Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


 All Forums
 Other Banjo-Related Topics
 Collector's Corner
 ARCHIVED TOPIC: 1923(ish?) Glee Club Banjo Uke


Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/331568

wormpicker - Posted - 06/11/2017:  10:52:42


I just acquired a cool looking and sounding old banjo uke.  The seller dates it as ca. 1923, but the earliest ad I could find for it is from 1926. It is a "Glee Club" model, sold by C. Bruno & Son, and made by Stomberg-Voisinet, of Chicago, which later became Kay. All original parts except for a new calf skin head and new tuning machine buttons. All original nickel-plated brass hardware, and pretty wood inlay around the maple rim and matching carved removable resonator. The seller, who restores antique instruments, got it from an 89-year-old local gentleman, who says his father bought it new a few years before he was born.  I'm trying to get in touch with this man. I'm sure he has a lot of stories to tell about this instrument.



 


cb56 - Posted - 06/11/2017:  16:29:42


Nice looking Uke! Enjoy!

wormpicker - Posted - 06/11/2017:  16:34:33


Thanks!  I am, right now!


tdennis - Posted - 06/11/2017:  18:22:40


This is about as nice as one could find in an S/V banjo uke.   S/V's are well made, & a pleasure to refurbish because the metal parts & wood finishes clean up so well. 

wormpicker - Posted - 06/11/2017:  18:42:57


Do you think I'd diminish the value if I did anything to it?  It's in mostly great shape.  The nickel could be a little shinier and the resonator is a little scuffed, but I kind of like it in its untouched condition.  The seller did a minor repair at the end of the fretboard, re-crowned the frets, and gave it a new calfskin head and tuner buttons, but that's about it. It plays nicely.  Do you have any insight on confirming the date?  Thanks.


Edited by - wormpicker on 06/11/2017 18:43:51

wormpicker - Posted - 06/11/2017:  18:54:09


Also, would it hurt the value if I replaced the tuners with Gotoh planetaries?  The Grovers on it now aren't bad at all, but I got spoiled by Gotoh's that I had installed on an old Gretsch Clarophone.  Too bad, I probably won't play that Gretsch much now.

mikehalloran - Posted - 06/11/2017:  20:54:59


Those are Champion pegs, patented 1888. I don't know when Grover acquired the company but I'm not sure it was as early as  that. 



White and ivoroid knobs haven't been made in decades and are very hard to find and no other knob fits. If you have any in good condition, hang onto them. Some collector will thank you someday. 



I am one of many who have been trying to get Grover to offer those pegs in white and ivoroid again. They were original to many 19th to early 20th C. Banjos including a few by Vega.



If the pros aren't working well, the paper washers are likely worn out. I have a vintage set of these with black knobs. I don't know what type of paper they are.


Edited by - mikehalloran on 06/11/2017 20:57:12

wormpicker - Posted - 06/11/2017:  20:59:54


Thanks for the info and advice, Mike!

banjo_brad - Posted - 06/12/2017:  11:01:44


Nice looking Uke, Paul.  When do we get a sound file?

wormpicker - Posted - 06/12/2017:  11:23:43


Thanks, Brad.  Come on up to CROMA and you can hear the real thing!


Muskrat - Posted - 06/12/2017:  16:38:26


Yes, 1923 is too early for this. 1926 to 1930 is more like it. 


wormpicker - Posted - 06/12/2017:  16:54:37


Thanks, Muskrat. What do you base your date estimate on?  Do you have any other info on this model?  I think the man whose father bought it new "a few years befor de was born" was born in 1928, so a 1926 date would fit in. The seller said that they had stopped using nickel-plated brass hardware by the late '20's and '30's. 


tdennis - Posted - 06/12/2017:  18:02:54


I've never  found any info over the years regarding  a clear date when S/V started building banjo ukes (S/V name appears in 1921).  ..And It's not clear what happened to their banjo uke lines & models & parts when S/V was sold   c.1928.  (how far into the 30's were the nice S/V resonator banjo ukuleles produced ? 

wormpicker - Posted - 06/12/2017:  18:08:10


This one doesn't have the S-V name on it. According to the 1926 ad, it was made for and sold by Bruno. I'm just presuming it was manufactured by S-V (as have others on the internet).


Muskrat - Posted - 06/18/2017:  00:39:36


quote:


Originally posted by wormpicker

 

Thanks, Muskrat. What do you base your date estimate on?  Do you have any other info on this model?  I think the man whose father bought it new "a few years befor de was born" was born in 1928, so a 1926 date would fit in. The seller said that they had stopped using nickel-plated brass hardware by the late '20's and '30's. 


 




It's mainly experience and trusting my gut. I can tell by looking at it that it's not from 1923. I collect banjo ukes, have about 30 of the tiny terrors. Over the years I've owned many more. 1923 would be pretty early for a factory built banjo uke (which yours is). Regular ukuleles were popular first, then banjo ukes a few years later. 1926 to 1929 would be the peak of production. Not that they didn't make any in the earlier years. I've seen a few from the "teens" but those were much more hand-made or small production.

beezaboy - Posted - 06/18/2017:  10:49:15


We hardly ever talk about banjo ukes on BHO so FWIW here are some things I've seen about its origins in case the topic might be of interest or sort of on point here..



I'm pretty sure the banjo uke was invented in San Francisco in 1916.



The Tranquada and King book "The Ukulele A History" states that details about the banjo uke's advent is murky.



I think that's because the inventors might be either J. A. Bolander or Alvin Keech.  Both were from San Francisco.  Maybe the inventions were simultaneous?  I think, however, that Bolander was first by a whisker.  There are those, though, that say Keech was first



Bolander's uke appears to have been the first to appear in a period magazine.  Pallma of Chicago was apparently the first to market a banjo uke and his ad reportedly depicting a Bolander banjo uke appeared in the Music Trades magazine on Oct. 28, 1916.



The Music Trades article "The Manufacture of the Ukulele Banjo" appearing in May 1919 gives Bolander the credit for the invention.



The early Bolander and Keech banjo ukes were round wood bodies with the head tightened from within the shell.



By July 1917, though, Bruno was  advertising a modern appearing banjo uke with brackets and tension hoop.



I've attached a couple of photos of my Bolander banjo uke.


wormpicker - Posted - 06/18/2017:  11:00:42


Dan & John, thanks for all the great info!

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories

0.1640625