Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors

Banjo Lovers Online

Banjo Reviews

Review Categories

Most Recent

The banjo reviews database is here to help educate people before they purchase an instrument. Of course, this is not meant to be a substitute for playing the instrument yourself!

7071 reviews in the archive.

Silvertone: unknown

Submitted by GeoffB on 4/15/2011

Where Purchased: Ebay

Year Purchased: 2011
Price Paid: 99 ($US) (bought USED)


Remarkable. This is a classic cheap 1950-1960 catalog banjo at the basic entry level. Simple, plain, functional. Sounds like it looks. You wouldn't take this to a bluegraas gig but you'd be happy to play it with maybe a guitar and a mando player and do old fashioned quiet at home bluegrass or old time. Has a great clawhammer sound. Hollow, ringy, plunky and the wear on the Remo shows this is what its done a lot of.

Sound Rating: 8


No it wasn't set up at all. I asked the seller to take the neck off to ship from USA to me here in Australia in 2 pieces. Worked out cheaper. It went back together real easy and was strung up in 30 mins. then I discovered the Silvertone adjustable neck trick and fixed the action perfect in 2 mins. I've strung it with lightish strings - otherwise its all ariginal. Tuners work good. Original "no knot" sylr tailpiece. Old Grover bridge. Original brass frets. all good.

Setup Rating: 10


Easy on the eye - are you kidding? Unless you like the look of a battered & worn down cheap old 5 that's done hundreds of hours of picking . Anyone who wants something fancy would walk right by this 5 at a garage sale or an ebay sale.

Appearance Rating: 2


Everything on this 5 has lasted well past its use by date but it still does exactly what it's supposed to. Its a Silvertone, no more no less. It holds tuning. It plays. It sounds good. Even the Grover un-geared 5th peg works good. I grew up with those pegs and like 'em. I ain't about to change this one. Works fine!

Reliability Rating: 10

Customer Service


Customer Service: 5


Neck - black painted hardwood. Separate hardwood fretboard with plastic dots and brass frets. Straight. Good. Plays fine. Pot - unimaginably bad. Made of kind of particle composition material pressed together. A new one milled up out of hardwood would work fine, but this original one still works, so it stays! Resonator - basic - painted black with a kind of flower sil screened on the centre of the back. No ivoroid or pearl has ever been near this 5. Rest of hardware. Cheap & minimal.

Components Rating: 2

Overall Comments

I like it. Takes me back to my first 5 in the mid 1960's. Perfect for sitting on the porch with and plunking out a few notes. Excellent clawhammer machine. And I just played a nice melodic version of Monreoe's Old Daingerfield on it perfectly in tune all the way up the neck - so it can do anything. Must have been lots and lots of these 5's got good folks started on the road to fame and glory with 5 string playing. It isn't going to be taken out to gigs, unless to a worksho about 5's in general, but I couldn't be more pleased with it.

Overall Rating: 10

Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories