DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online banjo teacher.
Weekly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, banjo news and more.
|
Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/347036
dpgetman - Posted - 10/03/2018: 10:27:32
Hi folks,
I have never finished anything with Tru-Oil, but am in the process of experimenting with a few different oil based products (Permalyn, Hammerl GmbH, Tru-Oil), wax (Caranauba [I love it!]), and nitro (rattle can and sprayer). There are a bewildering variety of application approaches for Tru-Oil in the forums, perhaps because of the way the product behaves in different climes. I have reviewed (and reviewed) the many topics here to nail down a process I can execute and refine as needed and came up with what you see below (I know they contradict the manufacturer instructions, but they are tied to success stories). I'm just curious whether folks who use this product see any glaring miss-steps before I begin or have thoughts on order, grit, drying times, etc.
David
Tru-Oil Application Steps
Day 1
a. Prep
i. Sand to 220 grit and wipe with mineral spirits to remove all dust
b. First Coat (pore fill)
i. Mix 2pt mineral spirits to 1pt Tru-Oil and wipe on heavy
ii. Wet sand (slurry) with 220 grit paper and let dry 2-3 hrs
* per Ken and Dan, open grained woods will take much longer to grain fill with Tru-Oil alone. Consider starting out with a grain fill step, then progressing on to the Tru-Oil.
c. Second Coat (pore fill)
i. Mix 2pt mineral spirits to 1pt Tru-Oil and wipe on heavy
ii. Wet sand (slurry) with 320 grit paper and let dry 12 hrs
iii. Wet sand with 320 to level out finish and wipe with damp cloth, let sit until dry
iv. Buff with 000 steel wool and wipe all particles off with cloth when done
Day 2
a. Third Coat
i. Uncut Tru-Oil wipe on lite
ii. Let dry 2-3 hrs
iii. Wet sand with 320
iv. Buff with 000 steel wool
b. Fourth Coat
i. Uncut Tru-Oil wipe on lite
ii. Let dry 2-3 hrs
iii. Sand lightly with 000 steel wool
c. Fifth Coat
i. Uncut Tru-Oil wipe on lite
ii. Let dry 2-3 hrs
iii. Sand lightly with 000 steel wool
3. Day 3
a. Sixth Coat
i. Uncut Tru-Oil wipe on lite
ii. Let dry and cure for 7 days (per Zach, 12-24 hrs is sufficient)
Edited by - dpgetman on 10/03/2018 11:59:37
Zachary Hoyt - Posted - 10/03/2018: 10:59:50
I'm sure what you outlined will work fine. I would recommend doing some experiments to see what works best for you. In the winter when I am applying Tru Oil in a heated room with dry air (not living space, another building) I apply a coat every 2 hours. I sand between some or all of the coats with 400 grit sandpaper. I do 5 or sometimes 6 coats and it makes a finish that I and all but 2 or 3 of my customers have been happy with so far. In the summer I spread the finishing out over 1 or 2 days depending on the humidity. I think the important thing is to make sure that the last coat is fully dry to the touch before applying the next one, and to apply thin enough coats to avoid runs and drips. I like to wait 12-24 hours after the last coat before setting up the instrument, but have not seen any benefit to waiting longer as I don't do buffing and polishing anyway.
Zach
Old Hickory - Posted - 10/03/2018: 11:04:04
If your wood is mahogany or walnut, I don't think two coats of a 33% solution of TruOil is going to fill pores. Maybe if you wet sand with #320 as you apply the TruOil, but definitely not after the coat is dry and you then buff off what you sanded.
If you want to fill pores, use pore filler. Either the same tone as the wood if you want to minimize the appearance of pores or darker than the wood (even black) if you want to emphasize the pores and grain.
Whether you can stop at 6 coats depends on how much build you want.
On my one resonator finished with TruOil, I started with a sealer coat of SealCoat (how appropriate) to protect the wood against staining from the pore filler that was drywall compound dyed black. I think I did two applications of that and should have done more because I sanded some out. I did at least 30 coats of TruOil over two weeks or more before I was satisfied with the fim build. I don't think I started sanding until the third coat. After that I sanded every two or three coats. Not every coat. At one point -- I don't remember where -- I thought it was starting to get too yellow, so I sanded pretty aggressively. That's probably the main reason for 30 coats.
I think I did fewer coats on the neck.
Both of these pieces could use a little more, but that's a low priority.
Dan Drabek - Posted - 10/03/2018: 11:24:35
You haven't told us to what kind of wood you're applying the Tru Oil.
If it is going on a smooth grained wood like maple or cherry, it should work well and shouldn't take many coats. If it's going on a coarse grained wood like oak or mahogany, it may take a lot more time and effort, depending on the look you're after.
Tru Oil by itself takes a long time to build up a protective coat and fill the pores on coarse grain woods, if that's what you want. On medium grain woods, like walnut, it will take fewer coats, but Birchwood Casey still recommends a filler before applying the top coats.
Tru Oil is basically a wiping varnish, is easy to repair and can look good. It's a little softer than polyurethane based wiping varnishes and a little more expensive. But it's far more protective than a wax finish ( including carnauba) , not only against abrasive damage, but also moisture resistance. You can keep it thin, or build it up to a tougher, thicker finish if you want that look.
I think Tru-oil is only available in a gloss, while most other wiping varnishes give you the options of gloss, semi gloss and satin. I've used Permalin, and can find little difference from Tru Oil, in both application and final result.
DD
dpgetman - Posted - 10/03/2018: 11:49:46
Thanks folks,
Pre-filling vs wet sand filling was a main question for me. The instruments I am working on are walnut and mahogany with accents of maple, wenge, and padouk. I wonder if a preliminary grain/pore filling steps of sealing the wood to protect it from the grain filler, applying the grain filler, and sanding away the excess would inhibit the penetration of the Tru-Oil?
Good advice, thanks,
David
Old Hickory - Posted - 10/03/2018: 12:28:39
Yes, a sealer is going to inhibit penetration of the the TruOil. But since each new coat of TruOil goes on the one before and not through it into the wood, I don't think you're getting much penetration on successive coats, anyway. As a wiping varnish, TruOil does build a film.
TruOil is not true oil.
Jonnycake White - Posted - 10/03/2018: 13:14:17
Interesting stuff here. FWIW, I'll just mention what I have done and how it turned out in the past. I've used TruOil for several instruments using several different woods. On walnut and mahogany, I have pore-filled using a heavy coat of straight TruOil and wet sanding it to make a slurry, rubbing the slurry in to the pores with my fingers, and letting dry for at least 24 hours. Then I dry sand it with 320 grit before applying six or seven more coats of TruOil. This is done by wiping it on thinly with a small pad of soft cotton (or cotton blend) cloth. Each coat drys 2 - 4 hours at least. Between each coat I rub it with the gray ScotchBrite pad designated for "between coats." If you get anything but white powder, you probably didn't let it dry long enough. This gives a satin finish (not high gloss) on walnut and mahogany. Closed pore woods like maple result in a higher gloss.
rudy - Posted - 10/03/2018: 13:33:27
Hi David, Somewhere in the archives I posted Tru-oil application guideline notes, but I'm not all that fond of using it. I found that it really took as many as 15 coats to really build even a minimal finish and it was just far too time consuming and finicky when I was doing 5 or 6 lap steels per month.
Here's a copy / paste of application notes that I did later and included in my banjo construction guides:
******************************
"There are many ways to apply an attractive and durable finish. A few are tailor-made for the part-time craftsman to apply be hand and obtain professional results. Many builders like to use Tru-oil. I have used it in the past and the results are fine, it just takes way too long and far too many coats to be practical for me as a hand applied finish. It can be sprayed, but I don’t have a dedicated area and equipment suitable for spray application of finishes.
My favorite finish is three coats of Minwax Satin wipe-on polyurethane. The secret to hand applied finish is meticulous surface preparation and NO DUST. Follow the steps outlined below:
1. Blow off the individual parts to be finished AWAY from your finishing area and wipe all of the surfaces down with a tack rag to remove any remaining dust immediately prior to finish application.
2. Take a shower and put on clean clothes that have been well shaken away from the finish application area to remove stray dust and lint.
3. Proceed to the finish application area, slip on a pair of latex or vinyl gloves, and tack rag the surfaces carefully.
4. Apply the finish in a remote area that will remain relatively dust free for at least the hour it takes for a first coat to harden sufficiently so that dust will not adhere to it. I like to apply finish with a soft absorbent cloth pad that has been shaken AWAY FROM THE FINISH AREA to remove any remaining dust or lint before forming it into an application pad.
Three coats are applied allowing approximately 12 hours between coats. If there is any appreciable surface roughness from airborne dust after drying of any of the coats then the surface should be VERY LIGHTLY rubbed with 0000 (four ought) steel wool and the dust removal regimen repeated. Make sure your steel wool has no residual oil on it from the manufacturing process. I rinse my steel wool that I’ll be using in fresh grain alcohol (Everclear, Gem Clear, etc.) and let it thoroughly dry out before use.
5. Let the finish cure a few days before final assembly. I like to give it a full week if possible. The steel wool can be used if there are a few dust particles that need to be removed, just go LIGHTLY. "
Zachary Hoyt - Posted - 10/03/2018: 13:34:31
I have had satisfactory results on mahogany and walnut as well as other woods using the methods I described above. I have never used grain filler, and I have never tried wet sanding. I've seen some very visible grain filler and I prefer the almost clear color of Tru Oil in the pores.
Zach
lightgauge - Posted - 10/03/2018: 14:01:22
I have used it on several necks and a couple of resonators. On the mahogany, I used a walnut grain filler prior to any finish and sanded smooth. I then stain with Behlen dye stains. Necks usually take 6-10 coats to get to where I want and resonators several more. I did learn on the last resonator to thin the last couple of coats to help with smoothing out any application rag marks. I usually wait at least 2 hrs between coats and lightly rub with the 0000 steel wool. After the final coat drys thoroughly, usually a light rubbing again with the steel wool and polish, leaving what I would call a semi gloss finish. This has been the most comfortable, non sticky neck finish I have found in my limited experience of just building for myself. It does yellow quite a bit on the binding over time, giving an older look, much sooner than lacquer.
davidppp - Posted - 10/03/2018: 16:31:00
I bought a banjo second-hand, and the neck needed a tiny bit of work. I contacted the very well-known builder to ask about the original finish -- so I wouldn't have to remove it all or risk adverse reactions when I touched it up. The finish was Tru-Oil, but there was a crucial, recommended last step. The last coat got 0000 steel-wooled, but, importantly, the steel wool was soaked with (non-silicone, i.e., not car) paste wax. The gloss was gone, but the feel was incomparably smooth with not the slightest bit of the stickiness that a smooth-as-glass finish can have.
YWGbanjo - Posted - 10/03/2018: 19:42:51
David,
I've used Tru Oil on four recent builds (two cherry, a walnut, and a jatoba). I don't have much to offer with respect to finishing schedule; I followed more or less the same process that you did except that I didn't thin any of the coats, and I applied two coats per day. I'm happy with how they all turned out. One thing I do have to offer is a recommendation to apply the finish with a postage-stamp sized square of first-aid gauze. I saturate the gauze with a few drops of Tru Oil, apply a few more drops to the piece being finished, then wipe on the oil with the longest strokes possible. This applies a near flawless coat, without specks of lint. If you wear nitrile gloves, cleanup is almost effortless, negligible finish is wasted, and a roll of gauze (kept in the original packaging) will last for a very long time.
Doug
arkred - Posted - 10/05/2018: 17:36:44
I've used Tru-Oil for over fifty years, and I put it on straight with no thinning. I apply it by hand.
One coat rubbed until I feel a little resistance, then another coat. I let these dry overnight, then repeat up to six coats. I wet sand with 600 Wet or dry paper after about three coats. If you want a satin finish use OOOO steel wool. I like a mirror gloss. This product dries hard and will not check or scratch like nitro. Tip: If you have an instrument that has a poly finish and it needs touchup Tru-Oil works well. I had a Taylor guitar neck that one of the peg head "ears" came unglued. After gluing and sanding lightly I wondered what I could use to touch up the spot. The neck was natural mahogany, so for an experiment I applied a couple of coats of Tru-Oil. Blended in with no checking or runs or any problems. After about three or four coats and wet sanding between coats the repair was invisible. I understand a company that restores old period furniture uses Tru-Oil for their restoration work. This was told to me by the Tru-Oil people at the factory in Minnesota. I've never tried to thin it and spray it through an air brush. It would have to be awfully thinned out, and then it might still clog up the works. I'll just stick with my hand application.
rudy - Posted - 10/05/2018: 17:43:55
Arkred, Chuck Lee sprays Tru-oil after he has thinned it appropriately. He has posted the thinner and percentages here in the past, so that information should come up from a forum search.
dpgetman - Posted - 10/06/2018: 13:53:58
Thanks for the replies everyone, all very interesting and helpful. My plan is to update the original post with a revised schedule based on everyone's feedback here in a bit as a way of getting a finalized schedule and of summarizing the advice in the first post for anyone else exploring this topic. Then I can follow up with the results. Keep the suggestions coming!
GSCarson - Posted - 10/06/2018: 14:26:18
I've used Tru Oil on the majority of the banjos I've made in my life (since 1975). I have tried some other finishes during the past five or six years, but it is still a finish I really like, mostly because I'm used to it. I just posted photos on this builders forum of a tenor banjo I built in 1981. I used Tru Oil on it and it has held up nicely over the past 36 years through several owners.
I sand the wood to 600, then start with a couple saturating coats, trying not to have runs, etc. Then I would lightly sand the second coat using finish as a sanding agent to help fill the pores, again trying to keep it as smooth as I could, sharp edge lines can be tricky if you have stained the wood. I would then build up with additional thin coats (the number depending on the wood species, less for maple, more for walnut, etc.), very lightly sanding with worn 600 between coats to smooth it out. Way back, I used to finish up with one or two coats from their spray can because I felt that hardened a little better, it was probably thinned a little like what Chuck Lee does. I use a simple drying cabinet with a 60 Watt light bulb which helps the drying. I allow it to dry for a few days, and then sand it very lightly with 800 or 1000 rather than steel wool because I like how that smooths and levels things a little. My final approach was to rub out gently using mineral oil and rottenstone or pumice or a mixture of both. Birchwood Casey's stock sheen works very well to rub it out to a high gloss as a last step rather than the rottenstone if that what you seek. If going for a satin finish, I use the pumice and light rubbing with quality steel wool.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.