Visit DAddario NY Steel Strings

 All Forums
 Other Banjo-Related Topics
 Shopping Advice
 Goodtime with EZ resonator vs. Goodtime 2

 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Print

 

 

briyo2289

United States
3 posts
since 9/23/14

06/18/2017 18:11:22 Reply with Quote

Howdy, the question is pretty self-explanatory.  I'm looking to upgrade from my awful mid-70s Korean made terrible junk banjo to a proper instrument without going broke.  I play both old time and bluegrass.  Is a good time 1 with an EZ resonator a good option or should I just go for the good time 2 and possibly remove the resonator for that frailing tone open-backs give you? 



Thanks!


Nashvolk5

United States
169 posts since 2/5/16

06/18/2017 18:39:52 View Nashvolk5's Classified Ads View Nashvolk5's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

In my honest opinion, the whole open-back thing is merely a cosmetic thing, and resonators don't really affect the tone, just increase the volume. But as far as a resonator goes, the GT 2 would give much more projection that the EZ Resonator would because of the full wall design and the flange. Also, you might want to consider the Goodtime Special 2 as well, as it has a tone ring.

Just my two cents.

Go to Top of Page

revellfa

United States
1780 posts since 9/25/06

06/18/2017 19:16:04View revellfa's MP3 Archive View revellfa's Classified Ads View revellfa's Photo Albums View revellfa's Blog Reply with Quote

I'd go for the EZ-resonator option if it were me. It makes it easier and you'll play it more that way. A goodtime banjo is a great banjo for all styles.

Go to Top of Page

BANJO TONY

United States
3517 posts since 9/24/03

06/19/2017 02:57:52 View BANJO TONY's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

Nash is right as far as tone goes but if you want more volume the EZ-resonator is a great little ad on to a goodtime open back. it looks like it was made for it, or should I say it looks like it belongs on the banjo. I have one on the back of a goodtime open back that I own & if you did not know you would swear it was made by the Deerings.

Go to Top of Page

AradobanjoPlayers Union Member

United States
2101 posts since 12/4/09

06/19/2017 03:20:18View Aradobanjo's MP3 Archive View Aradobanjo's Photo Albums View Aradobanjo's Blog Click to see Aradobanjo's MSN Messenger address Reply with Quote

Hello,

Resonators on banjos do not amplify sound. Amplification takes power and lots of it.  Resonators redirect sound. All wood colors sound when it is reflected. The same is true for the clothing we wear and our bodies. What does coloring mean? It means highs, mid ranges, and low frequencies are absorbed by the reflector. Hopefully, the tones we don't want to hear are the ones selected. That would be great. But, the reality is that both have equal opportunity to be absorbed. Some people see the resonator as making the banjo too bright by cancelling the lows. A sponge or sock placement can dampen high frequencies or filter the highs to allow the few lows to stand up. 

Only so much sound (a collection of many frequencies) are produced. What filters we use give us the sound we will like. 

Go to Top of Page

ildertongap

Canada
121 posts since 1/20/13

06/19/2017 08:54:08 View ildertongap's Blog Reply with Quote

As I was reading the thread a strange thought occurred to me( unfortunately not an infrequent event) . Since it is commonly suggested to put a towel in behind the head, why not simply cut a piece of towel to the same shape as the resonator and stick it to the inner surface of the resonator with some Velcro. Wouldn't that provide a more uniform dampening of the sound? Cheers. 

Go to Top of Page

Helix

United States
9934 posts since 8/30/06

06/21/2017 04:20:29 View Helix's Classified Ads View Helix's Photo Albums View Helix's Blog Reply with Quote

The banjos you mention are shallow, less productive. I jam regularly with all the brands, I'm more opinionated about it.

I think the banjo you have may accept upgrades easier and cheaper than just going for a factory banjo. Resonators are cheap. Some of us use magnet mount. You're a candidate.

a Mid-70's banjo has SOME features anyway. I play both old time and bluegrass, I frail and 3-finger, many times in the same song.

Go to Top of Page

briyo2289

United States
3 posts since 9/23/14

06/21/2017 05:07:40 Reply with Quote

Helix,
In thst case, can you recommend a good banjo around $600 or $700?

Go to Top of Page

bill t

United States
141 posts since 12/14/12

06/21/2017 05:48:36 Reply with Quote

So how well is your "awful mid-70s Korean made terrible junk banjo" set up? I wouldn't recommend spending
very much money upgrading it, but setting it up doesn't cost much if you do it yourself. The sound difference
between a well setup Korean banjo and a Goodtime may be minimal. Just my opinion.

Go to Top of Page

briyo2289

United States
3 posts since 9/23/14

06/21/2017 06:23:40 Reply with Quote

Bill,
I had it setup professionally a year or two ago and it made a noticeable difference. But tgmhe instrument is just in poor shape. It's beat up, the resonator is cracked, neck is not perfect due to many years of a loose truss rod, and before I oicked it up it had besn in my buddys basement for 30 years untouched.

The real reason I want a better banjo is Im moving to rural Wyoming soon. I expect I will lots of down time, Wyoming being so empty. I want to make practicing and playing as pleasant as possible. The banjo I have now just sounds bad,even when a really good picker has a hold of it.


Edited by - briyo2289 on 06/21/2017 06:24:17

Go to Top of Page

Paulf

Australia
2590 posts since 2/1/12

06/21/2017 15:15:19View Paulf's MP3 Archive View Paulf's Photo Albums Reply with Quote

quote:
Originally posted by revellfa
 

I'd go for the EZ-resonator option if it were me. It makes it easier and you'll play it more that way. A goodtime banjo is a great banjo for all styles.


Nothing wrong with a Goodtime especially when played by someone as talented as Mean Mary.

 

Go to Top of Page

Helix

United States
9934 posts since 8/30/06

06/21/2017 17:20:43 View Helix's Classified Ads View Helix's Photo Albums View Helix's Blog Reply with Quote

I can recommend looking at the Recording King market for that money. Also what is available used in the classified ads.  There is an Epiphone mastercraft for $500 that just listed today.  That's a shoe and plate banjo where you could remove the plate to use the banjo with rez or without. 


Edited by - Helix on 06/21/2017 17:26:45

Go to Top of Page

 

 

 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Print

Jump To:

Want to hide these Google ads? Join the Players Union!




You are not logged in.
Log In


Not a member? Create an Account (FREE!)



3060 BANJO LOVERS ONLINE

HOME | FORUMS | MEMBERS | MEDIA ARCHIVE | TABS & LESSONS | CLASSIFIEDS | REVIEWS | LINKS | CALENDAR | STORE | TERMS OF USE
Viewing desktop version - switch to mobile version