Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors

Banjo Lovers Online

Banjo Reviews

Review Categories

Most Recent

The banjo reviews database is here to help educate people before they purchase an instrument. Of course, this is not meant to be a substitute for playing the instrument yourself!

6953 reviews in the archive.

Pisgah: 12" Walnut Possum

Submitted by Big Ed on 5/28/2019

Where Purchased: Spruce Tree Music Madison, WI

Year Purchased: 2019
Price Paid: approx $1300 ($US)


Long time upright bass player, just getting into clawhammer. Looking to buy an instrument that will last me a long time.

I like a plunky tone. Loud enough, but not too loud. Like a spare, old-time sound - often play just banjo and fiddle. Very different sound in center of pot and over scoop. Mellow - but REALLY projects when I dig in. Will allow me to do whatever I wish as I grow into it.

I set a rough dollar range (under $1350), and was committed to buying the best sounding/feeling banjo in that range.

Being pretty much a beginner, it was a challenge to compare instruments, as my skills - and ability to repeat consistently - are limited.

Sound Rating: 10


Seller took this one out of the box - required minimal setup to how it came from the builder.

I had tried just about every 5-string openback under $1500 in the Chicago area. Headed to Spruce Tree in Madison, as they had the greatest variety in stock, to allow me to compare side-to-side.

Spruce Tree Music is an incredible store for anyone into acoustic instruments. Neat old building jampacked with banjos, fiddles, mandos, and guitars. Wonderful staff.

I told them what I was interested in, and they sat me down in a chair, surrounded me with maybe 4-5 instrument stands, and started pulling out instruments. As I rejected one, they'd whisk it away and place another banjo before me.

I think I tried banjos for some 3 hours - and I felt like I could've stayed another 3 if I wanted. Owner happily played them when asked to show what they sounded like when played by someone w/ skill.

Setup Rating: 10


Appearance is pretty much what made me end up with the Possum. I narrowed it down to 2 Pisgahs - the Possum, and a Rambler. Kept going back between which I liked better. And both were beautiful - in their own way. The spun over Rambler w/ side dots was much more "industrial" looking.

What decided me was my wife (who is a luthier) said, "That one's prettier - buy it!" I figured if she has to see it sitting in our living room, her opinion was worth something! ;) Plus, she told me to buy the pricier one!

The walnut pot is beautiful, with striking grain. The persimmon fingerboard has a couple of small knots - a look I really like. Just beautiful woodwork.

Appearance Rating: 10


Pegs seem rock solid, and hold tune very well. I brought it to my regular jam where at least 4 very accomplished pickers tried it out. All were EXTREMELY complimentary - and I LOVED how it sounded when they played it. This banjo is going to last me decades - and likely be handed down to my kids.

The aged brass and black tuning pegs are neat touches. Look VERY rich. I ordered a walnut armrest from Balsam.

Reliability Rating: 10

Customer Service

It is a real treat to deal with the owner of a small company like Pisgah, who is so committed to quality and customer service. He responded to my e-mails very promptly and thoroughly.

When I told him I had bought one, he invited me to stop by his shop if I were ever in the area.

Customer Service: 10


The Gotoh tuners are rock solid. All of the other hardware is made by Pisgah's partner/subsidiary Balsam Banjoworks.

Just nice to have an instrument that is entirely handmade in the US out of native wood.

Components Rating: 10

Overall Comments

There are several quality makers in the $1000-1350 range.  I played several very nice banjos, and had a hard time narrowing it down.  The fact that I narrowed it down to 2 Pisgahs says something about how their banjos appeal to me.  

If you like the look of wood, I think the Possum - and Pisgah's other models w/ wood fingerboards - really ought to be near the top of your list.  If you prefer black fingerboards and black/spun pots, you might prefer a different model/make.  For me, the sound and feel was the MOST important.  I feel this Possum gave me incredible appearance as well. 


Overall Rating: 10

Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories