Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors


 All Forums
 Playing the Banjo
 Playing Advice: 4-String (Jazz, Blues & Other Trad Styles)
 ARCHIVED TOPIC: Now *that's* an Irish tenor banjo -- and Irish box


Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link: http://www.banjohangout.org/archive/160300

pgroff - Posted - 10/16/2009:  09:07:59


Two great photos, John Maloney with a Paramount, and Johnny Bresnahan with (I think) a Baldoni, Bartoli & Co. Irish-American accordion:

msp.umb.edu/MassMemories/Hiber...to23.html

msp.umb.edu/MassMemories/Hiber...to22.html

PG


Edited by - pgroff on 10/16/2009 11:00:57

trapdoor2 - Posted - 10/16/2009:  10:35:55


No, *this* is an Irish Tenor:



John McCormack, ca 1910. Probably better described as *The* Irish Tenor.

I do like Paramounts though!!

===Marc

"If banjos needed tone rings, S.S. Stewart would have made them that way."

pgroff - Posted - 10/16/2009:  11:12:10


Hi Marc

Taking your point, I edited the topic title.

But if you still want to make good use of your post, I notice there are a few other topics that still have "Irish tenor" in their title :-)

I actually have some John McCormack records in my storage space, with leftover inventory from my former shop.

PG

fergaloh - Posted - 10/16/2009:  12:01:38


Great pics

youtube.com/fergohanlon

trapdoor2 - Posted - 10/16/2009:  18:26:18


quote:
Originally posted by pgroff

Hi Marc

Taking your point, I edited the topic title.

But if you still want to make good use of your post, I notice there are a few other topics that still have "Irish tenor" in their title :-)

I actually have some John McCormack records in my storage space, with leftover inventory from my former shop.
Ah...I just stuck that in there for fun, no need to edit the title.

I used to listen to a program on NPR called "The Record Shelf" by Jim Svejda...and he did one on "tenors" which completely blew my mind. I couldn't stand to be within a block (perhaps two, if they had the lungs) of an opera singer...now I can, esp. if it is a recording of Mr. McCormack's (and I have a small pile of his 78's).

I used to play IT banjo a good bit and keep the Bacon Blue Ribbon in "ready to go" IT condition. The Paramount Style A is set up for Dixieland. I have often wanted to try my hand at the button-box (and I have a nice Anglo Concertina) but I gots too many instruments already!

===Marc

"If banjos needed tone rings, S.S. Stewart would have made them that way."

NYCJazz - Posted - 10/17/2009:  15:01:18


quote:
Originally posted by trapdoor2
I gots too many instruments already!

===Marc



How is that possible?

pgroff - Posted - 10/17/2009:  22:38:10


Hi all,

I guess my point here is that Irish traditional music shouldn't be considered strictly "folk music played on whatever instruments are cheap," as has been suggested in some other recent topics here. There are many players of the music to whom that applies, as with many other musical idioms, but it is far from the whole story for Irish music.

Going back to the professional fiddlers and pipers of the 18th and 19th centuries (some of whom were blind, some who stayed in residence in certain towns, some who traveled a circuit, often with a professional dancing master), or even further back to the professional harpers.... and through to the professional Irish musicians of the American beerhalls, stages, dancehalls, and 78 recordings in the early 20th century, the ceili bands in 20th century Ireland, the showbands (with some trad content in their music), the professional "revivalists" and the "groups" of the 1970s through today:

There have always been traditional Irish musicians who invested heavily in the best instruments that could be made at the time, or sometimes who had instruments bestowed on them worth more than their career earning potential (such as Irish pipes).

Maloney's 19-fret Paramount in the photos I linked was a very valuable instrument and no doubt chosen over many others because of its ability to project, in competition with that accordion and piano. It's hard to say whether the banjo might possibly have been bought used at a bargain, during the Depression or later, but when it was made it was a pricey instrument. The accordion played by Bresnahan was definitely custom made for an Irish musician and cost hundreds of dollars when it was new (maybe 1928 - 1930?) .... a *lot* of money at that time. And those things are loud (I am lucky to have a very similar one). The banjo would literally struggle to be heard over one, as you can hear in some of P. J. Conlon's 78 recordings with piano and banjo.

PG




Edited by - pgroff on 10/17/2009 23:13:02

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)

Copyright 2026 Banjo Hangout. All Rights Reserved.





8.203125E-02