View raharris' Homepage
Read raharris' Bio
You must sign into your myHangout account in order to contact raharris.
raharris has made 99 recent additions to Banjo Hangout
Occupation: Information professional
Bart Reiter Professional, IR 5-string open back
Bacon Professional FF IR banjo mandolin, 1918
Doc Huff IR cello banjo
Bob Thornburg grain measure 5-string
Various mandolins and guitars
(In no particular order) Mike Seeger, Pete Seeger, Adam Hurt, Clarke Buehling, Cathy Fink, Abigail Washburn, Gillian Welch, Bruce Molsky, Dan Levenson, Bob Thornburg, Steve Baughman, The Carolina Chocolate Drops, Mike Marshall, Sarah Jarosz and all the others I'm forgetting right now.
Classified Rating: +3
Rate this Member
Visible to: Public
Last Visit 6/16/2013
Banjo playing woes
Monday, June 21, 2010 @6:48:15 AM
Lesson w/ Dan Levenson over the weekend. I practiced a number of tunes to impress him with then ended up playing none of them! He asked what I wanted to do so I mentioned a tune I'd tried to learn without success. Then I completely blanked on the tune. Anyway, I learned some about picking out a tune by ear on the banjo. When I picked up the mandolin I was picking out tunes by ear just about immediately. The mandolin just makes so much damn sense -- it's an *organized* instrument.
But desipite the fact that I am learning the mandolin more quickly and the fact that I can actually play the guitar, I still consider the banjo to be *my instrument.* That I really suck at it makes no matter. Irrational? Yeah, welcome to MY life! Dan corrected one element of how I hold the instrument, the element I realize now that made me put down the instrument and pick up the mando. Holding the banjo the way Dan suggests just hurts by shoulder too much.
So now I'm at an impasse -- between now any my shoulder replacement surgery I can:
1. Practice tunes holding the banjo the way Dan discourages, then when I've recovered move it into the correct position.
2. Practice tunes holding the banjo the right way but in very short spurts and with an increasing amount of pain
3. Put the banjos away -- losing a lot of what I've gained recently -- until I've recovered. Mid-September? I don't know - the surgeon doesn't play any instruments and has been very non-committal when I've asked him about it.
None of those options sound very encouraging. Still, I should be thankful that I can play at all, and that things will be much better in just a few months. Never get down! Always remember that it could be a lot worse, and will be a lot better.
on “Banjo playing woes”
Monday, June 21, 2010 @12:18:09 PM
I hope the pain goes away soon. If I were you, I'd go for the more comfortable choice No. 1. I've been e-mailing Dan about a possible lesson next month.
Tuesday, June 22, 2010 @5:46:49 AM
Hi Viper -- FWIW I agree about #1. I don't want to put them away and don't need more pain. I know what Dan suggests and can switch when it is feasible.
About Dan, I caught him when he was pretty much out the door for two months of traveling. He has Clawcamp in late July and my impression was that he was going to be on the road between now and then. But write him -- he's very amenable and you might be able to work something out.
Tuesday, June 22, 2010 @6:08:55 AM
Thanks for the suggestion. I've already been in contact with him by e-mail. Since I'm in Ohio, his coming for Clawcamp works out for me. He said he might have some time in the weeks before.
Hope the playing is pain-free.
Tuesday, June 22, 2010 @9:33:33 AM
I had shoulder surgery in May and am just now able to start picking again, almost pain free. You will not forget all that you have learned. I believe it will come back to you. Take care and take care of that shoulder!
|Bill Rogers Says:|
Sunday, July 04, 2010 @10:19:00 PM
There's shoulder surgery and there's shoulder surgery. I had my left one scoped and was playing almost immediately. Walt Koken told me he had his right one scoped and played that night(!). Said it hurt, but he could play. Replacement surgery will be a whole 'nother deal. I'd go with comfort when you play though. Dan's position doesn't work for all.
Monday, July 05, 2010 @7:56:37 AM
Thanks Banjosis -- you're right, of course. When I picked the banjos up after laying them down for a while I had half an hour of aligning right and left hands, but once I overcame that I was back in the saddle!
Monday, July 05, 2010 @8:05:28 AM
Hi Bill -- yeah, shoulder replacement is a whole 'nother thing. When I told my rheumatologist that I'd agreed to replacement I told her with some bravado that I wasn't worried because I'd come through the hip replacement so well. She shook her head and told me to buckle my belt - It'd be a bumpy ride! Since I originally wrote that I've circulated a week with each instrument. The triple ought guitar is much easier on the shoulder than my beloved dreadnought. As for the banjo, I have a new friend around these parts who holds the banjo in the Levenson style, so I think I'll try to stick with that. I'm putting a pillow on my thigh to hike the pot up to a position that is easier on the shoulder. And the surgeon? He thinks I'm nuts. "Why play anything?", he asks "read a book!"
You must sign into your myHangout account before you can post comments.
raharris' Blog Archive