|
Please note this is an archived topic, so it is locked and unable to be replied to. You may, however, start a new topic and refer to this topic with a link.
uncle.fogey - Posted - 09/06/2010: 05:58:57
Is anybody familiar with the Grizzly 2-way truss rods? grizzly.com/products/H6031
Grizzly is right down the road from me, and I use a lot of their stuff. I use electric bass truss rods for longneck banjos. I have been using hot-rods, which are cumbersome. I am thinking of trying one of these Grizzly ones, and wonder if someone on the hangout has had experience with them. In their catalog, they say they would be are adjustable from inside a guitar, but I would imagine they would also work with the adjustment nut at the fingerboard end.
desert rose - Posted - 09/06/2010: 08:17:16
Hi Ken
Of course they work, they are an adaptation of the rod used by Ibanez. They are available from numerous Korean parts suppliers with an endless variety of nuts at the adjustment end
Their Achilese (sp) heel is the fact they are welded front and back, and I cant count the quantity of rods Ive seen that have failed at one weld joint. When that happens you have PROBLEMS. For the most part you have a replacement free neck due to whoever owns the instrument
Scott
uncle.fogey - Posted - 09/06/2010: 09:51:16
Thanks, Scott,
That's good info. The last thing I would want to do is to have a weld break on one of those things.
They aren't anchored like a tension rod, I wonder if you could pull them out if that happened?
Frisco Fred - Posted - 09/06/2010: 10:13:20
Ken,
I think you can make a better one yourself.
John
desert rose - Posted - 09/06/2010: 10:14:21
A number of years ago when I was doing QC at Fujigen we were making an annaversary JEM model electric guitar. Retail about $2500
I picked up one and it was a bit back bowed. I flexed the neck in my hands like Ive done for thirty five years and heard a very loud BAM
When I sighted the neck it was extremely bowed in the opposite direction. The read weld failed. Out of fourty guitars that day fifteen rods broke when I flexed the neck!!! A whole lot of bad rods. We returned the rest immediately to the Korean maker
Problem with removing the rods is you usually do something to the rod to muffle it inside the neck, or just make a good snug fit, both of these situations make removal all but impossible. If it could be removed easily it most likely would rattle
Ibanez used thousands of these rods, or something similar actually, same construction and of course the vast majority are fine
But if you get some bad ones, to a small maker it could ruin you
Ive found nothing even close to the hot rod for function and reliability. the new ones dont even have the brased nut any more its pinned on so it cant break
If you want to say you COULD make a good rod personally, of course you COULD, but why, the best consistancy comes from people who specialize in doing this no question. Good materials supplier, expensive welding equipment, precision tapping etc. My time is worth more than wasting it on making truss rods. Ive made MANY so Im speaking from experience
Scott
Edited by - desert rose on 09/06/2010 10:18:22
uncle.fogey - Posted - 09/06/2010: 13:32:13
Thanks, Scott.
I certainly don't want to mess around with a longneck and I don't want to start making truss rods. I think the good old hot rod is looking better all the time. The big danger with longnecks is twisting. What I have been doing is using an electric bass hot-rod flanked by two carbon fiber strips to prevent twisting, and this works. As you can imagine, an electric bass hot-rod in a banjo neck makes you want to sing "this nine-pound-hammer is a little too heavy". BUT, I don't want something to go bang when I bend it!!!
One last thought. For normal length banjos, I have been using Gotoh rods, which are an up-and-down truss rod inside a 3/8" x 3/8" U-channel, not unlike the old Martin steel tubes. This is fully adjustable and prevents twisting.

Are these available in an electric bass length?
|