Rqj57t - Posted - 06/03/2017:  08:09:38

I could do with some advice I currently own two original Vega pot open backs with new necks one with a tubaphone and one with whyte lady...I was thinking of buying a new ome banjo with 22 frets and a silver spun tone ring but I have been offered an original bacon pot with a bacon silver bell tone ring with a new neck...mint condition! It's roughly half the price of the ome..which one do I go for? Hopefully they both sound different to my two Vegas! Could do with some help.
Contact me at the following please
theboowd@gmail.com

banjoracle - Posted - 06/03/2017:  08:24:28

Are we taking 4 string banjos? What kind of music do you play? I own a 1924 B&D Silver Bell plectrum banjo I purchased recently and am very happy with it. The fretboard is narrow, however, and may take some getting use to.

jbalch - Posted - 06/03/2017:  10:03:09

Jason:  Welcome to the BHO.

B&D Silver bell tone rings came in at least four (4) different configurations - over the years. 

Type 1 (holes inside & outside),

Type 2 (holes inside only), - my personal favorite sound. See photo below,

Type 3 )No holes - inside lip of the tone ring not touching the rim) -  see photo below,

Type 4 (arch top).

The Silver Bell model came in nine (9) trim levels.  The details of which can make a big difference in value & desirability. 

Also, the brand continued - made by Gretsch - after the flood closed the plant in Groton, Ct.  Generally, the Gretsch-made banjos are lower quality than the original B&D production.    

So ... it might be good to know more about the "original" Bacon pot before deciding.    If you can post photos, there are folks on this forum that have immense knowledge of B&D history. I'm sure you will get helpful responses.  

Then ... there is the issue of the new neck. A re-necked banjo is not really collectable.  But if it is well-made and you like it, that is the most important thing.

For what it is worth, I have a 1925 B&D Silver bell #2 17-fret tenor that is an amazing banjo.  In general, I would HIGHLY recommend a great old B&D banjo. 

Best wishes!

Edited by - jbalch on 06/03/2017 10:13:18

Silver Bell tone ring - no interior holes

1925 Silver Bell #2

Unclelevi - Posted - 06/03/2017:  15:14:19

This is just my opinion: I own an OME Columbine and as far as I'm concerned, the quality and sound is second to none. Any time I call OME, i get personal, friendly service and always get answers to my questions. I understand everyone has their favorites, but I believe OME and Nechville make the very best banjos available today. Just my opinion.mind you.