a world of information.  The video you shared with the singers was helpful.  The tuning I used is eDGBD.  Hope you enjoy it!  


ndlxs - Posted - 12/22/2018:  06:32:26

That is a very nice, Janet, a whole different flavor to it, and much closer to the spirit of the original, too. When played in A, that low D would be nice to get without having to cheat like I did. I guess I could try GCGGD capo'ed up...a lot of trouble tuning, though, for a song that is appropriate for 2 weeks of the year!

Tamarack - Posted - 12/22/2018:  07:40:47

Very well done -- with your voice, banjo, and an unusual tuning you kinda hit all the voices of a shape-note singing.

This has always been one of my favorite Christmas season songs. Shape-note harmony brings tears to my eyes:

(If you are inclined to pursue YouTube rabbit holes, the producer of this video has lots of videos combining music of English Pastoral composers (Ralph Vaughan-Williams, George Butterfield, Frederick Delius, etc.) with English art and photography.  Not plugging this for commercial purposes, just stuff BHO comrades might enjoy)

(Speaking of rabbit holes, Tim Eriksen has a wide and deep rabbit hole.  I am stuck in the office on a Saturday morning and shall do some exploring)

Edited by - Tamarack on 12/22/2018 07:53:22

banjo bill-e - Posted - 12/22/2018:  08:19:12

And yet again I just love the unique tone of your banjo, Andy. Those sound like nothing else.

RG - Posted - 12/22/2018:  15:03:31

Real nice playing Andy, enjoyed both songs/tunes very much!

Here's a version of "Fall of Richmond" I recorded almost ten years ago, one of my favorite modal WVa tunes... gonna give "Brightest and Best" a spin this afternoon...

ndlxs - Posted - 12/23/2018:  07:08:10

I just ADORE Internet rabbit holes...

Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories