|
Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link.
rexhunt - Posted - 03/24/2012: 04:36:17
I had one years ago. It's still around here someplace but hasn't been on a banjo in a long time. It's way too heavy and the compensation isn't really that great either. I believe it was that bridge that Roger Siminoff had in mind when he said something like "by their very nature, compensated bridges can never sound as good as a standard bridge". The Hatfield compensated bridge is much better as is the design used on the Snuffy Smith compensated bridges and others.
Rex
desert rose - Posted - 03/24/2012: 04:47:39
Hands down the most consistantly BAD sounding bridge made
Scott
David Cunningham - Posted - 03/24/2012: 04:58:31
I opted for one a little different from that. The price was a bit higher - a couple hours of my time. But I think it was worth it.
 
Edited by - David Cunningham on 03/24/2012 05:00:03
Fathand - Posted - 03/24/2012: 05:27:20
I had one for years on my Ball Bearing, the intonation worked well for me but it sure brightened up when I changed it.
ltjgcag - Posted - 03/24/2012: 05:42:12
I switched from that bridge to one from Steve Davis. Liked it so much I ordered another one for the latest banjo and sent to the builder to put on straight up on my latest build.
eagleisland - Posted - 03/24/2012: 05:50:38
One of those was on my Ode 2SR when I bought it. That particular banjo does better with a straight bridge.
Dead Reckon - Posted - 03/24/2012: 06:19:03
I tried one of those bridges, and as well as compensated, I found the sound constipated! Five minutes on the snag grinder and a lot of excess wood quickly removed and they look like this. Sound much better but not quite on par with a quality bridge. If you have one lying around that is gathering dust give this exercise a try. It will amaze you the difference in sound before and after!
Mumble Peg - Posted - 03/24/2012: 07:26:05
Bart Veerman, bridge maker extraordinaire, has a system where you measure the string length for each individual string and for your specific banjo. He will then custom make a compensated bridge that really works. It's just not necessarily interchangeable with another banjo.
banjobridge.com/
banjodad - Posted - 03/24/2012: 08:02:10
I have one on my AT-TT. I'm good with it. The banjo has a bright sound to begin with, perhaps I like it because it tones the whole machine down a bit.
scooter46 - Posted - 03/24/2012: 08:15:23
I've never bought one from StewMac but it's identical to a Grover I have, there are a lot better bridges out there, but if you need a cheap compensated bridge it will work.
wuzapicker - Posted - 03/24/2012: 19:50:22
I remember when they were introduced. I was in the 5th String store in Berkely California. The package had the name Shubb like the capo, so I think he was the inventor. I bought one and used it for about a month. I replaced it and never looked back.
A local picker started making a better one by bending standard Grover bridges over a hot iron. The angle of the bend matched Shubb's angle. The bridges were marked by a distinctive burn where the wood met the iron. I must say the bent bridge worked as well to correct intonation. Being no heavier than a standard Grover, it didn't kill the tone like the Shubb.
Now I use straight bridges.
mikehalloran - Posted - 03/24/2012: 20:11:52
The Shubb and the Grover were not identical. Elderly sold an ebony mute that fit one and not the other. I still have a Grover or two lying about - none are on my banjos anymore - still have the mute, too but have no idea where it is (sitting in a case, no doubt).
I didn't think they sounded so bad but, when I went to a wound third, they became useless to me.
|