Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/292315
maxmax - Posted - 10/05/2014: 14:04:25
Hi all!
Question: For optimal tone and response from a fretted banjo strung with either Nylon or Nylgut strings, would you think the overall build of the banjo would be similar to that of a strong, responsive banjo made for steel strings, or would you perhaps get more out of it, if it was lighter constructed? Thinner rim, no truss rod etc.?
Just for reference, I have a Cedar Mountain Banjo which is a real powerhouse with it's 12" rosewood block rim, brass hoop and fairly thick maple neck with ebony fingerboard. Strung it up with Nylguts, swapped the tailpiece and put a thin, all maple bridge on, and it sounds very weak. Especially up the neck I get no tone at all.
Not sure if I'm just not used to the Nylguts or if this heavy duty banjo is just not well suited for anything but steel strings?
Any input would be greatly appreciated! Thanks,
Max
Snaps - Posted - 10/05/2014: 14:17:31
I have a brooks banjo with a spun over rim, lots for wood inside the rim too. I find it louder and punchier with nylgut
Jeffa
etparadox - Posted - 10/05/2014: 14:27:28
The first thing I'd try is loosening the head some. Nylon strings don't give as much energy to the head so a easier to move head can make for a more responsive banjo. This is why the tops on classical guitars are built more lightly than on steel-stringed guitars.
maxmax - Posted - 10/06/2014: 02:12:12
Thanks for the replies!
Jeffa - Want to trade? 
Just kidding.
etparadox - Thanks for the tip! That's interesting, never thought about that. Will try it tonight. But that's kinda where my thinking came from, that other instruments made for Nylon strings are usually constructed lighter than their steel strung cousins. Maybe that would apply for banjos as well?
Thanks!
Max
