Banjo Hangout Logo
Banjo Hangout Logo

Premier Sponsors

Banjo Lovers Online

Banjo Reviews

Review Categories

Most Recent

The banjo reviews database is here to help educate people before they purchase an instrument. Of course, this is not meant to be a substitute for playing the instrument yourself!

6919 reviews in the archive.

Gold Star  GF-11H Archtop Banjo Reviews

Submitted by DrBillM (see all reviews from this person) on 2/14/2014

Where Purchased: ebay

Year Purchased: 2014
Price Paid: (bought USED) historic exchange rates / currency converter


I was iffy on an archtop but wanted mahogany. Love it! Plays like a flathead but with a little pop/ attitude. Not as bright as my Maple Blossom- smoother. I haven't begun to tap its potential but I'm struck with how easy it plays. Pull offs are effortless and full. Major changes in tone/sustain with small shifts to and from the bridge. Near the bridge it will poke your eye out and each string seems to say "next!"

Sound Rating: 10


Came to me with older strings that played fine. Swapped them out and the sound rocketed. Snuffy Smith bridge and the original head. Low action and super fast neck. I have smallish hands and nothing is a stretch. May go from light to mediums to see what happens.

Settled on Siminoff Straight Up strings Lights. Great match!
Update: Bill Keith Lights are the way. Great low action. Snugged the head a touch and WOW. Tried a few other bridges and came back to the Snuffy

Setup Rating: 9


Pretty- classic- just enough fancy to keep you smiling.Mahogany is rich and looks right. Finish is great for a 33 year old banjo. All the metal has an aged patina- nothing blinding but a nice shine. The binding/purfling(?) etc is yellowed to a beautiful ivory color. H & F Inlays look like they should- no mother of toilet seat here. Tight and smooth.Added a banjomate wood arm rest. Love that.

Appearance Rating: 10


Made it this far! No concerns. A banjo that's broken in not broken down.

Reliability Rating: 10

Customer Service

No experience. I'll give them a gentleman's 8

Customer Service: 8


Nothing I can see.

Components Rating: 9

Overall Comments

Great banjo- A keeper.  Work horse. Plays great and didn't break the bank- I'll take good care of it but I don't have to worry who plays it or where. A banjo people won't be shy about asking to play. I expect it will draw a crowd and I'll enjoy passing it around. What more can you ask for?

Overall Rating: 10

Submitted by cdmiller (see all reviews from this person) on 4/14/2006

Where Purchased: Amazing Grace Music, San Anselmo, Ca

Year Purchased: 2006
Price Paid: 1300 ($US) (bought USED)


Loud, brassy, but clear with that killer Stanley sound, it just lights up with light pressure, great tone with minimal effort, though with light vega strings I can't wail on it too hard or it gets to buzzing-I with vega mediums, it is more mellow and no buzzing, but I am just geting to know it.

Sound Rating: 8


seems to be set up about perfect. John at Amazing Grace is a master-great resource, as I've picked his brain for useful bits. The action is low, the neck is fantastic and thin-better than any 60's-80's gibson I've played, but you can see the similarities. I has the original tailpiece and a grover bridge-i ain't sure if I will give in to the custom bridge hysteria just yet-but I'm tempted.

Setup Rating: 9


Its pretty, just real nice finish work all around. It has that solid heft and feel, a fine quality thats hard to describe. It just seems to stand apart from lesser banjos, I could never feel in love with the gold tones or similar rigs that I tried-this banjo feels like living wood

Appearance Rating: 9


everything is rock solid, stays in tune for days with constant playing-i'm suprised a that.

the only fly in the ointment is a hairline crack up the heel-several knowledgable folk have looked at it and said it fine and nothing to worry about. I'll keep an eye on it

Reliability Rating: 9

Customer Service

saga seems solid, but I haven't dealt with them, nor would expect to

Customer Service: not rated


all tuner and plating are top knotch, I assume they're original.
John threw in a new "golden gate" archtop case-this thing is so sweet, I'll never worry about the gold star when its packed away this snug.

Components Rating: 10

Overall Comments

I paid a fair amount, maybe more than I would expect, but I still feel that I couldn't have made a better choice-the banjo just spoke to me.
Its the banjo that I daydream about-it begs to be picked up. I like lifting it out of its case, or when it's weight settles down upon my shoulder.
I compared it to quite a few banjos, some costing five times the price of the Gold Star. I played Deerings, Wildwoods, a Tennessee, other older imports, a new gold star, and quite a few gibsons, new and old. While I was impressed with the gibson black jack and many others, the only ones I truly love cost well over $3500+...versus my little Gold Star, all worn in and beautiful for just over a grand with all sorts of stuff thrown in the bargain. Plus I was able to support my favorite independent old time music shop. 'nuff said.

Overall Rating: 10

Hangout Network Help

View All Topics  |  View Categories